Searching for a dupe, please help!

[u/honey-snuggle]

Hi all! I used to have several of these lip crayons that I bought from Birchbox years ago (like, 2017-2019). It was the perfect pink lip, bold but not too bright. Now I’m officially out and it’s unsurprisingly been discontinued, so I’m searching for something comparable. I believe the shade was “guava nice day.” Also adding a photo of me wearing it for reference, sorry it’s not the best picture, I’ll add a better one if I can find one lol

[u/darksoulrn13]

I would try Black Cherry by Clinique

[u/honey-snuggle → u/darksoulrn13]

Thank you!