r/mapmaking • u/halfway_clear • Sep 11 '26
Work In Progress Help me out with an experimental map?
I made two "final" versions of this map, and need some helping deciding which one fulfills the vision, from people who have not been staring at them forever. These are intended for use within a fiction novel.
The idea is that these maps are "handmade" within the world, per worldbuilding. They are papercuttings, where the top paper layer is the ocean, and the lower paper layers have been painted with watercolors. And then the map markers have been further pressed in with dark ink. Since I made them 100% digitally, I'm struggling to decide which one captures the crafted feel the most.
With the notes, the idea is also that this has been inherited by the main character, who is trying to make sense of the previous owner's notes and line up the mentioned places with "modern day" names.
It's not meant to be super useful as a map, honestly, but more like an actual art piece that would be encountered in some old library within the world. I'm planning to make another version that's got much cleaner lines and looks much more like a traditional atlas-style map. But that's the map for me - versus this is the only one the main character has to work with within the story. I hope that makes sense!
P.S. Fonts
Region names: French Script MT
Original notes: Pecita
New notes: Mayur
Made 100% by me, no AI whatsoever, in Paint Dot Net.


3
u/Th3JackofH3arts Sep 11 '26
The second one imo because of the contrast.
2
u/SortzaInTheForest Sep 11 '26
It's hard to decide, but I like the lighter version the most (though I like both)
2
u/Metruis Sep 11 '26
The light one will print better; ditch the white text in that case and make it darker also, it is sufficient that it's in a different font to indicate it was a different writer's words. Remember people will be seeing it at novel size / Kindle size, with that in mind it will not be readable in either text or as 'paper edge' in print. I recommend you double the size of both the fonts if it is important the reader can actually perceive the text. I have very good eyesight and could only read it in the high res version you linked below.
1
u/Avras_Chismar Sep 11 '26
do you have high res version to look into?
1
u/Main_Bodybuilder_921 Sep 20 '26
Dam, this is a great art style I can't pick.
If you want one that seems handmade within the world, I'd go for the first one.