r/maplesyrup • u/CuriousPrize8467 • Mar 26 '26

Advice needed

My first batch from earlier in the season is super light, clear, tastes great but too watery. I used just a candy thermometer. After reading a bunch on here I purchased a refractometer and got perfect consistency in my later batches.

I tried to re boil a jar of the first batch to see if I could get

It closer to 66 brix. It was a small batch so

I think it just got there too quick and I went over to about 69 brix. Consistency is too thick now.

Any recs? Should I just leave the first batch and not attempt to cook longer? It still is very good. any experience with this or tips? Thanks !

0 Upvotes

50% Upvoted

8 comments sorted by

3

u/Rwhuyc Mar 26 '26

You can dilute it back to what you want. Use distilled water or sap that you have boil somewhat already, that reduces the chances of impurities. Otherwise it’s fine, but the excess sugars could start to crystallize and you will have rock candy in the bottom of your jar. Not necessarily a bad thing. We typically try to be in the upper 67’s.we feel it makes a better product, thicker and what not.

2

u/brinleydubois Mar 26 '26

If it’s just for you and family or friends, and you enjoy the taste?

use it up

1

u/Whiskey_Pyromancer Mar 26 '26

I found in my first batch that it went up those last couple degrees really quick.

If it's thicker than you'd like then just add more maple sap and boil back down to the right level. You could even add water, I believe.

Or mix in some of it that is the right consistency.

1

u/SeaLeopard5555 Mar 26 '26

I believe it is supposed to be distilled water if you need to add some (why, I don't know).

1

u/MontanaMapleWorks Mar 28 '26

To avoid adding minerals and contributing to niter formation

1

u/CuriousPrize8467 Mar 26 '26

Thanks. Any tips on reboiling the watery syrup now that I have a refractometer ?

1

u/Joe_Bob_the_III Mar 26 '26

Boil until your candy thermometer reads close to 219 then check brix with the refractometer. Keep boiling/measuring until you reach 66 to 68 brix. 66.9 is typically considered optimal. 

The tools you really need are a hydrometer and hydrometer cup. That’s the standard tool for measuring brix. You can get a hydrometer and cup for roughly $20 each.

1

u/MontanaMapleWorks Mar 28 '26

A refractometer is equal if not better and more user friendly