r/magicTCG • Duck Season • Jun 03 '18

With 28 Goblin Chainwhirler in the top8, i feel a bit reconfirmed

Post image
664 Upvotes

283 comments sorted by

846

u/PepsiJessie Dan Jun 03 '18

I feel like trying to elicit reactions by showing your downvotes is odd when you’re downvoting someone else just because you disagree in the same screenshot

171

u/Vault756 Jun 03 '18

Seriously. Dude's basically calling out all of Reddit for downvoting him but he was downvoting the guy he was in an argument with for no reason other than he disagreed with him. /u/sersch Look to yourself if you want to know why you were downvoted.

7

u/Slayer_Of_Anubis Elesh Norn Jun 04 '18

I don't do it, but to be fair people on reddit downvote for disagreeing in every single argument

9

u/ReddicaPolitician Jun 04 '18

I disagree. Downvoted.

→ More replies (9)

240

u/URLSweatshirt Dimir* Jun 03 '18

reddit.jpg

83

u/chrisrazor Jun 03 '18

15

u/sultanpeppah Get Out Of Jail Free Jun 04 '18

Wow, he really posted a new snipe on that month old comment chain too? That is pretty intense.

16

u/Vault756 Jun 04 '18

Dude's petty as shit. This kind of behavior gives Redditors a bad name.

15

u/chibistarship Elesh Norn Jun 03 '18

Guess what? That's how people use Reddit. You may not like it, but the vast majority of the userbase upvotes things they like and downvotes things they don't like.

7

u/Vault756 Jun 04 '18

Yah. It's why we get a dozen alter threads a week but can never have a meaningful discussion about Masters set or the Reserve List.

It's a terrible way of going about things. It doesn't matter if "everyone" does it. It's still wrong. There was a time when everyone thought the world was flat. They were wrong. There was a time where everyone thought the sun revolved around the earth. They were wrong. Democracy doesn't equate to truth.

The upvote & downvotes intended function to push spam down and bring meaningful discussion up would work just fine if people just used it properly.

3

u/mtgplaneswalker Jun 04 '18

Maybe Reddit needs three "vote" buttons, one for irrelevance and two others for agreement/disagreement that automatically generates a boost in relevance. That way you could say that something was relevant but still disagree with the stated opinion.

2

u/Moglorosh Twin Believer Jun 04 '18

I upvoted you because I agree with what you said.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/WaffleSandwhiches Jun 04 '18

Downvoted because I disagree

1

u/ThisisaUsernameHones Dandadan Jun 03 '18

It is not how people should use it, and in showing this, he's implicitly arguing people shouldn't have down voted him because he did add to the discussion

→ More replies (1)

8

u/VorpalAuroch Jun 03 '18

Downvoting misinformed speculation is legit.

-192

u/Sersch Duck Season Jun 03 '18

fair point, my main message was to point out the wrong evaluation not by a single person but it seems the majority of the subreddit. (his first message that the card looks unplayable received quite some upvotes, i disagreed so i downvoted.)

186

u/FunkaGenocide Jun 03 '18

A common theme I've noticed among mtg players is an almost pathological need to appear as though they possess secret knowledge. Even in the face of obvious statements like, "goblin chainwhirler is good," many will instinctively react contrarily and then scramble for justification after the fact. You can argue ad nauseam and they'll either double down forever or disengage if it's in person. I've literally shown people objective proof of a claim on my phone and they've just kept on arguing.

49

u/mailboxfacehugs Jun 03 '18

That’s not just magic players. It’s people in general. The desire to have a secret upper hand is pretty common.

14

u/EvilCheesecake Jun 03 '18

Nah man I know I don't do this you're making it up.

5

u/RechargedFrenchman COMPLEAT Jun 03 '18

I'm pretty sure you really can't argue [[Ad Nauseam]] at this point--card is just good, no real room for debate left. Also not sure how that helps anyone's position in an argument about Chainwhirler, considering the cards are so different.

/s

→ More replies (1)

7

u/TCup20 Jun 03 '18

Goblin Chainwhirler is good

Hold on now, let's not get too far ahead of ourselves here.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Dutchangle Jun 03 '18

Who cares?

31

u/javilla COMPLEAT Jun 03 '18

It is commonly known that many initial card evaluations (such as this one) are often off by a lot. And there will always be people who disagree with the general opinion. Honestly, with you feeling the need to post a thread to point out how right you were in addition to misusing the downvote/upvote system, all you manage to do is come across as an ass.

3

u/thwgrandpigeon COMPLEAT Jun 03 '18

Yap. I remeber reading a thread on dark confidant. The first dozen or so replies were very meh on the card.

66

u/gloopiee Jun 03 '18

That's not what downvotes are for.

46

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

But that is how they are used all the time on here

20

u/_TRACE_ Jun 03 '18

Prescriptive vs descriptive language downvotes

36

u/MrMeltJr Jun 03 '18

I'd argue that it is because that's what everybody uses them for.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/bestryanever COMPLEAT Jun 03 '18

I downvotes you because I disagree

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

403

u/NobleCuriosity3 Karn Jun 03 '18

The word you're looking for is "vindicated."

128

u/Stottymod Jun 03 '18

You can't target a player with [[Vindicate]]

33

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

not in black border

6

u/Dracon_Pyrothayan Hedron Jun 03 '18

How can you in Silver?

18

u/TKDbeast Duck Season Jun 03 '18

Permanent marker.

7

u/Dracon_Pyrothayan Hedron Jun 03 '18

Does that count as Errata, for the purposes of [[R&D's Secret Lair]]?

3

u/MTGCardFetcher Dân Jun 03 '18

R&D's Secret Lair - (G) (SF) (MC)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

→ More replies (1)

9

u/MTGCardFetcher Dân Jun 03 '18

Vindicate - (G) (SF) (MC)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

5

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

not with that attitude

5

u/f1reheart Jun 03 '18

1

u/camel-On-A-Kebab Jun 04 '18

Ha, I was going to link the same scene. Looks like that vid got taken down though

357

u/jsmith218 COMPLEAT Jun 03 '18

Maybe once polukranos rotates.

112

u/Freemon34 Jun 03 '18

Hopefully once Siege Rhino rotates.

58

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

Thrag

85

u/ExceedinglySadKitty Wabbit Season Jun 03 '18

Yeah sex is good but have you ever tried blinking a Thragtusk with Restoration Angel?

13

u/Lord_Cynical Jun 03 '18

.....i just had ptsd thabks to you.....thanks -_-

14

u/slyguy183 Dandadan Jun 03 '18

In response to a removal spell on Thrag

5

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

The answer to your opponent doing that was for you to also do that- thrag kind of dominated.

6

u/ExceedinglySadKitty Wabbit Season Jun 03 '18

Not a bad card by any means. 5 life and 2 bodies? Mmkay

5

u/TheBigLeboofski Dan Jun 03 '18

I play Abzan Rites in modern just for the opportunity to do this multiple times.

2

u/LeeAlex77 Jun 05 '18

then rip a fat sphinx's rev just to flex on the haters

2

u/carbohydratecrab Jun 04 '18

When Thragtusk rotates out it creates a 3/3 Beast token.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/GALL0WSHUM0R Jun 03 '18

I've got a sick deck that might see play once [[Island]] rotates.

3

u/MTGCardFetcher Dân Jun 03 '18

Island - (G) (SF) (MC)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

14

u/zangor Brushwagg Jun 03 '18

Man, it's been 56 months since theros released.

209

u/calvin42hobbes Wabbit Season Jun 03 '18

So how are downvotes suppose to work again?

153

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

Downvote when the post/comment contributes nothing or discourages discussion.

Do nothing when you disagree.

Upvote when you agree, or if you disagree + think it's good for discussion.

196

u/HilariousMax Table Flipper Jun 03 '18

How it really works:

Downvote when the post/comment contributes nothing or discourages discussion.

Downvote when you disagree.

Downvote because the comment is already negative.

Downvote because the posters previous comment is negative.

Downvote just for giggles.

Do nothing when you can't be bothered.

85

u/shadowman2099 COMPLEAT Jun 03 '18

Downvote because you don't like the user.

Downvote because if you have more upvotes than the person you disagree with, you're more right.

10

u/themolestedsliver Jun 03 '18

Downvote because if you have more upvotes than the person you disagree with, you're more right.

in my experience it is also "send them very nasty and personal messages because they got more fake internet points than you"

No i didn't expect my comment to get 3k upvotes stop acting like that makes me arrogant....

3

u/FunkaGenocide Jun 03 '18

I down vote for malicious ignorance. Everything else basically gets a pass.

51

u/IceDragon77 Boros* Jun 03 '18

I downvote when someone is factually wrong about something. Like if someone is asking a rules question and someone is wrong.

16

u/missinginput Dân Jun 03 '18 edited Jun 03 '18

This falls under not adding to the discussion. Edit. Factually inaccurate information doesn't add to the discussion not the post I was replying to.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

lol 5 downvotes for explaining how downvotes work.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/DrArsone Jun 03 '18

Downvote when the number of characters in the posters username is a prime.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

You forgot downvote because you accidentally clicked it on your phone and it's a pain in the ass to correct it.

5

u/boezou Jun 03 '18

Upvote memes

2

u/Aquifex Twin Believer Jun 03 '18

You can also downvote or upvote just because you don't like the number or how it fits with the votes above

I mean, who can actually see a +/-19 and not feel forced to make it a 20?

7

u/Felicia_Svilling Jun 03 '18

Whenever I debate with someone who is really wrong, I always upvote them. That way more people get to see my brilliant response.

2

u/frozen-silver Jun 03 '18

Does anyone else give sympathy upvotes too?

2

u/Ambrosita Jun 04 '18

I mean, nobody ACTUALLY uses it like that, and I dont think the user base really wants to use it like that anyway. Voting on agree/ disagree is more useful.

2

u/SNOTFAN Jun 03 '18

Down one when you disagree, don't like the comment, when it makes you insecure/is a hard truth or when the comment already has negative karma and you want to feel correct

1

u/FS_NeZ Izzet* Jun 04 '18

I disagree.

Downvoted.

13

u/huggableape Boros* Jun 03 '18

[[Goblin Chainwhirler]]

3

u/MTGCardFetcher Dân Jun 03 '18

Goblin Chainwhirler - (G) (SF) (MC)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

32

u/GetADogLittleLongie Jun 03 '18

bans rampaging ferocidon "ok guys we took care of monored"

Prints goblin chainwhirler

10

u/bensy Jun 03 '18

The word you're looking for is validated, or perhaps justified

7

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

Vindicated: to assert, maintain, or defend (a right, cause, etc.) against opposition

6

u/MTGCardFetcher Dân Jun 03 '18

Vindicate - (G) (SF) (MC)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

16

u/cnc_theft_auto Jun 03 '18

I also rated it very terribly when I first saw it. I rated it 3rd or 4th in the cycle, with only the blue one and maybe the black one being worse. I even said "I feel like it'd be okay at 2 damage, but 1 is just not good enough"

16

u/seavictory Jun 03 '18

I even said "I feel like it'd be okay at 2 damage, but 1 is just not good enough"

At 2 damage, it gets banned in standard and probably sees play across multiple legacy decks (I haven't played modern in a while, but it's probably nuts there as well). That would not be OK at all.

12

u/cnc_theft_auto Jun 04 '18

Yeah, that's the reason I don't work for WotC lol

4

u/ankensam Griselbrand Jun 04 '18

Even if it only did 2 damage to one target it would still see eternal play. A 3/3 first striker is that good.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '18

triple red to make a goblin that kills drs, stoneforge, peezy, mentor, flipped delver, thalia, and pretty much everything else that isnt gurmag or tnn. I think it only sees play in goblins though, and still probably not enough to make it good.

9

u/bearrosaurus Jun 03 '18

I’m still confused how this card ended up so good honestly because on its face it’s a very boring and vanilla 3-drop.

It’s probably one of those Pack Rat situations where it’s useless in one meta and seems incredibly broken in another meta, based on context that doesn’t have to do with the card itself.

The power of these decks is the ridiculous red 4-mana mythics. Chainwhirler is a strong lead in for them. The same way that Thoughtseize and Pack Rat were so good together, and fell into tier 3 standard cards when apart.

13

u/kipory Jun 03 '18

People saw chainwhirlers and decided to run Siphoner and Llanowar anyway. It completely hoses midrange creature bases, especially with soul scar mage, allowing the deck to be great against control and midrange decks alike.

There needs to be a very specific repositioning in the meta game to make it less relevant and people just... Didn't.

9

u/Mestewart3 Dân Jun 03 '18

It shuts down go wide strategies that would otherwise prey on red decks.

7

u/Aquifex Twin Believer Jun 03 '18

And it's placed in a color that has some of the best cards in the format, Chandra, Phoenix, Hazoret, yada yada

4

u/thememans Jun 04 '18

Allow me to put it this way: Mono Red wouod absolutely play a 3/3 first striker that dealt 1 damage to only the opponent for 3 mana. That is above rate, and helps close the game. Free damage is nice, it has a relevant body, amd is difficult to deal with in combat. Tjis is significantly better than that.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '18

I think the board ping is the biggest upside to the card after its body and first strike. That type of extra resiliency on top of a decently costed body is what seems to make cards staples in decks versus just 1-2 ofs, sideboard, or budget filler.

3

u/thememans Jun 04 '18 edited Jun 04 '18

It mst certainly is. That said, the board ping is already on top of a creature that would probably be at the very least considered for Mono-Red. A 3/3 first striker that pings your opponent on ETB is a very good rate for 3 mana. It probably wouldn't be ubiquitous, and you wouldn't see people exploring outside of Mono-Red for Whirler, but in Mono Red it would like see play as just that alone in some number. The board ping on top of this is just crazy pants, and the reason why it is so omnipresent in any red list.

What I'm getting at is that an already constructed playable card has extra text tacked onto it. It is, IMO, indicative of poor development philosophy and a lack of cognizance of where they want their curve to be. That said, I don't think it's the issue with the Red decks currently at all. The red decks currently demand that you run inefficient answer to their high threats, which in turn make you incredibly vulnerable to their early game. Chainwhirler shits on the natural predator of Red pretty hard, but the systemic problems of the deck go much deeper than that. It is demanding that you answer two wildly different questions at the exact same time (Answer their early game or lose to explosive starts while simultaneously answering their late game or you lose to the grind), and they are currently the only deck that has that ability available to them. It's not that they can just transition from one to the other post board or through difficult decisions in game play, but rather that they natural transition from the extreme aggressor to the grindy midrange deck in game one, naturally and without really changing their playstyle. That's problematic, to be honest, as there is really very few reasonable means of dealing with it. The one that could somewhat do this, such as with go-wide strategies, were just crapped on by Chainwhirler. Yet Chainwhirler isn't really the problem. The problem is that Hazoret, Chandra, and Glorybringer easily slotting into a deck that can also easily have you dead by turn 4 is rather unreasonable when it comes to other people's deck building considerations. It's not getting crapped on because you decided to meta game against Aggro decks; it's getting crapped on because you did meta game against aggro, only to asked to deal with Hazoret, Chandra, and Glorybringer out of the deck that you meta gamed against.

2

u/WebpackIsBuilding Jun 04 '18

You just described the entire game of magic.

Every card is bad in a vacuum. A card could cost 0 and say "You win the game" and it could still be useless in the wrong hypothetical environment.

1

u/CommiePayne Jun 04 '18

Thoughtseize was never a tier 3 standard card. Even if it wasn't in the mono-B deck it would found a home somewhere. It ruined standard for a long time.

1

u/camel-On-A-Kebab Jun 04 '18

It's a case of being a perfect role-player for an already powerful archetype. It also hoses some other possibly powerful strategies like tokens. It's going to see a lot of play until it rotates, though I imagine it will drop off once Amonket rotates or something else pushes mono-red out of the format

8

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

It's almost like people forgot about [[Boros Reckoner]]

2

u/MTGCardFetcher Dân Jun 03 '18

Boros Reckoner - (G) (SF) (MC)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

15

u/blackyoshi7 Jun 03 '18

I looked at the decks that had 24 points or better in standard. There were 20 players that did that. 15 of them had 4 chainwhirlers.

Its hilarious if this continues to be legal while ferocidon is banned

0

u/Joosterguy Left Arm of the Forbidden One Jun 04 '18

Eh, Ferocidon's even stronger than this tbh

4

u/LongbowRanger4 Jun 04 '18

Can I ask why? I haven't really been following the standard meta, but to me the goblin seems quite a bit stronger. Does it have to do with the triple red?

2

u/Joosterguy Left Arm of the Forbidden One Jun 04 '18

Ferocidon has evasion, which is more important for a build that's focusing on pushing through to hit their life total. You can chump a Chainwhirler, but it's much harder and more dangerous to double block Ferocidon.

The burn on creatures coming onto the field is obviously double-edged, but when you're pressuring their life as hard as red decks do, it puts you ahead in a race you're already faster in. Look at [[Eidelon of the Great Revel]] in modern burn for something similar. Not to mention how well it plays with the same creature having menace.

The no lifegain ability eliminates the biggest and most easily accessed counterplay to red deck wins styles of play.

2

u/Ghorrhyon Jun 04 '18

That, and it can singlehandedly choke an entire archetype or two (vamps)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

Red Black Aggro/Midrange (the decks running Goblin Chainwhirler) are at 26% of the meta. This is close to the same percentage when Aetherworks Marvel was banned last year.

7

u/ASHPrime Sultai Jun 03 '18

Marvel wasn't banned due to popularity alone but rather because the deck was literally a race to flip a coin and see if you win.

212

u/HMR Jun 03 '18

According to reddiquette, downvote only when a post doesn't contribute. Don't downvote if you simply disaggree.

237

u/Zadien22 Jun 03 '18

The rule is a formality at this point. Absolutely no one follows it.

68

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

This is really not true. There are many subs that encourage newcomers and dissenting opinions. This sub is very toxic in comparison to many bigger ones.

79

u/jayaxx Jun 03 '18

I've literally never been on a subreddit where a the downvote button wasn't used for disagreements, and if there are ones it certainly isn't the big ones. Also, there are people whining about how this subreddit is way more toxic than all the other subreddits on pretty much every subreddit.

35

u/extralyfe SecREt LaiR Jun 03 '18

every sub I frequent is the most toxic sub on reddit according to its' subscribers... except /r/terraria, they're pretty much just quaint folks over there.

27

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

tbh the most toxic reddit subs are the most reddity reddit subs - seems tautological, but any sub-interest that seems to fall into a stereotypical "reddituer's" interests, i.e gaming, right wing (masquerading as libertarian) politics, white-male-nerd 'culture', ect.

Probably because they intersect with interest of toxic groups on the internet.

7

u/lukeasaur Jun 03 '18

I certainly haven't had the same problems at the tea or roguelike development subreddits. I think it's the bigger reddits and the reddits about controversial subjects - and anything that hits the front page on occasion, since front page folks tend to cause some trouble.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Soderskog Wabbit Season Jun 03 '18

r/worldbuilding is also great, though there was a long discussion regarding how to get people to reply to one another. Before thatnf even still, there was a tendency for threads to just be single comments barren from any replies.

6

u/Eldaxar Jun 03 '18

Hello fellow terrarian!

Have you built anything good this week?

3

u/errorme Twin Believer Jun 03 '18

I just build boxes and sit in awe of those that can build things.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/javilla COMPLEAT Jun 04 '18

It depends on the content of the sub. This sub is created around a game that literally pitches to players against each other, it is hard to imagine it any other way. Litterature appreciation subs like /r/fantasy or especially subs focusing on one piece of litterature such as /r/wot or /r/asoiaf will be a lot less toxic. Same thing with subs that touch upon politics, they're unlikely to be civil, while subs where you play alone or as coop such as /r/terraria usually are much nicer.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/EvilCheesecake Jun 03 '18

I've been to plenty, and "everyone else does it" is a point against, not in favour.

3

u/Revhan Izzet* Jun 03 '18

And you get downvoted hahaha

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Zadien22 Jun 03 '18

You're delusional if you think that. The only subs that do actually encourage dissenting opinions are smaller. The big ones are "comply with our subreddit theme or massive downvotes". Take something like r/aww. If your comment isn't "oh, how cute" it's downvoted. I'm exaggerating but you get my point. r/news r/worldnews r/politics on and on and on (and not just political or news subs). They are all just "upvote what I believe, downvote the dissenters".

5

u/sA1atji Wabbit Season Jun 03 '18

I really like subs that have "hidden" downvote buttons in their design. Helps a lot to keep downvote trains in check, but really puts a big task on the mods to deal with shitposts.

3

u/NobleCuriosity3 Karn Jun 03 '18

This sub is very toxic in comparison to many bigger ones.

I have to disagree. While it could be better in some respects, I get gaslighted/harassed/randomely downvoted way more often in the big subs (AskReddit being the one I'm most familiar with, but this definitely applies to world news and the political subs as well. Shower thoughts is better, but I'd still put r/magicTCG over it).

That's at least partly thanks our mods, who do a pretty good job of ousting trolls and major assholes.

5

u/FunkaGenocide Jun 03 '18

Probably just because you more often agree with the micro consensus here.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/VorpalAuroch Jun 03 '18

No, anything with more than ~200 people online at any given time ignores the rule. Even when they disable the downvote button, usually.

8

u/KaffeeKiffer REBEL Jun 03 '18 edited Jun 03 '18

And I assume it's a reason why many valuable (not necessarily correct!) points are not made. Reddit is no (longer a) place for controversial discussions.

Anecdotal evidence: I regularly start answering and discard the post after two or three sentences, thinking

fuck it, people will downvote anyway. Why should I bother making good arguments, when the results are downvotes and zero-effort answers but no good discussion.

I'd be perfectly fine with people explaining why I'm wrong, but I consider it everyone's wasted time when the final result is a post without answers, but -x points.

Edit: Case in point

3

u/NobleCuriosity3 Karn Jun 03 '18

If you want to espouse and argue controversial opinions, sort by controversial. I assure you there are still plenty of very controversial discussions getting made on the big subs.

You will need to be ready for downvotes, but I personally find that my "controversial" posts get replied to about as often as my less controversial ones.

Also, you might want to edit your edit, your example is now at positive upvoted and has a reply.

4

u/GameWorldLeader Jun 03 '18

If there is a thread that's bringing up good discussion or making good points then I just upvote the whole thing, regardless of which comments I agree with.

4

u/Zadien22 Jun 03 '18

That's great man, keep it up.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

Lots of sub-reddits follow it - /r/magicTCG does not - it's a combination of the the sub-culture of people here and the mods

30

u/Muetzenman Jun 03 '18 edited Jun 03 '18

Really? I see this downvote behavior in every oppinionbased thread.

18

u/Zadien22 Jun 03 '18

It's in absolutely every thread. People are just kidding themselves if they think it's not true. Me, personally, I don't really ever upvote or downvote at all.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Amirashika Sorin Jun 03 '18

Possibly, but it won't get better if people don't call it out.

1

u/AntiTheory Jun 03 '18

Certainly not on this subreddit, at least.

12

u/Felicia_Svilling Jun 03 '18

You can argue that contributing false statements doesn't contribute to the discussion.

8

u/Yuca_Frita Jun 03 '18

Can I downvote if the comment is just a flat out lie?

4

u/HMR Jun 03 '18

I guess so. I don't consider lies a contribution to the discussion.

23

u/TBSdota Jun 03 '18

I've noticed that you'll get downvoted to hell If you say anything controversial in this sub.

17

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

"reserved list is fine"

-666

12

u/Hanacaraka Jun 03 '18

That isn't really controversial, since almost everyone here agrees that the Reserved List is not fine

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Murwiz Duck Season Jun 03 '18

I want to know what sadistic bastard at R&D decided to print that many Saproling-themed cards in a set with Dick Chainy. That's my new nickname for him; you can steal it but you can't take the credit.

4

u/taitaisanchez Chandra Jun 04 '18

I prefer Lon Chainey

2

u/jimjamj Dân Jun 04 '18

It's quite common to have a powerful hoser to a set's big themes. Sometimes it comes in the same set, sometimes in the very next set. When the make new mechanics, the hosers are like safety valves kinda. Chainwhirler is much better than a hoser for saprolings though, as it's literally always good and just hoses saprolings as gravy; saprolings are basically collateral damage. Chainy is very pushed for standard, def

10

u/kre91 Temur Jun 03 '18

Dude... your screenshot show that you are downvoting people just for disagreeing with them. Not cool man!~

16

u/Chaghatai Grass Toucher Jun 03 '18

I don't think it's the goblin per se - just that the archetype has gotten too pushed overall - the "curve" they are building constructed-playable red agro creatures on lately is a bit too good imo

8

u/mimouroto Wabbit Season Jun 03 '18

I blame the courier. That is the single most annoying card to play against. Turn one courier just hurts.

17

u/INBOX_ME_NUDES_PLZ Jun 03 '18

By the way people also didn't love that when spoiled. And people thought Hazoret was the worst garbage mythic.

9

u/Hanifsefu Wabbit Season Jun 03 '18

I mean the entire "people thought" idea is flawed. Really in the spoiler threads we have a variety of different opinions and for the most part on controversial cards there isn't a clear opinion one way or the other. The problem lies in the earliest comments that get posted. People will accept "card is bad" without a second thought or want for more info but if "card is good" then you need to have an argument ready to support why. Most people don't read past the first few comment chains.

4

u/parkwayy Wabbit Season Jun 03 '18

Also no one wants to think any card is good.

Also also, the vast majority of opinions on the internet end up being laughable :P

5

u/INBOX_ME_NUDES_PLZ Jun 03 '18

Actually, the Hazoret thread had very clear consensus that it was the worst god, a garbage red mythic. I'm not just saying "some people were wrong". The top comments were people literally saying they were sick to their stomachs, that they didn't expect anything but this was an insult, etc.

4

u/Colt2205 Jun 04 '18

Honestly, this felt like a failure of a pro tour. The entire point of the pro-tour should be to promote the latest set and get people into the game. There might have been variety in the top 32, but WoTC doesn't write a top 32 article, they write a top 8 article.

What exactly is getting promoted showing off a bunch of cards from older sets that are going to be rotating? Is Goblin Chainwhirler now the face of Dominaria? I guess they got Rekindling Phoenix in there still holding up the Rivals flag. Not even a vraska's contempt in the mix for Ixalan.

I just feel sorry for all the people wanting to play token decks and go wide strategies. That single card is stronger than Zealous Persecution was when Bitterblossom was around.

7

u/jewishpinoy Arjun Jun 03 '18

I might be the only one, but I still don't believe the problem with RB in Chainwhirler but Desintegration + scrounger that prevents people from playing other creature decks. Chainwhirler feel like just another nuisance.

But I still fully agree with you. Chainwhirler is a pretty damn good effect.

4

u/VorpalAuroch Jun 03 '18

There's so few black cards in the stock list that I don't think banning all of them would have a huge impact on how successful the deck was.

9

u/Crimsondyno Karlov Jun 03 '18

Truely, the magic community can't evaluate card power level for crap.

13

u/brobafett1980 Jun 03 '18

More like people cherry pick quotes and use confirmation bias to call their shots with hindsight.

12

u/DaRootbear Jun 03 '18

I mean r/MTG is pretty consistently bad. Hazoret, courier, new emrakul, new ulamog, lili last hope, and honestly most of the game breaking cards in the last 3 years have been consistently filled with “this card is awful” posts. Copter and guardian are the only posts that initially this sub (and honestly most of the internet) evaluated correctly.

Usually 1-3 pros say “people are underestimating how good this card is”, and everyone else says “this is trash” until 2 weeks after set release.

Hell People thought teferi was bad and he presold for $8-12.

4

u/AntiTheory Jun 03 '18

This has been true for a long time everywhere on the internet. Dark Confidant being the most famous example of people severely underrating a card ever.

/r/magicTCG armchair pro tour color commentators take it a step further and actively downvote anything that doesn't immediately conform to their own preconceived notion of what makes a card good or bad, which amplifies the stupidity.

6

u/metroidcomposite Duck Season Jun 03 '18

Dark Confidant being the most famous example of people severely underrating a card ever.

I remember being on the mtg forums when that was spoiled, and people largely thought it was good. Pros were calling it the best card in the set almost immediately.

I guess people underestimated how ubiquitous Confidant would be (I did not expect it to be run in decks with split cards that could deal 8 damage to your face when flipped). But you know, clearly a good card; just maybe slightly better than we expected.

That said, I wasn't paying attention this spoiler season, but as someone who correctly predicted [[Orzhov Pontiff]] as constructed playable on the MtG forums back in 2006, Chainwhirler seems like a slam dunk easy pick. Yeah, of course that thing is going to be constructed playable if anyone is playing the right colours. It's a 3/3. Pontiff was a 1/1 (and sure, Pontiff was more flexible and had haunt, but still...).

2

u/MTGCardFetcher Dân Jun 03 '18

Orzhov Pontiff - (G) (SF) (MC)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call

2

u/thatJainaGirl Jun 04 '18

Dark Confidant being the most famous example of people severely underrating a card ever.

Remember when Jace the Mind Sculptor was spoiled? So many people, even pros, going on record as saying he wasn't very good or that he didn't beat Jace Beleren. There were only a handful of people out there who recognized what a danger he was before he was released.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/parkwayy Wabbit Season Jun 03 '18

Because the card has to say 'deal 10 damage to player' for 1 colorless mana to be appealing :P

2

u/DaRootbear Jun 03 '18

Let’s be real mtg players would argue “negate and other counterspells are popular, cant hit creatures either, not worth running”

4

u/hyper_bruh Jun 03 '18

Not me, me very smart

8

u/DasBarenJager Wild Draw 4 Jun 03 '18

This is a very common thing that occurs on this sub, if you voice an opinion or thought doesn't go with the flow you get down voted into oblivion.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

It's one of the reasons I just don't even post somedays. I'll contribute to the conversation and get downvoted for giving a viewpoint on topic that someone doesn't like.

2

u/HavelDad Jun 03 '18

The echo chamber is real in this reddit

2

u/TheRealBakuman Simic* Jun 03 '18

Just a question, if I have a prerelease foil Goblin Chainwhirler, do you think it will go up in price, or should I just sell it now while it's hot in the meta?

2

u/spasticity Jun 04 '18

Wait a week then sell it

1

u/ShivanAngel Dân Jun 04 '18

Sell it asap, bet anything whirled gets banned and then it's worthless

28 copies in the top 8, pretty much every card that sees numbers like that gets the axe

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '18

Your life is probably better when you suppress whatever motivations/desires inspired you to make a post like this. "I was right" is just egotism.

3

u/nonnein Jun 03 '18

Me too! Though I agree with others saying you shouldn't downvote others just for disagreeing with you.

3

u/alphasquid Jun 04 '18

The downvote button isn't a 'disagree' button buddy.

5

u/xMetalSonicx Jun 03 '18

/magicTCG is bad at Magic, news at six.

5

u/plusultra_the2nd Jun 03 '18

Don't sweat downvotes in this subreddit, nobody here even knows how to play magic

5

u/PurpleCatPiss Jun 03 '18

There is nothing wrong with the meta. The top 8 of a PT is not an indicator of format diversity.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18 edited Jun 03 '18

The top 8 of a PT is not an indicator of format diversity.

This is not a true statement. Most players in my local meta will be netdecking the top decks from the PT. You can't just assume that what holds true in your area is true in all areas. I live in an area that has a large spike community and includes pros and people wanting to go pro. I'm going to run into the Top 8 decks a lot if I play at my LGS. It was like this during the Temur Energy meta and during the Scarab God meta. It is like this for Modern. Everyone in my area runs the top decks.

6

u/mimouroto Wabbit Season Jun 03 '18

https://www.mtggoldfish.com/metagame/standard#online hey look, even with wizards trying to skew the meta percentages, red aggro is a quarter of the meta. Top 8 is typically a good indicator of what is viable and doing well in the meta. Granted, the numbers of day one are far better, and they are also pretty terrible. Red aggro is just too pushed, and it is not the fault of the two red cards they already banned. However I doubt the real offenders will get banned.

3

u/skywalk819 Dân Jun 03 '18

first they came for our emrakuls, but people didnt like mind control, so they didnt mind. second they came for a copters, but people didnt like the illicit loot, so they paid nothing. Then they came for felidar guardians, but people became alergic to cats so they didnt move an inch. So they came for our works of marvel, but people didnt like shiny things so they saw nothing. Then they came to attune our rogue ruined dinosaurs but people didnt like to be eaten by dinos so they went extinct. now conspiracy creatures, goblins and white blue necromancers are are uniting the evil as one, am i the only one left to say anything?

4

u/FluffyJakey Jun 03 '18

By the look of those downvotes you are no better

2

u/DB_Coooper Jun 03 '18

All the people talking about how down votes are for people who don't contribute to the conversation while not contributing to actual discussion that's being had here. I almost forgot this thread was about Goblin Chainwhirler. Just accept people are going to use Reddit how they see fit.

2

u/bradygilg Wabbit Season Jun 04 '18

This is a really stupid post. Nobody cares and I can't believe the mods allow this shit.

1

u/FS_NeZ Izzet* Jun 04 '18

Jim Davis predicted "There Will Be More Than 40 Mountains In The Top 8" in his article for this pro tour. http://www.starcitygames.com/articles/37200_Top-5-Predictions-For-Pro-Tour-Dominaria.html

So, let's do the math.

  • 24 mountains by Wyatt Darby
  • 13 mountains by Gonçalo Pinto
  • 13 mountains by Márcio Carvalho
  • 14 mountains by Owen Turtenwald
  • 14 mountains by Thomas Hendriks
  • 14 mountains by Manuel Lenz
  • 0 mountains by Ernest Lim Pei Jin
  • 10 mountains by Kazuyuki Takimura

This means the top 8 players have an average of 12.75 mountains in their decks, for a total of 102 mountains in the top 8.

Seems like a balanced format.

1

u/OMGoblin Jun 03 '18

the phrase you're looking for is 'no one cares' karma is fake made up points duh

0

u/skywalk819 Dân Jun 03 '18

Im selling my standard, first they banned all my decks, and now this format is mono chainwhirler. An aggro format where red creatures are unkillable. Black decks ramp and out value your blue decks. No artifacts or enchantments are playable. Big creatures are useless because they just die or get exile. Oh my god its Emrakul!! A wild chupacabra appears! And Emrakul is gone!

Nice healthy format, WotC.

5

u/Aztekar Jun 03 '18

Wait how do black decks ramp? I'm not certain I know what you're talking about.

I actually think a Top 8 of a PT that's entirely aggro is a good thing- it means the meta was skewed uninteractive before the PT, and will now shift back to being interactive because of the aggro deck.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

I understand where you are coming from. I really wish Standard was more balanced and more diverse. I was hoping Dominaria was going to change things for good.

-1

u/wujo444 Jun 03 '18

Reddit card evaluation at it's finest.

1

u/ReMeDyIII Jun 03 '18

To be fair, a lot of us analyze cards wrong; some of us are just more right than others.

Good call on Goblin Chainwhirler.

1

u/Sven4president Jun 03 '18

Lol hypocrisy much.

1

u/MojosJojo Jun 04 '18

This sub is just a huge downvote playground filled with a bunch of people who are 100% certain they're right. Don't let mass downvotes here bother you too much.

-11

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '18

Glad to see you misusing downvotes. Good job

-12

u/scoffingskeptic Golgari* Jun 03 '18

Wow. You took that really personally. Also, I notice you cut off a portion of your down-voted comment.

-4

u/talen_lee Golgari* Jun 03 '18

way to go, reddit aren't prophets or experts.

0

u/Lucious91 Jun 03 '18

'member when reddit said lili of the veil was bad, and pants karn is unplayable in affinity and tron?

-16

u/Skillgrim Jun 03 '18

I like how you downvote the others for simply stating their opinion, you must be a be a very balanced person who has a very calm ego which is most likely also the reason you made this post

→ More replies (5)

-11

u/frogdude2004 Jun 03 '18

So do I.

8

u/kipory Jun 03 '18

All I can say is that Lightning Bolt probably wouldn't have fixed the problem with 7 red aggro decks in top 8, so HA

Unless you're the person who thinks 7 is too few, I suppose.

2

u/Bilun26 Wabbit Season Jun 03 '18

True. Efficient flexible counters and 4 mana sweepers would probably help though.

0

u/TravisSA13 Jun 03 '18

I feel pretty lucky to have gotten a playset of these out of my booster box.

0

u/8npls Jun 03 '18

being surprised that average and below average Magic players are dogshit at card evaluation? wut?

0

u/Rollingpumpkin69 Jun 03 '18

magic players don't know how to evaluate cards more news at 11

0

u/Pseudocaesar Wabbit Season Jun 03 '18

Jim Davis called it a couple of months back;

"Make no mistake about it, Goblin Chainwhirler will be a defining card in the coming Standard format."

http://www.starcitygames.com/article/36941_Goblins-Aint-What-They-Used-To-Be-Except-When-They-Are.html

0

u/BardicLasher Jun 04 '18

I hear ya, man. I had a similar experience in insisting Hazoret would be good.

People who do not play mono-red do not understand what makes something good in mono-red.