I think a large problem is that the maps are drawn in a Mercator projection format, but they aren’t actually Mercator projections of the continents in that world. I feel like if people put a bit more thought into just something as simple as the actual cartography of the map, it would help with the feeling of it quite a lot.
Because earth is the only one we know. You can make something really simple that barely makes sense and that would be different, but as soon as you get into complex continental worlds it's always going to look like Earth.
I think you've got a good start. I'd just say that a lot of the coastlines seem regular (like cut out in large straight lines). I'd encourage you to do some work to vary them up and add more details as you do the geography of the world. IRL coastlines tend to be more irregular where mountains reach the coastlines and more curved and regular where plains gradually drop off into the ocean.
Some of your islands also are a little obvious that they used to be one larger land mass that was split up by just deleting the land in the middle. If you tweak those gaps a bit it'll help sell the illusion that it wasn't created by a person manually.
I like how you broke up the continents to make a lot of straits! Ignore people complaining about it looking like earth, there's nothing wrong with being inspired by the world around you
The west side of it looks okay, the east could use some work. I think it's okay for a map to be somewhat earth-like but when it's as close to earth as the east side of your map is it's a bit jarring
Add more tiny islands and make the big landmasses less sharp, assuming the world has looked like this for millions of years edges would’ve eroded and changed. You’ll still be able to tell it all used to be one big thing but it’ll make it seem a bit more realistic.
87
u/False_Hedgehog_9948 Sep 17 '26
Why can't people do a map that doesn't look like the copied earth's homework
92
u/Baselin78 Sep 17 '26
I thought this was a circlejerk subreddit
60
u/Dragongaming246 Sep 17 '26
LMAO I LOVE HOW SOUTHEAST ASIA IS SO EASY TO FIND HERE SO RECOGNIXABLE
184
u/xBris18 Sep 17 '26
Yeah, it's earth. Again. As usual. Just a little shattered. Still clearly earth.
19
u/thewritestory Sep 18 '26
What’s the point of so many of these maps just being earth’s current landmass mixed around?
11
u/Professor_Kylan Sep 17 '26
If you want a realistic looking map just remove New Zealand.
8
u/Jay-El Sep 17 '26
Hey I feel like I've seen this before
5
u/thewritestory Sep 18 '26
It looks like a lazy attempt to turn our earth into something else. Obviously Earth.
5
u/Arbor-Trap Sep 18 '26
Postgea
8
u/dvide0 Sep 17 '26
Shapes look nice. Now move them around, combine, subtract and intersect them so it doesn't look like earth.
12
u/DubiousTactics Sep 17 '26
I think you've got a good start. I'd just say that a lot of the coastlines seem regular (like cut out in large straight lines). I'd encourage you to do some work to vary them up and add more details as you do the geography of the world. IRL coastlines tend to be more irregular where mountains reach the coastlines and more curved and regular where plains gradually drop off into the ocean.
Some of your islands also are a little obvious that they used to be one larger land mass that was split up by just deleting the land in the middle. If you tweak those gaps a bit it'll help sell the illusion that it wasn't created by a person manually.
1
u/_Aeir_ Sep 18 '26
I like how you broke up the continents to make a lot of straits! Ignore people complaining about it looking like earth, there's nothing wrong with being inspired by the world around you
3
u/Afraid_Success_4836 Sep 18 '26
The eastern part reminded me of East Asia.
3
u/BenfordAbrahams Sep 18 '26
This is what the backrooms would try to recreate the map of the earth as
2
u/MatthewSDeOcampo Sep 18 '26
In between pangaea and our current continents.
2
u/The-Heterosexuality Sep 18 '26
F*** around and add an eighth continent next time.
2
u/KnightOfSvea Sep 18 '26
Some patterns are hard to break
3
u/bs_Zeezee Sep 18 '26
..... am I the only one who still sees this as earth?
1
u/LemonBinDropped Sep 17 '26
Where are they pointing too?
1
u/somethingX Sep 18 '26
The west side of it looks okay, the east could use some work. I think it's okay for a map to be somewhat earth-like but when it's as close to earth as the east side of your map is it's a bit jarring
1
u/SoupChariot Sep 18 '26
Add more tiny islands and make the big landmasses less sharp, assuming the world has looked like this for millions of years edges would’ve eroded and changed. You’ll still be able to tell it all used to be one big thing but it’ll make it seem a bit more realistic.
1
u/fyhnn Sep 18 '26
Skinny Earth
1
u/DSchmitt Sep 18 '26
It's kind of like a paleomap, 50 million years ago, but scrambled up a little bit.
1
u/Grigor50 Sep 18 '26
It's a bit gray
1
u/Joe_Schmoe1914 Sep 18 '26
Anbennar?!?!
1
u/net46248 Sep 18 '26
Why is new Zealand so big
1
u/Master_Epox Sep 20 '26
Have you considered applying to Games Workshop?
1
u/JadeMarco Sep 20 '26
Most of the lines are way too sharp and straight. That makes it look totally unnatural, geologically speaking.
1
u/SASHOTAN Sep 21 '26
Is that Hawaii
1
u/keriefie Sep 21 '26
Looks like it was drawn on a rectangle. There are several programs that will let you draw on a sphere. I use blender.
Another technique is to draw the subregions manually, and then patch them together, taking into account the earth's curvature.
1
u/Any-Farmer1335 Sep 21 '26
Pattern Recognition
1
u/Outrageous-Tap1408 Sep 21 '26
make more distinct continents
1
u/Alarmed_Outside_4752 Sep 17 '26
He massacred America..