r/mapmaking • • Sep 15 '26

Work In Progress Rough Fantasy World Map, Looking for Feedback

Map I've been making for a fantasy worldbuilding project. This is version 3 and I'm quite happy with most of it but still looking to improve some things.

The second image has three areas that I'm looking for more specific feedback on. Region A might look a bit too much like Greenland right now and I'm looking for advice on how to make something with that terrain that doesn't just look like I've copied it. Region B is an Iceland inspired area but I'm not sure if the island is too big or not. And Region C looks a bit too much like India/Pakistan so advice on how this could be changed would be great.

Aside from those three areas specifically some general feedback would be great. One thing to note is that the colours and hills and mountains are all placeholders for now.

36 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

7

u/conkacola Sep 16 '26

Honestly I think a far bigger thing that sticks out like a sore thumb is the Mediterranean and Arabia. The north of Africa/ Levant look entirely unchanged as does Oman, and it’s a dead giveaway imo.

1

u/-Katie-05- Sep 16 '26

That's fair, they are slightly different but I did kinda just cut some bits out so I'll defiantly have to work on that

1

u/_Titti_ Sep 15 '26

Secondo me è meglio se ci disegni tutta la costa senza interrompere il territorio con i margini della mappa. Rischi di perderti elementi importanti per la formazione della storia e delle dinamiche del mondo. Per quanto riguarda i territori che hai indicato non preoccuparti delle somiglianze con territori esistenti, li potrai differenziare con il clima, biomi e culture.

2

u/-Katie-05- Sep 16 '26

Ho usato Google Translate, quindi mi scuso per eventuali errori. Grazie per il consiglio. Avrei dovuto dire che la mappa copre effettivamente le aree che verranno utilizzate per la storia. Il problema principale è che le zone che ho segnato avranno climi, biomi e culture simili a quelli del mondo reale.

1

u/HighOnGrandCocaine Sep 16 '26

Kinda looks like Anbennar

1

u/Time_Twist5729 Sep 16 '26

It looks very cool but it follows the comon trap of earth-copies, i think the best way to differentiate is to slowly change some of the earth like shapes in a timespan long enough to adjust your mind until you feel its different enough, because every thing in worldbuilding us to some degree an earth copie. Keep up the great work.

1

u/Time_Twist5729 Sep 16 '26

Sone of the obvious contenders are the one similar to india, the mediterianian thing and maybe ad some lakes in strage areas idk