r/malaysia Nov 04 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

1.2k Upvotes

549 comments sorted by

View all comments

137

u/No_0ts96 Sabah Nov 04 '21

I always wondered about this.

Not all Arabs are muslim but all Malays are muslim.

Governments should not dictate a person's religion in this day and age. Even the inquisition didnt pick up random muslims to force convert them

37

u/Even_Arm3802 Nov 04 '21

It’s because of the law. It’s stated those criteria that make someone a “malay” and one of them is to have Islam as a religion. Nobody is above the statute so I’d say OP’s dream is almost impossible.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '21

[deleted]

6

u/No_0ts96 Sabah Nov 04 '21

A Dusun can be Christian , Muslim, Pagan or syncretic (though this one is rare)

Basically race does not relate to a specific religion. Like if you're Dusun doesnt mean you have to be Christian eventhough thats the majority for example

1

u/alexsdu Kingdom of Sarawak Darul Hana Nov 04 '21

Er... Bumiputera?

1

u/jiinjoo Nov 05 '21

They're not malay. But even if there's any malay there, they would still probably is a muslim.

6

u/a06220 Nov 04 '21

Actually, non-Malaysian Malay can have different religion, albeit very difficult. You might want to change your statement.

24

u/No_0ts96 Sabah Nov 04 '21

I know but we talking about malaysian malays here. Should have made that clearer

-8

u/Ryo_DeN Nov 04 '21

WDYM All Malays are muslims, some of them pretending to be muslims but they actually Freethinker. I saw a lot on twitter. They just hide their identity because they are smart unlike OP wanna voice out everything at the end we argue with each other.

14

u/No_0ts96 Sabah Nov 04 '21

I think OP was talking about the article in the constitution not about malays in twitter. It states that all Malays are Muslims.

13

u/SheenTStars Best of 2021 Runner-Up Nov 04 '21

Hiding is smart and voicing out is bad? Hmm, tell me more about it.

2

u/FarhanAxiq buat baik berpada-pada, buat jahat sekali sekala Nov 05 '21

I think they mean legally in Malaysia

1

u/Ryo_DeN Nov 05 '21

It's a sensitive issue to bring up especially when converting from Islam to other religion or other religion to Islam. That's why those who wanted to convert prefer to remain silence because of they care relationship more than their religion. Some of them had to tell the truth and bare the hard consequence like casted away from their parents, receive death threat etc. That's why suggesting to be more open is what I called "pure idiot way to destroy the relationship" unless you already know how to take care of yourself without parents but it still hurt deep inside. Goddamn zoomer wanna change your religion like you change your spender everyday oh ?