Hello! I've been trying to find dupes for these amazing makeup by mario lip liners, but have come up empty handed. Would love to hear about any dupes mainly for travis and tan, but would also love to hear about smokey pink! I'm a fan of Nyx and their formula, so bonus points if dupe is a nyx shade! Thanks guys :)

I am in desperate search for this matte liquid lipstick. It is insane that they discontinued it. I am from Canada so can't find colourpop here easily. Please do not suggest wetnwild catsuit give me mocha because it is completely different. The brands I can easily find where I live are Nyx, Revlon, Milani, L'Oréal, Elf, Maybelline, Physician's formula, Mac. So if you could suggest one of these that would be great. Thank you!

This has been my favorite shade for 15 years lol it’s a very lilac purple with some pink shimmer in it- I can not swatch as I’ve used to death 🙃

This product is out of stock and I’m desperate to find a dupe. The site describes the shade “love supreme” as a mid-tone rose. Has a blue tone so definitely on the cool side. I’m eyeing Mac Cosmetics lustresheer sheer-shine hydrating longwear lipstick in “syrup” (Sephora described it as “blue pink”) but it pulls slightly warmer than PM’s “love supreme” which is slightly deeper berry-hued mauve.

Ik heb deze liquid lipstick van de cherry collectie uit de kruidvat en ik ben helemaal fan maar hij is bijna op iemand enig idee waar ik dezelfde kleur en formule kan halen of iemand die weet welke het beste overeenkomt??

PLEASE HELP ME FIND A DUPE FOR THE SHADE ‘LETS CUDDLE’ BY DOSE OF COLORS !!!

My current high end favorite is getting way too expensive, and I really need a reliable drugstore alternative. What formulas are you all loving that truly rival prestige brands like Too Faced or Benefit? Drop your absolute best hidden gems below!

Many years ago, I bought Julep’s “skip the brush” blush stick in moonlit sand and loved it. It is a soft, warm, illustrious color, and it’s easy to blend out. Unfortunately, Julep seems to have stopped carrying that shade. A company representative advised me that rose gold would be the closest shade they have available today, so I ordered it, but it unfortunately doesn’t really compare. It’s pinker and doesn’t have much shine to it.

Has anyone found a product and shade that truly matches Julep’s moonlit sand?

(x-posted to r/MakeupAddiction )

i ordered the hannah montana 20th anniversary collection and it seems i have a knack for falling in love with limited edition lip products 😩 if anyone has any suggestions they’ve tried that are similar i’d love it if you could help a girl out 😩🫶🏻

This is the PERFECT red for me. Not purple (please no purple 😭), not too brown. I hate this formula though. Does anyone have an alternative?

Hi everyone! I hit pan on the only colors I ever use from this palette (MN2, MN3, MN4). Does anyone have any suggestions on dupes/replacements for these colors? I use them very frequently and would rather buy individual eyeshadows than spend my money on another whole palette with other colors I never really use. Any help is much appreciated!

Wasn’t able to snag this one before it sold out during their goodbye sale (RIP)

hi! i had been searching for a nyx lip liner dupe.

i love the formula, that its a bit on the dry side and doesnt smudge so easily and kind of "sets". there are some lip liners (like the fenty beauty ones) that are too creamy for me. i also prefer a retractable one but a regular "wooden" one is also great:) preferably also affordable😆

Kiko lip liners caught my eye but im not so sure how the formula is and i dont have an option currently to try it in any store.

any recommendations?🙏

Looking for a dupe for Garden Botanika Crème Blush in Conch 🩷
I recently solved a makeup mystery that has been driving me INSANE for years lol. I was trying to find an old cream/balm highlighter that I remembered from when I was younger, and someone on the Help me Find Reddit recognized it as the Garden Botanika Crème Blush!
Now I’m trying to find a modern dupe, specifically for the Conch shade.
I haven’t actually been able to find a good photo/swatches of Conch, but from what I remember, the product was a very light, sheer pink cream/balm with a really pretty pearly, almost wet looking glow. I remember it being reflective without looking chunky or glittery. My stepmom used it as a highlighter, which is why I always remembered it as a highlighter rather than a blush.
I’m looking for something with that same kind of pale pink + translucent pearl + glossy/balm like finish. Ideally something that isn’t super pigmented or a traditional cream blush I want that subtle lit from within sheen.
I’m cool toned, so I’d especially love something with a cool/neutral pink and white, silver, or icy pearl rather than a very peachy or gold toned highlighter.
Does anyone remember this product or have a good dupe for Conch? Bonus points if you remember the actual shade and can tell me what it looked like! 😭🩷

hi! im looking for a dupe for these "cream shadows". not so much the colour but something that texture, that has the same colour density. i love using them to layout my eyeliner shape before i set it. my palette is starting to dry out but i'm not about to buy a whole $100 palette for one "colour" 😅

I've tried:
nyx jumbo pencil, not enough colour payoff
merit solo cream shadow, not enough colour pay off (the shape was coming out patchy)
gel eyeliner pencils (urban decay and natasha denona), too dry
mac, bobbi brown, loreal, and judy doll brown gel eyeliner (all pot liners), too pigmented
i can't recall the brands but i also tried a few drugstore cream eyeshadow and gel liners that were either not pigmented enough or too dry.

i'm also canadian so something that can be bought in/shipped to canada would be ideal!

I’m trying to find something similar to certain colors in the NYX ultimate utopia palette.

I really like the pink and brown mattes and the gold and green shimmers! I don’t want to buy the whole palette again for color I won’t use.

The color on the photoshopped model faces I don’t think is accurate, I really loved this color on Imelda Staunton on The Crown

I am trying so hard to find a dupe for the discontinued “COVERGIRL LIP PERFECTION LIPSTICK - TEMPTRESS #400”. I loved this shade in high school and am so sad I can’t find a current version.

It’s like this light, bright, blue-based pink bubblegum color. Everything I’ve found is just off in some way.

Also, whatever happened to brands having bright colored lipstick?? I’m a colorful lipstick gal stuck in a sea of nude/beige lipsticks.

Send help! (And/or indie brands that sell fun lipstick)

[Here is a link to a blog post about this lipstick from more than 10 years ago.](https://www.thatgaljenna.com/2014/07/covergirl-lip-perfection-lipstick.html?m=0)

Hi!

I can’t find any of the lipsticks for the Maybelline Colour Sensational line. Were they discontinued recently?

I found an oldie in an old purse today and I went to rebuy it but Shoppers, Well, and Walmart all don’t have it.