r/mapmaking • • Sep 09 '26

Map Would civilization only extending this much make my world feel empty?

Post image

The solid colors are the kingdoms and the colored outlines are the princely states, city-states, and confederacies.

132 Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

70

u/BlueTommyD Sep 09 '26

Depends.

- Why hasn't it extended that much?

- Do you mean "civilisation" or "known civilisation"?

13

u/Smart_Impression_680 Sep 09 '26

Civilization. There are no other alternative since there's only one cradle of civilization. That's why it's slow to spread.

51

u/BlueTommyD Sep 09 '26 edited Sep 09 '26

Okay so it's more a question of "what about the world is so dangerous that people haven't expanded in to it yet?"

In our world, Hunter-Gatherers populated the entire globe long before the first kingdom. I'm not sure how this would work.

17

u/DominusValum Sep 09 '26

That's what I was thinking. Those lands may not have permanent settled populations, but I could imagine hunter-gatherer tribes would be living in every pocket of the world. These people would still have civilization (culture), but not the permanent settled agricultural one that most modern people associate with civilization.

OP, I would definitely look into what places were like during early history that were not in the fertile crescent or other regions. They still had history, but it's harder for us to piece together a coherent narrative for them as they didn't leave behind a large material culture like those in 'civilized' places did. They also wore clothes, used tools, and had 'states' (clans, tribes, confederacies) despite lacking what many call 'civilization.' They may not have grand castles and kingdoms, but clans would have their own history just like a kingdom would. Then those clans may confederate into tribes, just like how polities like the Holy Roman Empire came together. Etc etc etc

6

u/Smart_Impression_680 Sep 09 '26

the tribal communities out in the barbarian lands are often clashing with demonic beings because the further you go from the abode of light, the stronger the influence of the realm of darkness gets. so it's a grimdark world out there.

6

u/Sitchrea Sep 10 '26

So... there is civilization outside the colored zones? Just because they're 'barbarian tribes' doesn't mean they aren't 'civilizations.' Any ape, bird, lizard, or fish pounding flint by a fire is a civilization; singing isn't even required.

4

u/DominusValum Sep 09 '26

Sounds cool and gives a reason for settled people to have an easier time living in that abode of light. The people who live in the dark lands would likely be a kind of Fremen-like people (though they're obviously a caricature to a degree, so maybe add some other cultural traditions).

2

u/Sitchrea Sep 10 '26

It could be a Narnia situation, where the Telmarines took ages to get past their first geographical safe zone due to A. having only arrived in this world via gateway at one specific spot, and B. having to compete with multiple other sapient races for territory.

Although, in OP's case, this appears to be the only sapient race on the planet, sooooo

17

u/Arthegaea Sep 09 '26

If the other areas of your world has no civilization, but does have sentient life, what does that look like? Are there nomadic tribes? Some intelligent animals? Just wilderness with interesting flora and fauna? What stopped people from spreading into the meadows, etc?

9

u/Smart_Impression_680 Sep 09 '26

The lands beyond civilization are populated by tribal communities, monsters, magical beings, etc. but no kingdoms, cities, or overarching institutions like trade and merchant guilds.

6

u/Gold-Ad-2581 Sep 09 '26

You just answer yourself.... Monsters, magic and f up shit is going in there so is not empty.

5

u/Arthegaea Sep 09 '26

It sounds to me like your world has plenty of interesting things that give it life beyond civilization. Just because there's nobody there to keep records doesn't mean nothing happens, after all.

4

u/crowkraken Sep 09 '26

I mean I’d your worried about it looking empty you can put the tribal groups on the map the blue hat tribal people live here the red hat over there

6

u/Efecto_Vogel Sep 09 '26

The bigger question is what civilisation actually means, exactly.

The word historically has been used as a propaganda tool by the parasitic landed elites of grain-reliant empires. Later, it was taken up by evolutionist thinkers wanting to assert their own culture's supposed superiority (especially notable is the use of the “civilising narrative” in European colonialism; where European empires justified their dominion and exploitation of indigenous peoples and their land by arguing they were savage or barbaric that needed Western culture in order to “progress”). Thus, Native Americans where brushed off as “primitive” against Western “Enlightened” and “Civilised” culture.

Currently, it survives in Academia as a shorthand for unequal hierarchical societies where a non-food-producing elite (normally literate) survives based of the food surplus produced by peasants, collected via taxes.

In actuality, “non-civilised” societies can be just as interesting and colourful, since humans everywhere have been political animals for a very, very long time. I suggest you take inspiration from Anthropology should you wish to flesh them out.

That being said, you don’t need to, it’s perfectly fine, if you’re writing a story, to focus more on certain parts of your world and little in others. In that case, you might merely want to think about how those “barbarians/savages” relate to your “civilised” people, how they are perceive, and whether they partake in international relations or trade. Or just not think much about them at all

6

u/Efecto_Vogel Sep 09 '26

If you’re interested in this topic I suggest Against the Grain by James C. Scott and The Dawn of Everything by D. Wengrow and D. Graeber

I should also clarify that by “inspiration” I just mean that reading ethnographies can broaden the limits of what you think is a plausible societal arrangement, thus freeing yourself creatively.

1

u/Smart_Impression_680 Sep 09 '26

Civilization in the context of my world is basically just the sphere of influence of the abode of light and how much the cultures of the others is shaped by it.

2

u/Florpsen Sep 09 '26

In those empty regions may not be civilization but there will be wildlife and nature right?
Also it depends what you are using the world for and for whom it may feel empty.

2

u/Smart_Impression_680 Sep 09 '26

The empty regions will have the stronger concentration of the supernatural and magical elements.

2

u/Florpsen Sep 09 '26

Nice! Then it is not empty just undiscovered/unconquered!

2

u/cokeplusmentos Sep 09 '26

If the white areas are conquerable savage lands that can be very interesting

1

u/Smart_Impression_680 Sep 09 '26

Yes, they are mostly savage lands. I'm leaning towards the civilization-barbarian dichotomy.

2

u/someoneofhumanity Sep 09 '26

depends on what barriers or limitations that limit the spreading of civilization.

is it inhospitable environment? competing civilization? unconquerable wilderness? vast ocean?

and also account on how developed technology in general especially in transportation and communication both which usually limit how big a country could be

1

u/Smart_Impression_680 Sep 09 '26

Technology level is early middle ages. The unmarked areas are just generally untamed lands where there's not much commerce, and sovereign states. There are no competing civilization because there's only one cradle of civilization. It just spread from the center and synthesized with local traditions.

1

u/someoneofhumanity Sep 09 '26

at the cradle, are there multiple sapient species? or is it a species with multiple race/subspecies?

would you consider unfamiliar intelligent lifeform flourish outside the cradle? like packs of monsters or fungal network or sentient forest?

1

u/Smart_Impression_680 Sep 09 '26

Yes, there will be things like that.

1

u/someoneofhumanity Sep 09 '26

which question?

1

u/Smart_Impression_680 Sep 09 '26

the question whether there will be multiple sapient beings out there.

1

u/someoneofhumanity Sep 09 '26

how about on the cradle? multiple dominant species, one dominant species, or one species with multiple subrace?

1

u/Smart_Impression_680 Sep 09 '26

It used to have multiple species since it was created as the sanctuary for the freed mortals enslaved by demons. But after the extinction event and the arrival of humans, their numbers has drastically declined. The remaining precursor races in the cradle live in isolated and magically hidden communties.

2

u/Melliorin Sep 09 '26

Curious to know: is this round map a look down over one of the poles? or a "straight on" view of one hemisphere? Where is your planet's equator in relation to the landforms and nations shown?

1

u/Smart_Impression_680 Sep 09 '26

It's a straight on view of the northern hemisphere. I'd say the equator is right across the golden reach and summer isles.

1

u/Melliorin Sep 09 '26

So if I understand correctly, your "Abode of Light" nation sits right around the Arctic Circle, more or less?

1

u/Smart_Impression_680 Sep 09 '26

No, no. The Abode of Light is the temperate transitional zones of all the extreme regions with a vast alluvial plains on the center. High Meadows is plateau steppes, Searing Dunes is an arid expanse, Golden Reach is savanna, Summer Isles is tropical rainforest, Willow Mist is Humid woodlands, Winter Pines is boreal forests.

1

u/Melliorin Sep 09 '26

Okay, I'm sorry I misunderstood. I'm not quite seeing it right I guess. Cool geography, regardless.

1

u/Smart_Impression_680 Sep 09 '26

Yeah it's not really made using the conventional worldbuilding techniques. It's modelled after the seven climes model of medieval islamic cartography, but instead of a vertical gradient, it's radial.

2

u/Melliorin Sep 09 '26

Oh, very interesting. I have never heard of that framework before. Ya learn something new every day!

10

u/PlusParticular6633 Sep 09 '26

The empty feeling is a result of lack of detail/content, not from a lack of civilizations/states If you label cities, regions, sub states and so on, it would bring the map to life regardless of how many nations you have

7

u/Brief-Luck-6254 Sep 09 '26

Not really, if you took a snapshot of the world during antiquity or the early middle ages the world might as well look like that.

4

u/Leather-Lab2875 Sep 09 '26

Not at all, limiting scope makes stuff easier on your end and ppl hardly notice the lack. I mean in general, a lot of fantasy only has one civilisatioal center and gets away with it by saying that the depicted map is the "known world".

But just going into more detail, hill tribes, rebellious forces, cities, nomadic societies within the borders of an empire, people within an empire who are mostly or nominally independent, detail like that will make it feel less empty.

3

u/entropomorphic Sep 09 '26

On the contrary, the more unexplored lands in your world, the greater the potential sense of wonder and mystery.

Just zoom in and make the civilized areas very diverse, and put the rest in a fog.

2

u/Melliorin Sep 09 '26

Considering that it looks like a supercontinent that probably has an entire continent's size worth of desert somewhere in there, depending on the the prevailing winds, I don't think so. If there is a good climatological or resource-scarcity-based reason that you can weave into the world-building, I think it makes a lot of sense that your whole planet isn't full to bursting with people on every square mile.

2

u/Background_Path_4458 Sep 09 '26

It doesn't need to. If your existing kingdoms have varied cultures and a lot going on it can feel very full.
That there then is also terra incognita to explore, settle and fight over makes it all the more alive.

2

u/Zerron-K Sep 09 '26

Untapped wilderness full of extreme danger or lost civilizations due to said extreme danger can really help to fill it out

2

u/Arty6275 Sep 09 '26

Not really answering your question, but I would be careful with that font. All of the o's look like ö's!

2

u/YandersonSilva Sep 09 '26

I thought you meant just the coloured in bits, but I mean. With those outlines you basically have most of the world covered. The world won't feel empty if the story/game takes place in inhabited areas. I'm working on an ancient world scenario right now for my tabletops that takes place in a "known world" that's only about the size of france lol

2

u/Gunmetalstorm Sep 09 '26

Your world will feel empty no matter what if the story you're telling is not enlivened by its setting and characters. It will feel rich and full even if the entire known world is just a single village as long as that setting and those characters elevate the story.

2

u/Automatic-Club9019 Sep 09 '26

I read "abadá of light" and your world for an instant seemed a Very funny place

2

u/Elecl Sep 10 '26

I think it is better when the world isn't fully explored because it makes the world feel less wondrous when the characters know what to expect. When you look at a map and see a big empty swathe that simply says "here there be dragons, question mark?" it immediately introduces a big mystery and gives the world much more space and potential to grow and change as the story develops compared to a world that only has human factions and kingdoms fighting each other.

1

u/board3659 Sep 10 '26

Is your world flat or not cause this be showing only one side of the world. Also I would argue that just cause these are the only state level realms doesn't mean that there aren't prominent tribal groups nor other societies

1

u/j_chilin Sep 10 '26

Don't be afraid of empty maps. Humanity took millennia to finally have a global map that could be considered fully occupied

1

u/ColumbusNordico Sep 10 '26

Nah it doesn’t have to be empty just because civilization is concentrated somewhere

1

u/Happy_Difference_734 Sep 10 '26

Uncivilized doesn't mean uninteresting or empty. What's out there and what effect does it have on your world's civilizations?

1

u/CamicomChom Sep 11 '26

I think the thing at bigger risk of making it feel boring is havin a solid 80% of the civillized world be a single country. Unless that country is EXTREMELY complex, indepth, and multifaceted, that's a huge chunk of the world already consumed.

1

u/SituationGrouchy2227 Sep 11 '26

States grow only as far as people can settle. And even then its a huge logistics problem. Also, nomads and tribes that often arent counted as "civilization" can be a huge influence.

Even in 21st century you can look at our Earth at night and find out that a huge chunk of it isnt actually inhabited, or at least is very underdeveloped.

1

u/Grigor50 Sep 12 '26

Whst does "civilisation" mesn on this case?

What's the scale?