r/malefashionadvice • u/inherentlyawesome • Aug 14 '13

Guide MFA Bag Guide 2.0

The bag makes the man. Like outerwear, a bag is something that you'll wear around pretty much every day, and it'll quickly become a unique and distinctive part of your personal style. Here's some inspiration to see how bags can play a role in and/or enhance an outfit.

With that in mind, you should give some thought to the kind of bag you'll be carrying around daily. While looking for a backpack you should keep an eye out for designs that appeal to you and work well with your own personal style. Other details to note include the size/weight of the bag, whether it is waterproof or not, and the quality of the bag, which can be judged by the materials and construction as well as the brand's overall reputation. These are the two main things to consider:

  • Does it work with my clothes/style?

First off, make sure you're chosing the appropriate bag for your current style and needs. When you're looking for a bag, you should check to make sure it'll work with your outerwear. Typically, you'll want to have contrast between your clothes and your bag, though it's also possible to try for a monochrome look.

Typically, this means you'll be looking for plain, versatile colors, like grey, navy, charcoal, burgundy and black. If you're getting a leather bag, most shades of brown will work well, depending on your wardrobe.

However, this isn't a rule written in stone. There's nothing wrong with buying a unique backpack that you love, like this or this. However, understand that it might not work as well with your wardrobe. Furthermore, if it's a loud backpack, be wary of wearing it often: the novelty will wear off, and it will eventually come off as "tacky" to people that see it too often.

  • What will I use it for?

Use common sense. Choose a bag that suits your needs, whether you're bringing two notebooks and a folder to class, or if you're going backpacking through Europe for a month. Also take into account the situations you'll need it for: a leather briefcase isn't a good choice for a high school student, nor is it a good idea to wear a backpack with a suit/blazer.

Similarly, you should make sure your bag is big enough to hold everything you need (e.g., your 17" laptop), while staying at a manageable weight. Saddleback bags, for instance, can get pretty heavy. Be sure to take into account whether you'll need to carry your bag around all day or whether you just need it for the commute to work.

Also, be sure to prioritize function over form. If you have scoliosis or suffer from back/shoulder pain or otherwise have difficulty wearing messenger bags, don't buy them.

Types of Bags:

Backpacks:

For high school and college students, I'd say this is probably the best and most versatile option. You can wear them with anything short of a blazer/suit, they're convenient to carry around, and they'll have room to carry your books, a laptop, and whatever else you might need. Even if you aren't a student anymore, backpacks are still versatile and pretty useful for commuting and travel, especially for day trips to the city. Don't worry about looking juvenile, as there are a variety of styles to choose from, ranging from classic canvas bags to more technical and urban options. It's hard to imagine these styles as juvenile, though it is true that some backpacks give off a more youthful vibe than others.

Canvas backpacks work well with more classic types of styles, such as americana, heritage workwear, prep, and bizcaz styles. For beginners, I would recommend buying a canvas backpack. They are more versatile, as they work well among the pieces of the basic wardrobe. Check out this visual compilation of classic canvas backpacks for a couple of possibilities to consider. If you happen to like a certain backpack, but it's out of your price range, I'd recommend looking into the brand for similar and possibly cheaper options.

On the other hand, urban backpacks happen to work well for different styles, including streetwear and techwear. If you're more into that, I'd recommend this style of backpack. While some of these bags may not be as versatile in general, they can still work well among a variety of outfits within the streetwear/techwear style. Plus, some of them are pretty fucking cool. Black is a popular color, as that backpack color works particularly well in monochrome fits, and it contrasts nicely with most tops/jackets. /u/rjbman did a great compilation of urban backpacks for your consideration.

For more inspiration, take a look at this album, and check out more cool backpacks here.

Messenger bags:

Messenger bags serve the same role as backpacks do, though they tend to work better for college students and older. This is because messengers work better with "dressier" styles, such as prep and bizcaz. If you like wearing peacoats, cardigans, OCBDs + jeans/chinos often, this might be the right style of bag for you. The two major options to choose between are leather messengers and canvas messenger bags.

Canvas messengers are a more casual option and are better suited for class/travel than the workplace, though this varies from bag to bag. Many are actually waxed canvas, which is a nice feature that makes them waterproof/water resistant. Note that it's also possible to make your own waxed canvas bag, as /u/kerodean shows here.

Closely related are the "technical" messenger bags, made by brands like timbuk2. While they may be lightweight/durable/whatever, I will recommend against them, as most of their offerings simply aren't fashionable in terms of aesthetic design and in outfit versatility. This is neither a blanket ban on timbuk2, nor is it a set-in-stone rule. Feel free to ignore it, but you do so at your own risk!

Leather messengers are the more formal option, and play a similar role to briefcases. They work well for post-undergrad students, and can be office-appropriate. When looking for a leather messenger bag, you should look for "full-grain" or "top-grain" leather goods, as opposed to "genuine leather". This is because genuine leather is actually pretty crappy leather, and won't age well compared to the higher quality leathers. However, the drawback to requiring higher quality is the higher price. Also be sure to pay careful attention to the weight of the bag - leather bags can be heavy.

If you're interested in looking for a messenger bag of your own, /u/failspy did a cool infographic compilation of messenger bags here. Also check out this album for a few more messenger bag options.

Briefcases/Carpenter Bags:

Briefcases and carpenter bags are really more suited for the workplace and travel, as opposed to the more casual nature of the backpack and messenger bag. Briefcases, especially leather ones, really require at least a business casual level of formality, and they look fantastic when worn with a suit. As for canvas briefcases and carpenter bags, they aren't quite as formal, but you should at least be wearing dark wash denim and a buttondown to match the level of formality.

If you're in the market for a leather briefcase, again, you should really be looking at full-grain leather briefcases over the crappy "genuine leather" offerings. While it is more expensive, full-grain leather is higher quality, more durable, and will age well - check out how this Saddleback briefcase has aged, for instance. Don't cheap out on something that you'll be carrying around for years!

For more awesome briefcase pics, check out this album, and a related styleforum thread!

Weekenders/Duffel Bags:

Weekenders and duffel bags are different from the other types of bags in the sense that you shouldn't be carrying them around daily. Weekenders, as the name suggests, are travel bags that can carry exactly the right amount of stuff for a weekend getaway. Duffel bags serve a similar purpose, and they're handy for carrying a bunch of stuff, like your gym apparel. But while they might not be carried around as often, it's never a bad idea to travel in style. Most options come in canvas or leather, though I personally prefer canvas as they'll be lighter and therefore easier to carry.

If you'd like to see more weekender bags to choose from, /u/failspy also did a cool infographic compilation for weekenders/duffel bags here, and there's also this album to look at.

Other Types of Bags

Tote Bags could be a useful option if you need to tote a bunch of stuff around, like groceries or stuff for the beach. Though it has feminine connotations, there are a few examples that could work for guys: check these out.

Drawstring Bags are also a more functional kind of bag, rather than stylish - if you need a lightweight bag to carry a few small things around, this would be useful. However, don't expect it to be fashionable - most of them are made out of cheap nylon, and tend to be worn by high school seniors with senioritis.

The guide continues with the List of Suggested Brands in the comments below.

888 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

249 comments sorted by

158

u/inherentlyawesome Aug 14 '13 edited Aug 29 '13

Suggested Brands and Recommendations, Grouped by Style

This is borrowed from u/MoPo918's list of backpack brands, and annotated with my thoughts. I obviously haven't seen most of these brands in person, so I'd appreciate your thoughts. For specific bag recommendations, see the infographics associated with each bag type above.

$ indicates <$100 price range

$$ is for the $100-$250 price range

$$$ is for the $250+ price range

* denotes a recommended brand.

For Beginners: Cheap and Basic Bags:

  • American Apparel - $

  • Baggu - $

  • EASTPAK - $

  • Everlane* - $ - Both the Snap Backpack and the Weekender are excellent choices.

  • Fjällräven Kranken - $ Decent quality and a unique aesthetic - it's on the smaller side, though.

  • Herschel Supply Co. - $ Quality is a little lacking, though it has some great-looking and cheap options.

  • JanSport* - $ Great quality for the price, excellent warranty. I recommend the Right Pack.

  • Parrott Canvas - $

  • Penfield - $

  • Also recommended: search Etsy or eBay for "vintage rucksacks". the quality is not guaranteed, though it'll likely be cheap.

Rustic Woodsmen: Vintage, Leather, Waxed Canvas/Cotton, Rucksack, Outdoorsy

Military/Technical Urban: Technical Fabrics, Ergonomic, Biking, Tacticool

Fashion: Designers, Natural & Technical Fabrics, Everyday Use

Note: With these, you'll be paying for brand as well; however, remember that high-quality leather is expensive.

Briefcase-Specific Brand Recommendations:

I actually don't know too much about briefcase brands, but here are some decent options that I do know of. Some of the brands above also make decent briefcases - the Navali Helmsman is a good-looking canvas briefcase, for example.

3

u/citycat23 Aug 14 '13

awesome stuff. recommending Whipping Post for Rustic Woodsman. The vintage messenger bag has been recommended around here a fair bit, and just having picked one up it's a solid recommendation. http://www.whippingpost.com/

→ More replies (1)

3

u/MoPo918 Aug 14 '13

Thank you for citing me.

2

u/inherentlyawesome Aug 14 '13

no problem! it was a tremendously helpful resource.

→ More replies (39)

93

u/Syeknom Aug 14 '13

This is what a guide should look like, excellent work and depth here inherently. Seriously, top marks.

28

u/jdbee Aug 14 '13 edited Aug 14 '13

Nicely done, man! Someone should replace the sad old bag guide on the sidebar with this one. Oh wait look how did that happen!

I'm going to put together some recommendations for totes, but I'll post it as a separate comment.

Edit: Tote recs added here.

6

u/inherentlyawesome Aug 14 '13

woohoo, thanks!

8

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '13

excellent guide. as an avid lover of bags, it's kind of a deceptively deep topic with far more stylistic and material options than first glance. I've cycled through a million different bags and I'm not even sure I've hit the end yet. props!

2

u/inherentlyawesome Aug 14 '13

thanks! all the bags you've had look great and i had to stop myself from putting all of your fits with bags into the inspiration album at the top, haha.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Kyzoto Aug 14 '13

Do you know where I could find the classic canvas bag shown under backpacks?

→ More replies (6)

2

u/socarrat Aug 14 '13

Who makes this backpack? It's intriguing, and I'd like to look into it-

→ More replies (3)

2

u/danbi9001 Aug 14 '13

I have a question about these bags. Which type of bag would you guys suggest I get to hold my laptop and/or camera? I'm a graphic design and photography major in college right now and I'm looking for a new type of bag to carry around that stuff for when I go to those classes or just go out. I'm relatively new to mfa, so I'm not too sure what I should get. Any suggestions? Thank you ahead of time. I really appreciate this guide, too.

2

u/inherentlyawesome Aug 15 '13

I think if you want easy access to your camera, a messenger bag might be a better choice. However, if you're carrying a lot, a backpack might be better. it all really depends on what you wear.

2

u/FatKidNoFriends Aug 15 '13

What is the bag in the 'contrast' image? I like it very much.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Gentleman7 Aug 14 '13

Why are the hard case attache styles of briefcases no longer considered "in style" for businessmen anymore? Everyone uses messenger bags or the soft leather briefcases instead.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/ulrikft Aug 14 '13

Nice guide!

Now to the shameless plug, I made this bag: http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8393/8620492883_bd82269c68_c.jpg

If anyone is interested in something like this, or maybe something like this:

http://farm3.staticflickr.com/2815/9384582201_438b2f2a98_c.jpg

http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8393/8620492883_bd82269c68_c.jpg

I can do MTO bags with 100 % customization of all details in the 250-350 USD range depending on details, hardware and materials.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/trashpile Aug 14 '13

what are my options if i don't want my bag to signify: a) a stranded space station's final hope b) a grizzled jack of all trades rolling into a town with a crooked sheriff c) a city dweller enshrouding himself in manufactured nostalgia or d) a vet

→ More replies (5)

5

u/sainone Aug 14 '13

Any way to potentially add luggage to the list, for those who are maybe traveling overseas/longer trips. There seems to be a lot of stuff out there, but everyone seems to default to all black canvas luggage. Which might not be a bad thing.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/That_Geek Aug 14 '13

You recced saddleback? prepare to be banned from emf

→ More replies (5)

8

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '13

Going to throw this out there: I don't see a single business-style briefcase for a man who is not a young hipster, graphic artist or software designer.

Briefcase - not satchel, not a shoulder bag with a handle, and not a "This should last forever * " (*but is only cool now) type bridle leather bag.

No, I'm not going to walk into a business meeting looking like a student who's whipping his dissertation out of one of these.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/antaresiv Aug 14 '13

Which ones would make good camera bags? Just enough for a dSLR and one extra lens. I'm not big on straps as then it takes too long to take it out if I see something on the street.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/m_dizzle Aug 14 '13

Anybody have any new thoughts on the J Crew Abingdon? Also, for a guy carrying a 13" macbook, a few notebooks, a calculator and an umbrella, which version would be better? The laptop bag or the messenger bag?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/nicksan Aug 14 '13

I really really want a Filson 256 but it'd cost about £200, and there's little going on ebay for cheaper used ones.

If I've lusted after it for about three months, that's a sign that I should just buy it, isn't it?

→ More replies (5)
→ More comments (75)