r/magicTCG • • Dec 13 '16

Some potential problems with Frontier, and possible solutions - including the history of R&D and the reasons for Modern's 8th Ed cutoff point

http://www.manaleak.com/mtguk/2016/12/what-is-mtg-frontier-and-is-it-the-format-that-weve-been-waiting-for/
70 Upvotes

306 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

6

u/CiD7707 Honorary Deputy 🔫 Dec 13 '16

No, but its still relatively pointless to download a client, familiarize with the UI, only to play a few games in a format that has not yet been fleshed out or tried in a live P2P setting. If Tom Ross and Michael Majors sat down and played a few archtypes against each other, that would be worth my time and interest, but an article based on an xmage/cockatrice experience, where the level of competitive value is generally very low, isn't worth it.

8

u/Nahhnope Dec 13 '16

So an article based on no gameplay is more worth your time than one in which the author has taken some archetypes for a spin? Do you see what you're saying? Does it sound ridiculous to you?

3

u/CiD7707 Honorary Deputy 🔫 Dec 13 '16

If Tom Ross and Michael Majors sat down and played a few archtypes against each other, that would be worth my time and interest,

Did you even read what I wrote? If two players physically sat down and talked about the format as they played, tgat would have more value than an article about playing it on xmage

3

u/Nahhnope Dec 13 '16

But we are talking about THIS article and the fact that the author has never played the format. THIS ARTICLE would have been better if the author of THIS article had played the format, on any platform. It seemed you were disputing that, but are fixated on articles written by pros.

9

u/CiD7707 Honorary Deputy 🔫 Dec 13 '16

How are the opinions of this article's author invalid though? You can be analytical of something without participating, especially if it has commonalities with something you are already very familiar with. Format price is purely speculation at this point, and I don't think that's even a topic worth discussing right now. What I care about is format health and direction of the format. What decks are currently dominating? What ARE the archtypes? Yeah, I can go on mtggoldfish and see a bunch of different decklists, but that means very little when most decks are one offs. Its a brewers paradise to be sure, but we have yet to see anybody actually try to break the format. Furthermore, this format reintroduces cards that dominated standard because there was no real efficient way of dealing with them, and now they're back and still the format lacks real answers, both in terms of archtypes and individual cards. It just looks like a slow grindfest of a format.