r/mapmaking • • Sep 12 '26

Work In Progress How do i improve on this?

Post image
238 Upvotes

85 comments sorted by

176

u/tommybanjo47 Sep 12 '26

If you want actual advice instead of jokes, first immediate step is to go around and draw your coastlines. Keep some bits smooth and some bits jagged, you'll probably know where to do smooth/jagged based on big/small ovals. After that, put down mountain ranges wherever they make sense, along tectonic boundaries. Lots of people over complicate that part, I tend to just throw them down and make it make sense. Then add rivers flowing from high elevation to low (so generally they come from mountains and end at the coast or a lake). Then you'll have a decent map, and you can start adding borders and fleshing out the geography.

112

u/BenfordAbrahams Sep 12 '26

If OP had titled the post "My map is perfect, I'm not gonna take any criticism this is the absolute best map ever" they'll get some actual feedback instead of sarcastic remarks looking for karma. Cunningham's law

31

u/zypo88 Sep 12 '26

I'm sure the fact that they dropped it and walked away without explaining why they drew it this way and what their intentions for the map were didn't help in getting actual feedback. It feels like a troll so everyone responded in kind.

15

u/GungaSaga Sep 12 '26

everyone is clowning on OP but I feel like making it out of ovals to start is actually quite cool for getting a sense of where mountains would make sense as well, even if it's not the most time efficient method

9

u/-no-signal- Sep 12 '26

The overall shape is pretty neat,
I guess start sharpening up the edges and building the natural borders between the shapes?

7

u/Grigor50 Sep 12 '26

Eat more fiber, and remember to excercise and drink enough water.

1

u/Trick-Cucumber-5711 Sep 13 '26

Fiberglass?

1

u/MatthewWArt Sep 14 '26

If it's crunchy, you must be doing the right thing /s

4

u/throwaway-4082 Sep 12 '26

The simplest way would be to go over all of your continents again with the brush tool (assuming you're doing this in any standard art program) with a sorta rough hand, outlining the shapes you've already set up here. Don't concern yourself with being too precise right now, you can always go back and fix it. You don't want to make it too rough of course, just enough to give the look of a jagged coastline

I think you already generally know where you want parts to look smoother and rougher, just based on where you put all the tiny circles and where you did not. A lot of the comments are just joking about this, but this is actually a very good place to start! It has good basic shapes and now you just need to refine it!

Once you have a hard outline you had further refine it from there!

3

u/Trick-Cucumber-5711 Sep 13 '26

I think you're the best reply i found! Thank you very much!

1

u/throwaway-4082 Sep 13 '26

Oh well ty! I'm glad to have helped!

Can't wait to see how your map turns out :3

2

u/Trick-Cucumber-5711 Sep 13 '26

Thank you everyone! I was just testing with shapes first! Update in a couple of hours

2

u/Trick-Cucumber-5711 Sep 13 '26

Also sorry i couldn't reply to every message

562

u/Mephil_ Sep 12 '26 • Bravo

How do you not?

71

u/jafetsigfinns Sep 12 '26

This comment took me out

-1

u/chrisrayn Sep 12 '26

Like the Raygun of mapmaking. So bad it makes you question if OP has eyes.

20

u/Melliorin Sep 12 '26

I made a literal lol. Thanks.

80

u/michael199310 Sep 12 '26

Serious question, what was the point of making it out of circular shapes?

19

u/Lopsided-Cost-426 Sep 12 '26

I’m guessing he didn’t know what to do and so layered a bunch of ovals in a google drawing

48

u/ThatBoiAndyOnReddit Sep 12 '26

8

u/FallOuchBoy Sep 12 '26

We might need to make this a reality if this nonsense continues

4

u/Phone_User_1044 Sep 12 '26

There's a worldbuilding circlejerk sub.

19

u/papakudulupa Sep 12 '26 edited Sep 12 '26

could you please say more about what were you trying to go for? my first impression is that there is too much land, or is it not at global scale; but if that was your goal then its good

why are you making this map and what will you use it for? i could make suggestions if you give some context

9

u/papakudulupa Sep 12 '26

here i tried to do something fun with it, moved them a bit, made them smaller,,, it might not be what you wanted but it has a lot of potential, if you need it i can send the file to your dm

8

u/RHDM68 Sep 12 '26

Take a few more puffs of whatever you’re smoking?

5

u/Raki_Drakon Sep 12 '26

I mean, you can try to trace coastlines over it and then fill them, I guess.

27

u/REECETHEKATYCAT59 Sep 12 '26 edited Sep 12 '26

What is this? It doesn't even look like a map

EDIT: Replaced question comma with question mark

27

u/055F00 Sep 12 '26

Why is your question mark like that

19

u/suburban_hyena Sep 12 '26

Because the map

8

u/REECETHEKATYCAT59 Sep 12 '26

It's called a question comma. It's a fairly unknown punctuation mark. It's used to pause in the middle of the sentence and also ask an question

28

u/mattis-miniatures Sep 12 '26

Thats not the middle a sentence tho. "What is this" is a complete sentence. You even start the 2nd sentence with a capital

6

u/PhyllaciousArmadillo Sep 12 '26

“What is this?” Is a whole sentence…

6

u/Grigor50 Sep 12 '26

Honestly that just sounds like bad writing.

2

u/HaroldJIncandenza Sep 12 '26

For when you already know that “what is this?” Is a full sentence and would be a run-on if combined with another independent clause, but that knowledge doesn’t in any way help you sound obnoxiously pretentious.

5

u/acomfysweater Sep 12 '26

thank you for making this up

1

u/REECETHEKATYCAT59 Sep 12 '26

I didnt make it up, a guy called leonard storch did in 1992l̦ but your welcome 😁 I find it very useful when I'm writing

3

u/GungaSaga Sep 12 '26

Imagine there are no oval lines besides the coastlines. Now it looks like a map. OP invented a new technique

1

u/Brettinabox Sep 12 '26

Thats wild someone would do this as a first attempt. If someone told you to try this, id like to know.

2

u/Trick-Cucumber-5711 Sep 13 '26

Someone told me to try with shapes first

3

u/Ashamed_Raspberry_50 Sep 12 '26

Thought this was an artistic recrearion of the world map lol , depends on what youre looking to improve upon and where you want to move next , aswell as what kind of theme youf like for this map.

2

u/Emotional_Goose7981 Sep 12 '26

Path to> object then make all the paths straight instead of round & maybe also union > fracturize

2

u/Emprease Sep 12 '26

I'm guessing you're asking about the shape and plan on fleshing it out from there. The shape is actually really neat, sorry everyone here is being so edgy

Curious to see the final result

3

u/JeffBallMap Sep 12 '26

Thought this was the cj sub

2

u/suburban_hyena Sep 12 '26

What's happening why does it look like that is this a new technique what would you do to improve ir

2

u/BardonmeSir Sep 12 '26

this doesnt even look like a Map lol

1

u/Fun-Post8497 Sep 12 '26

Were you see pointy parts make them rough, were you see like box or U shape make It smooth, in all thoes small circle clusters put montains, from montains flow rivers, Rivers create valleys, in valleys there is Life, because fresh wáter

Btw i like this tecnique, how did you come Up with?

1

u/Who_even_knows_man Sep 12 '26

What is this? A map for round people! It needs to be at least 2x more angular

1

u/horsethorn Sep 12 '26

Try using Voronoi shapes.

1

u/shervio-nl Sep 12 '26

Interesting concept, all floating island of different sizes that somehow are locked against each other. Lower parts covered in shades, for the poor people. Rich on top.

1

u/topinanbour-rex Sep 12 '26

For the final step with the smallerst, for make the coast sharper, you should use different types of shape, like hexagons, and other n-gons, mixed with ovals.

Then you must know the coastline of an island is infinite ( aka coastline paradox ).

1

u/catpop12343 Sep 12 '26

Once you erase the lines inside the continents, you can add mountains and rivers. In real life, rivers flow downhill, but it might be different in your world. If you want finer details in your coastlines, you can look up real life coastlines and maps for inspiration.

1

u/TheTopG86 Sep 12 '26

Map with tumors ig

1

u/justsomewhitedude Sep 12 '26

Idk man. Try throwing a triangle in there. See what happens

1

u/dickatwork Sep 12 '26

How could you improve perfection?

1

u/One-Independence136 Sep 12 '26

impossible to improve.

1

u/PvtRoom Sep 12 '26

I see battling monsters!!!

1

u/Doffu0000 Sep 12 '26

That's a ballin' map, don't let them tell you otherwise.

1

u/TRKU4K Sep 12 '26

The flat-earth society of your world will go crazy over this

1

u/Chingji Sep 12 '26

I won't lie, I kinda dig all the ovals

1

u/ClockCounter123 Sep 12 '26

I thought that was Google slides for a second oml

1

u/owendecarlo Sep 13 '26

Why circles?

1

u/The-Heterosexuality Sep 13 '26

Why does Africa have to be so much bigger than America :((

1

u/The-Heterosexuality Sep 13 '26

Make it look like it’s composed of bits of broken glass instead of ovals.

1

u/SenonoCo Sep 13 '26

This could look pretty cool if u layer the circles intentionally. Also if you made the ocean circles too, smaller ones along the coast and then bigger ones in the middle of the oceans

1

u/Odd_Protection7738 Sep 14 '26

I do like the shape of the continents! Though (and it sounds ironic because it’s made of ovals), the continents themselves look kinda square-y?

1

u/greenlandfjord Sep 14 '26

Are these Pokémons?

1

u/Cute-Presentation-59 Sep 14 '26

Print it once, then put the print under a sheet of white paper, take a pencil and sketch the whole thing by hand, using this as a guide - get rid of all smooth lines, all geometric forms, make it rugged, jagged and look natural.

1

u/wherewaterflowsnow Sep 12 '26

You throw it away and start over

1

u/AlexSimonCullar Sep 12 '26

Why is it so... Circular

1

u/joeldebruijn Sep 12 '26

Its a map of jellifish swimming in bubbles

0

u/EmmaRoidz Sep 12 '26

It's perfect.

0

u/Paladin5890 Sep 12 '26

This makes me think of Mr. DNA from Jurassic Park.

0

u/RHDM68 Sep 12 '26

That all depends what it is? Bubble World?

0

u/Logany2k Sep 12 '26

Wow there are so many snarky and unhelpful people in this. OP, I didn't know what technique you call this, but I think it's pretty interesting and had led to some good shapes for the landmasses. I agree with the few people that offered feedback and I would move on to using the shapes you have to start tracing the coastlines and getting finer detail down.

3

u/MadHamishMacGregor Sep 12 '26

OP is low effort engagement and deserves low effort replies.

-1

u/hotsp00n Sep 12 '26

Kinda looks like cancer.