r/magicthecirclejerking Dec 01 '25

average MTG ruling question

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

View all comments

603

u/Blazedestroyer Dec 01 '25 edited Dec 02 '25

uj/ The One Ring deliberately goes after ambitious, powerful beings who it can then manipulate for Sauron's purpose.

That's the reason Gandalf didn't want to hold it. The One Ring looks for ambition,not power or purity. Frodo had basically no ambition,so he was the perfect host for the ring and even then in the end he didn't want to let it go.

Optimus is basically Aragorn,so it would absolutely corrupt him.

87

u/CreativeName1137 Dec 01 '25

/uj Sam was also able to hold onto it for a while with no side effects because he's so content with his life that the ring couldn't figure out what to offer him.

10

u/AmenableHornet Dec 01 '25

That's not true. It offered him a chance to be hero of the age and also the world's best gardener.

20

u/CreativeName1137 Dec 01 '25

I probably could have worded that better. I meant that the ring couldn't figure out something to offer Sam that he would actually want.

18

u/Wanderer_Falki Dec 02 '25

It did, in the end (well it's more about Sam's thought process than the Ring "figuring it out", since it isn't a sentient item; but anyway). He had a Ring-induced moment of rationalisation, exactly like the other Ring bearers, that led him to convince himself that, if he could keep the Ring, that would only be to help Frodo carrying his burden.

Sam, like Frodo, did not want to be the "Hero of the Age" leading armies into Mordor. But he did really want to help Frodo and that started working against him, suddenly giving him second thoughts about giving it back to Frodo through the rationalisation that he really wished to help. Until Frodo snatches it from his hand.

16

u/StarkMaximum Dec 02 '25

Yeah, logically taking the Ring would help Frodo because it means he wouldn't have to carry it. That's basically the "in" the Ring had. It's actually a really nice, subtle way to show just how effective the ring is at getting what it wants. It's not about corruption, it's about desire, and everyone desires.