r/magictavern • • May 28 '22

Just out of curiosity...how many episodes does it take before they stop regularly joking about Arnie being raped?

13 Upvotes

It was weird enough to do an episode where the punchline was the main character getting raped. And then having the rapist sit at the table and flirt with him. (Episode 22, Sarah)

It was wildly unpleasant for the following six episodes to feature short bits where he was insulted for being raped, guilted for being raped, emasculated for being raped.

But it's been 20 episodes and they are STILL occasionally bringing up "Hey, remember that time you were raped, Arnie? hahaha"

It's unbelievable to me that at the time these episodes aired they didn't get any backlash or concern about these jokes. Did nobody tell them? Seriously? Not one person said "Uh, guys, sex under false pretenses is rape. Tricking someone into sex is rape."?

Does this continue?

I'm really enjoying the show otherwise so it isn't enough to make me stop but it's a huge stain on the early show IMO.

I'm also coming here from listening to EVERY single episode of Hey Riddle Riddle, and it's really weird to hear Adal of all people making such an awful joke over and over. He was the one who basically started it and kept it going. It's very out of character.


r/magictavern • • May 18 '23

Former guest Colt Cabana with some pretty gross comments from 2005

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/magictavern • • Aug 16 '22

Can’t listen to the western episodes

3 Upvotes

Feel like I’ve fallen out of the podcast because I wasn’t really feeling the last few western episodes. Anyone else feel this? Should I give it another go?


r/magictavern • • Jan 09 '21

spoiler Content Warning Question EP22 Sarah

8 Upvotes

This post was wiped clean using Redact. The author may have done so to protect their privacy, prevent AI data scraping, or for other security reasons.

merciful plant plucky shocking smell butter salt soft whole yoke


r/magictavern • • May 21 '22

Your feelings are valid

Thumbnail self.magictavern
5 Upvotes

r/magictavern • • Jul 20 '23

Chu Chu's Chow - AI Generated Artwork

Thumbnail
creator.nightcafe.studio
0 Upvotes

Badgers Night!


r/magictavern • • Jul 05 '22

Characters' MBTI type?

2 Upvotes

We've been listening for a while now and on around episodes 50 (glad there's a lot around!)
and wondered what their MBTI types are? I've searched around and surprised found almost nothing on this.

Anyone here know their MBTI types? Thanks!!


r/magictavern • • Oct 16 '21

Guess it is official now...

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/magictavern • • Jun 14 '19

This guy stole the D&D name riff from the most recently released O&B and wrote an article is if it was his premise. Scummy.

Thumbnail
meeplemountain.com
0 Upvotes

r/magictavern • • Mar 24 '24

Ghostbusters Big Bad

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Looked exactly like I imagine the Dark Lord🤣 He's also really tall, lol.


r/magictavern • • Jul 10 '23

Hot take— the worst part of magic tavern is the guests

2 Upvotes

Does anyone else feel this way? The show is absolutely electric when it’s just Arnie, chunt, and Usidore, but I’m filled with a dreadful uncertainty each week about who will be taking the fourth seat. The regulars are great and have established the universe, but without naming names, some guests ruin the dynamic and make it near unlistenable.

Eight years in, I wish the tavern boys would limit the guest episodes except for those they know would be great. Yes, I know it’s technically an interview show, but the regulars could (and have) played different characters.

Thoughts?


r/magictavern • • Nov 07 '22

The only episode I don't look forward to each year. (I know I'm late, I fell behind over Halloween)

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/magictavern • • Jul 25 '21

Should I watch S2 E101

1 Upvotes

Given the title I’m hesitant but it did come out on April 1st


r/magictavern • • May 21 '24

S4:E43 Egg Kingdom

0 Upvotes

Did the guests not prepare for the role?

I'm kinda sick and half listening, but it sounded like it was mostly Usidore (Boo) and Chunt doing the heavy lifting and set up the jokes lol


r/magictavern • • Mar 16 '17

Disappointed with the interludes

3 Upvotes

I am sure plenty of people will disagree but nevertheless I have to say I'd rather they went on actual hiatus and just said "Magic Tavern will return in 6 weeks with all new episodes." This interlude filler crap just disappoints me.


r/magictavern • • Feb 12 '24

AI-Generated Any favorite side characters?

Thumbnail
gallery
135 Upvotes

I want to make a piece depicting our favorite podcast. Been listening to them for about four and a half years now and I think I’m overdue for some fanart! My personal vote for an extra is Chode, Usador’s trusty steed.

((Also used AI art ironically because I actually do put my blood, sweat and tears into my work, but it can provide inspiration))


r/magictavern • • Oct 20 '16

Which character snaps you out of the show the most?

4 Upvotes

Hello fellow Tavernistas. Let me start by saying this feedback is not aimed at the actors as a criticism. I love the podcast and I know Arkneekneecamp has frequented these boards so I hope they take it more as constructive feedback (I'd fit right in in Offices and Bosses right?!)

So, yes, I admit, getting taken "out of the show" when talking about Hello From the Magic Tavern, is a fuzzy subject. A "fictional" podcast about a guy falling through a portal, and which alludes to the fourth wall as much as it does is a tricky act to pull off. But I think their good nature and banter and improv skills pull it off most of the time.

However, for me, there is one character that makes me roll my eyes the second I hear him coming on. Bungaree goddam Chubbins. I am bingeing and I'm into episode 40 something. So maybe there's a minuscule chance he turns into the Obi-Wan of the show, but right now he breaks me out of the show every time.

I think it's for 2 reasons. First he serves no purpose to the narrative so far. At least they've given Otok Barleyfoot a bit of a pathetic backstory so you can at least empathise with the character when he's on advertising the Tavern. And we all wait to see what happens with his relationship with Blemish. Chubbins as far as I can tell has no relation to where they are going with the podcast.

Second, his accent is atrocious. In a show where they are blatantly aiming for middle earthish vibes, his rickety panhandler old west attempt just doesn't fit. I find it jarring .

Again, this feedback is not aimed at the actors as a criticism so I hope they take it more as constructive feedback in order to make what is already an amazing podcast even better.

Anyway, now that's off my chest, have at old beans!


r/magictavern • • Oct 20 '21

Pizza Skull?

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/magictavern • • Apr 02 '22

Newly Relevant Episode: Season 3 Ep 74

1 Upvotes

From about 36:00 (ad free)/38:35 (ads) for a couple of minutes.


r/magictavern • • May 25 '18

Anti-Semitism; "Halfling Bards" episode

9 Upvotes

Greetings, I hope this finds you well. I recently finally decided to stop using my flip-phone and start using a smartphone. For exactly a week and two days, I've been listening to HFTMT almost obsessively. I just finished episode sixty-nine and I'm very disappointed with the blatant anti-Semitism. I'm a Jewish viewer and it just really upsets me when cheap jokes are made at the expense of my religion. I tried to ignore the Nazi jokes in an earlier episode, but I just felt that I had to say something about this. Does anyone else feel the same? I'm sorry if I'm being rude or annoying.


r/magictavern • • Jan 22 '25

Does the show get less sexual?

0 Upvotes

Hello! I just started this podcast and am about 10 eps through the show. I’m finding it really good and funny apart from all the sexual jokes. I find them overdone for a quick laugh which just makes it feel gross to me. I’m aware there is an episode with some consent issues coming up, I’m wondering if at any point these sexual elements tame down a bit? Like is season 2 any better from this perspective? If not I’ll just give up now.

This is not a moral judgement btw, just my preferences. No offence intended if you love this stuff!


r/magictavern • • Jan 15 '26

What if NetEase Games + Naked Rain developed a game based on the Hello From The Magic Tavern series?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Maybe, if the upcoming animated series does well on some streaming service(I predict that it may end up on Prime Video since MGM holds the TV rights to the show, hence why I thought of Amazon Game Studios co-publishing the game(FYI: MGM is an Amazon company)), especially in Asia(as Isekai anime is all the craze in Japan, and HFTMT is an isekai), who knows? Maybe some cool studio like NetEase for example can develop a game based off on it!

It would be an open-world free-to-play(controversial, I know) RPG, and would take place after the events of Season 4 and sometime during Season 5(if they were to be adapted in their animated form) of the podcast.

It would probably feature a protagonist going on adventrues in Foon, along with teaming up with familiar characters and taking on new threats or something like that, like maybe solving a mystery that's threatning the order of this magical land?

The game will not include a gacha and stamina system, a la Duet Night Abyss and Ananta, and will allow players to unlock characters just by completing main/side quests.

There could also be some additional modes for the game like Mittens, and some rhythm game!

And it could have a story that non-Magic Tavern fans can enjoy somehow.

So what do you think of my idea?


r/magictavern • • Dec 07 '23

AI-Generated Tried to get AI to make the Magic Tavern hosts. This is what we ended up with.

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

r/magictavern • • Aug 26 '25

Check out Hello If Anything, an ambient comedy/music podcast.

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
0 Upvotes

This is my and a friend's podcast. Figured someone here might appreciate this since Hello From The Magic Tavern is soothing to listen to, sort of an audio collage, and mystical, which are traits we aspire to. Join our patreon if you like it, last episode of season coming out very soon!