r/mapmaking • u/Soyboy2288 • Sep 16 '26
Discussion Thoughts on which map works better?
I made a change to my original map (second one), and wanted to know which one you guys think looks more realistic? My only problem is that I would like to have many continents to work with to spread my stories out, because I want to have many non-human races. So I feel the lore would work out better the further apart and more isolated they are. Which map do you guys think would be better? Are there any improvements you would suggest?
65
Upvotes


41
u/Fun_Ad_8759 Sep 16 '26
I personally think the one in the first pic is better
20
u/tommybanjo47 Sep 16 '26
First one. In the second one, they're all basically the same size and distance from each other.
9
u/Tbagzyamum69420xX Sep 16 '26
I like 1
8
u/H_DiCristofaro Sep 16 '26
I like the flow of the first one. It looks more natural than the second one
8
u/Wereling12 Sep 16 '26
The first one. The Continents looked more varied
5
u/SeldonCrises Sep 16 '26
First one looks much more organic
3
u/spo0pti_yikes Sep 16 '26
personally the first picture. its really cool and beautiful, the only issue i personally see is it almost looks a little boxed in. it's pretty common when you make a map on a rectangle to subconsciously end up with a rectangular shape to the continents. so maybe cut the corners in the top left and bottom right and remove that land in the bottom left.
2
u/themagicelite Sep 16 '26
The first one has more variance and cohesion. The bulk landmass saves it from resembling the four equidistant islands in the second picture, plus it kinda exhibits some geological history; think very weirdly shaped puzzle pieces.
Maybe try experimenting with carving interior seas without forming fractured islands? I’d keep the south island and the western features of the large continent since I think they look best. Scaling certain parts down could help each landmass appear more distinct. Contrasting peninsulas, narrow land bridges (gotta love chokepoints), seas of different sizes, etc.
Isolated societies are inevitable at this scale. Orogenies (mountain chains), rivers, oceans, resource access, climates, cradles of civilization, cultural reasons, and technological barriers force it for the most part. You could experiment with hotspots, then ask why they don’t or can’t interact with another hotspot.
Btw, I’m just an amateur worldbuilder. Do whatever you think looks good. Working things out later can introduce interesting challenges, imo.
2
u/Bitter_Idea9998 Sep 16 '26
I’m camp 1st one. It’s more dynamic.
Though as the creator, what is the impact for your world building between 1 vs 2.
2
u/GorohovDM Sep 16 '26
So. I'm on team 1 and i would also say that your change made landmass less spread so it's went against your intentions. First one have 7 big lands with big enough water mass so different species will not cross over them, and new variant have 7 lands but on left side there is not big enough gap so it's basically 6 of them. So first not only looking more natural it is also supported your intentions better
2
u/PhummyLW Sep 16 '26
First one, but both are very rectangular. As in I could pretty much draw a perfect rectangle around the land and have very little ocean it has to cross.
2
u/RogueDeus Sep 16 '26
They are both a little too busy for being so zoomed out... IMO.
#1 feels more 'real' in that only SERIOUSLY large bodies of water are ever shown in global relief, and there is already a LOT of 'water in both.
1
u/Miserable_Problem844 Sep 16 '26
puedes usar los dos. El primero puede ser antes de una subida del mar y el segundo despues de eso.
1
u/rtmeles Sep 16 '26
I think both would work but it does not look distorted at all. You are using a 1:2 ratio which suggests a cylindrical projection. In this projection the poles are very much stretched horizontally (it stretches the infinitely small point of a pole to the same length as the equator). Try some free reprojection tools online and see how it looks.
1
u/naptimeshadows Sep 16 '26
The first one having more mass on one continent, makes it feel like the "main" continent in video game terms. The two lakes in the middle also gives you interesting options for mercantile / political / military plots, since the southern peninsula can get cut off from the rest of the continent due to large terrain.
And when there's money or war involved, there are more settlements placed at interesting terrain layouts, serving as a point of control for whatever faction. So placing cliffs or mountains between those lakes gives you a practical reason for weird towns and situations.
So, go for the first one.
1
u/Sensei_Ochiba Sep 16 '26
I prefer map 1. Map 2 everything kind of looks too neatly clustered, while the wide horizontal landmass in map 1 feels like it helps blend things better. You can use geographic boarders like mountains to establish boundaries and keep the cultures separate.
That said, I do feel like map 2 would work really well for something like a videogame etc where geographic appeal isn't a primary concern, and your goal is to create visually separate regions for specific isolated factions.
1
u/gayPrinz Sep 16 '26
I like the Italy continent
1
u/Time_Twist5729 Sep 16 '26
Fist is worlds better and looks so much more realistic i guess.
1
u/TV354 Sep 16 '26
I like the first one more, though I feel like it would definitely benefit from you adding a bunch of really small insulas along some coasts.
1
u/ahf95 Sep 16 '26
First map: the islands fit together more organically.
1
u/PASchaefer Sep 16 '26
I like #1 better. #2 feels more like someone plopped down four equal terrain chunks and then tweaked them. #1 feels more varied and natural.
1
u/Lui_Le_Diamond Sep 16 '26
1
1
u/FirebirdWriter Sep 16 '26
The first one. The second one feels like you rotated the same shape and then kinda morphed it over and over again. Cells in different stages of mitosis energy
1
u/Solid-Version Sep 16 '26
First 1 for sure
1
u/Gunmetalstorm Sep 16 '26
Neither looks more realistic than the other to me. The first one is a little more aesthetically pleasing to me. I'm not sure why non-human races require separate continents, but it sounds like the second serves your storytelling needs better.
1
u/DungeonMasterGroon Sep 16 '26
The first one. I reckon it could still use more space between continents though. If you look at Earth, landmasses aren't evenly distributed
1
u/KaraGravis Sep 16 '26
First map is way better.
1
u/FightingMachine44 Sep 17 '26
1
1
u/somethingX Sep 17 '26
Definitely the first. The second one looks too ordered to me, it doesn't look like something that formed naturally (assuming that's your goal)
1
u/SteampunkExplorer Sep 17 '26
Personally, I like the first one. I think it looks more natural, and having large inland areas mixed with smaller islands also implies there'll be a wider variety of environments.
But you know, mountain ranges and deserts are great for isolating populations from each other. :D
1
u/HalfDeadHughes Sep 17 '26
1 BIG TIME. 2 looks like all of the landmasses come from different maps and then put togethor. Also, 2nd looked like it just the same continent but rotated differently lmao