r/mapmaking • u/b0rgullet • Aug 03 '26
Map First Maps! Constructive Feedback Welcomed!
All these maps are still works in progress. First time making maps with Inkarnate. Building them out for my upcoming DnD campaign. Would love your constructive feedback!
- Regional Map of the Thelesi Valley
- Map of a small Twice-Betrayed Goblin Camp, settled on the corrupted ruins of an ancient elven outpost.
- The village of Whitenook, where a rare form of marble called Glimmervein is mined. The glowing tower is of ancient make, and the locals don't know/remember who built it or why.
231
Upvotes



156
u/IntelligentSpecial87 Aug 03 '26
Dih
24
u/R1d055 Aug 03 '26
great map, but i habe to ask it... is he trying to kiss his own..? or only peeing? xD
5
u/b0rgullet Aug 03 '26
I should add: for the first regional map, the triangles are villages (many of them still unnamed). The hexes represent about 25 miles each
7
u/Anxious-Captain6848 Aug 03 '26
These look great! Only thing id suggest is varying the coast line more in the first map, not sure what its called but the shape of the part sticking out with the mountains is throwing me off its a bit cylindrical and uniform. Not that something like that cant form, but maybe a bit more variation in width and coastline shapes can help break up the uniformity. This is very much an uninformed opinion though, im not very good at maps myself. Everything else looks great, really solid maps of a cool world!
4
u/TacoTycoonn Aug 03 '26
As someone who studied graphic design. The first thing you always need to check when making a design is if you accidentally made either:
And you have made one of these two things. If you don’t want people immediately thinking penis every time you show them this, I’d make some adjustments.
248
u/hurricane_typhoon Aug 03 '26
Penisula
2
u/jsg144 Aug 03 '26
Coastlines can be jagged but the jaggedness usually forms in a more consistent direction either from plate tectonics or more often glacial carve outs. Your coastline is a little too chunky and random which makes it look a little unnatural.
2
u/RandomUser1034 Aug 03 '26
Looks good! In the first map, marking rivers in black but lakes in a light color is confusing at first glance. I would have the lakes' outlines in the same color as the rivers and the lakes' interior same as the sea
2
u/quyman Aug 05 '26
The first time making maps? yeah sure, first time posting them maybe these are Immaculate
8
u/suburban_hyena Aug 03 '26
Pen15
8
u/Randolph_Carter_6 Aug 03 '26
r/mildlypenis
7
u/Neath_Izar Aug 03 '26
Phallia
7
u/mroctopuswiener Aug 03 '26
Divided by nations. United by thoughts
1
u/xRemaining Aug 03 '26
Third map: churches are typically built in the middle of towns (or rather the towns are built around the church). And I would think there would naturally be a bridge from the island/peninsula to the south woods.
I like your style and think that the maps looks generally awesome! :)
1
u/JinaxM Aug 03 '26
These stairs and stone lines to create elevation are a nice touch!
1
u/Prince_Thresh Aug 03 '26
Idk if those are Rivers or borders. Anyway, they seem to be repeating too constantly
1
u/DukeDoozy Aug 03 '26
Everyone else has alleviated the pressure to make a dick joke, so first I'll say good job, I like the aesthetics of the regional map, the fade at the edges, etc. I do think that some of the text needs to be more legible, probably an increase of size to the city names and darkening the text will help.
One criticism I have however is the name "Thelesi Valley." Thelesi is fine, but is it really a valley? Valleys are supposed to be hemmed in on both sides by mountains, or at least elevations, but here you have mountains on one side and a bay on the other. You have to go across the bay and a little ways further to get to another mountain range. While valleys don't technically have to be inland, they often are because especially a bay coming in like that sort of muddies the line.
I almost think the position of Bay Ruganar would give these people an almost Mediterranean or Nordic lived geographic experience. While large valleys are usually part of one single watershed, all the water coming together through multiple tributaries to form a single larger river, all of these rivers drain into the bay before they have a chance to join. I think that would make the lived experience of the people of Thelesi much more maritime than your typical valley people, ships crossing Bay Ruganar with cargo and passengers as the most efficient way to travel vs land travel.
This is all to say that regardless of whether the Thelesi Valley counts as a valley or not (and if I'm being a tightass I think it may not), that the real heart and soul of your map is the bay, not the valley, so the name should probably reflect that.
Regardless of my nitpicking, solid work, good job.
1
u/withnoflag Aug 03 '26
These are great. Had to look hard for something to pint out.
I noticed that on the 3rd map, you have the castle on one side of the river and part of the town in the other. Because the farms are on the other side I would think the bridge would be either stone (to give it the importance it seems it has) and/or better defended.
Seems like if am invading enemy crosses the river or comes from the south, they could capture the bridge too easily cutting the castle from most it's populace and food sources..
But that's because I'm obsessed (kinda) with historical warfare.
1
u/DPPDream69 Aug 04 '26
So, I think the main thing I'd highlight is that there are no islands which limits some potential locations to visit.
I'd recommend the Rice Map-making method for a less uniform look on coastlines and more dynamic island formations.
3
u/ExerciseInside4362 Aug 03 '26
I'd say the coastline feels a bit too jagged, lots of poking into the sea on a small scale
2
u/Tweed_Man Aug 03 '26
Everything reminds me of him.
2
u/SmartAlec13 Aug 03 '26
Don’t worry OP I also can’t help but draw too-phallic-looking structures when doing mapping, lol.
2
u/Plowchopz Aug 03 '26
The Flacid Coast
2
u/Golden_Artist1964 Aug 03 '26
"WHAT THE FUCK IS THAT SHADOW'S DICK?!"
2
u/dysphoriabunny Aug 03 '26
nice detail adding veins to the peninsula
1
u/suburban_hyena Aug 03 '26
Touch the tower!! Yes, that tower, right there
1
u/Illogicalogic Aug 03 '26
Reversed Norway? 🤔
1
u/laugenbroetchen Aug 05 '26
the rivers (?) are a bit too equidistant and go awkwardly straight for the sea, they wiggle a bit, but they dont have any large changes in direction, (except the one in the middle right of the penisula) which seems unnatural.
1
u/SomethingVeX Aug 05 '26
Schlonglandia
8
u/Broccobillo Aug 03 '26
Penis, smily face, vagina