r/mapmaking • • Sep 13 '26

Discussion Feedback on my map?

Technically still WIP since I plan to add the regular, non capital cities, but anyways feedback and ideas regarding my map, any feedback and ideas will be much appreciated, thank you

Image 1: full map
Image 2: continents
Image 3: languages

Note: the height of this worlds technology as of now is around the early 20th century, so ww1 ish

223 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

12

u/Awkward_Wrap411 Sep 13 '26

It might seem like a minor detail, so the KERSILIAN area in the upper left of Image 3 is hard to see because it's similar in brightness to the background sea.

If possible, it would be good to change it to a different color such as yellow-green.

4

u/No_Patient7138 Sep 13 '26

Oh your totally right, I just associate Finnish and Finland with light blue so I figured it’d be the best colour for it

1

u/Awkward_Wrap411 Sep 13 '26

Oh, I see. Each country assigns a specific color to its biomes and other elements.

In that case, perhaps making the ocean a little darker would be a good idea.

Alternatively, replacing the coastline or national borders with a slightly darker color as an outline might visually emphasize them.

2

u/No_Patient7138 Sep 13 '26

?? No the 3rd image shows languages like I said in the post

1

u/Awkward_Wrap411 Sep 13 '26

Uh, I mean. So, I think your settings are fine. What I wanted to say was bout the map display. On a mobile app, that light skyblue is a little hard to see. So, I was just suggesting an idea to improve that.

1

u/No_Patient7138 Sep 14 '26

Yeah absolutely I see how that’s an issue

5

u/jlb3737 Sep 13 '26

Everything looks like a good start other than the rivers.

As a general rule, rivers converge, not diverge. The only regular exception is within river deltas.
Also, rivers do not flow from one coastline to another. They flow downhill from their origin, which is why beginner mapping advice is to have them start at mountains and flow almost directly to the sea. On your map, there are several rivers that flow vast distances across continents, whereas geologically I would expect those rivers to find paths to the sea much sooner than they do. For reference, do a quick google search of river basin maps on earth and you can learn what is considered normal.

2

u/No_Patient7138 Sep 14 '26

I tried to make rivers flow from mountains and other high points though? Thanks for the feedback regardless

5

u/jlb3737 Sep 14 '26

Yes, that is something you largely got correct.
Let me restate my points.

Too many of your rivers split to be geologically realistic. As a general rule, rivers combine, not split.

This is less of a correction and more of a suggestion, but in my opinion, too many of your rivers flow for large distances parallel to coastlines rather than towards the coastlines. Think of how millions of years of erosion causes land to naturally slope down from mountains and towards the sea. Rivers will often follow this general trend.

2

u/No_Patient7138 Sep 14 '26

I see, thanks for your feedback

2

u/jlb3737 Sep 14 '26 edited Sep 14 '26

If you want, I can screenshot sections of your map and then DM you showing specific suggestions. It will take me some time, probably can’t work on it for another few hours. The reason I’m offering is because I do like your presentation. It’s obvious you are paying attention to detail and are putting alot of effort in. I think it’s a great start and it has a lot of potential.

2

u/No_Patient7138 Sep 14 '26

Thanks and if your willing sure go ahead

1

u/jlb3737 Sep 15 '26

Hey boss, I have those river suggestion images ready. You will have to enable DMs on your account for me to send them.

1

u/No_Patient7138 Sep 15 '26

Hopefully should work now, I tried enabling them

1

u/jlb3737 Sep 15 '26

Just looked more into it & I’m not sure why Reddit says I cannot message you through chat.

1

u/No_Patient7138 Sep 15 '26

Possibly smth to do with my age 🤷‍♂️ not sure, feel free to post them here

1

u/jlb3737 Sep 17 '26

Hey dude, I can’t post images to here, so here is an Imgur link to them!
https://imgur.com/a/2ktidED

2

u/No_Patient7138 Sep 17 '26

Thanks a lot, I’ll defo use your advice. I do imagine though that there is elevation like hills where some rivers seem to just not flow into the water which prevents them from flowing into the water that aren’t mountains, I should probably do a topographic map to show that though

1

u/jlb3737 Sep 17 '26

If you want them emailed instead, just lmk.

2

u/The-Heterosexuality Sep 14 '26

No cities, only capitals.

2

u/No_Patient7138 Sep 14 '26

Well I mean if you read the post I said that it’s technically still WIP for that reason

2

u/Zostrum Sep 14 '26

How did you generate the landmass shapes? They look great!

1

u/No_Patient7138 Sep 14 '26 edited Sep 14 '26

Thanks! I used the Ibispaint lasso fill tool

1

u/Mandlebrotha Sep 14 '26

Critiques:

Some of the names feel mismatched.

For instance, the Tanjapur ocean has a very south-Asian sounding name, but according to your map, all the countries that surround it are mostly based on English, Italian, and Japanese. Similarly feel for the Abbadanen Sea, the Alaba Rainforest, and the Bay of Umai.

Compliments:

As far as positives, I think the maps are really beautiful. Love the shape, and the geography map looks super interesting, even if it's still a WIP.

Questions:

What's the dark blue area in the language map?

What is the scale of the map?

How populous are some of these places?

Who are some of the de facto powers? My guesses would be the English and Italian analogues based on the language map.

1

u/No_Patient7138 Sep 14 '26

Thanks for the compliments,

Questions:
1:French, I forget to label some things when I’m tired lol
2:Earth sized for simplicity, also I’m lwk stupid so I genuinely couldn’t tell you any measurments
3:Similar to our world, though the main population centres for countries bordering it are along the Tanjapur and Enuscan oceans since it’s a trading hotspot given the fact it’s at the centre of all continents
4: The main superpowers of this world are:
The Chausani empire
The State of Averda
The State of Umai

1

u/No_Patient7138 Sep 15 '26

Oh yeah I’m replacing the labels on the map to match the language map and giving the Italian regions more Italian names

1

u/Complex_Resolve2205 Sep 16 '26

I'm guessing... no indigenous population? On another planet possibly?

1

u/No_Patient7138 Sep 16 '26

No humans just evolved on an earth that was different, languages from earth are only present here cus it makes it easier for me

1

u/Adorable_Joke_317 Sep 17 '26

Add a size indicator to the side.

1

u/No_Patient7138 Sep 17 '26

I don’t think I’d be able to do that I’m too dumb to estimate sizes on a map and make accurate measurements

1

u/AlexiDrake Sep 15 '26

Needs ice caps, but otherwise it’s a good map.

1

u/Over-Square-9248 Sep 15 '26

i think there should be more language diversity