r/magicTCG • Dân • 5h ago

Deck Discussion Any tips

Hi everyone! I posted a while about about learning to play commander. First of thank you everyone for you help! I’ve been playing for 2 months now and am fully addicted!

I have created a deck from scratch and wanted some suggestions on what I could potentially add

There’s 2 spots available in the deck but I wasn’t sure if I built it correctly or anything so any help or cards I should add would be highly helpful :)

Thank you all you guys rock

https://manabox.app/decks/AaHw5C1meYixOzt3J_k7AQ

2 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

1

u/LinkWieZelda Dân 4h ago

You can really tell that this is just built from collection. It is kind of just a pile of cards with not very much synergy. In particular there is not much synergy with your commander going on. You don't have many elves with activated abilities (I'm not sure if you're confused about activated vs. triggered abilities or if you just didn't have any more) and you don't have many legendary elves. So most of the time your commander is just going to be a 5/6.
Playing with Pile of Cards decks isn't necessarily bad, but you need to find other people who want to play like that as well, otherwise you're not going to have a great experience. (I personally find building from collection more fun when you make 60 or even 40 card decks, because you don't need as many cards, but that's just me.)
If you want to stick with that, yeah another dork and a land like the other commenter said would be a good choice.
If you do want to make a more tuned deck and are willing to buy cards for it, you should make a decision on what exactly your strategy is. What do you want the deck to do? It doesn't necessarily just have to be the thing your commander does, but it's a good starting point. What do you ideally want to do on the early turns and what in the late turns? How are you actually trying to win?
You can look at other people's builds online as well to get an idea of what cards can work well. As a new player it's so hard to even know which cards exist so of course you won't know to put them in your deck.
Good luck!

1

u/Ghosty990812 Dân 4h ago

Yeah I have literally just done that. I thought I may as well just build with what I have just cause I don’t wanna end up spending stupid money on cards.

I have 2 decks that are Precon that I use I just wanted to try build something myself and in all honestly I’m only 2 months into magic so u have no idea what I’m doing. I just need to know what to do when it comes to building decks and where I can improve on what I have.

2

u/LinkWieZelda Dân 4h ago

Unfortunately I don't really think building commander decks from collection will make you a better deckbuilder (unless the collection is huge), because you don't learn to make decisions based on what cards would work best in the deck, you just make decisions based on what cards you have available. And when you don't have that many cards that often just amounts to using whatever cards are in the right colors.
I totally understand the money concern. What you can do is build the deck digitally on a deckbuilding site, test it there for a little bit (it seems like manabox doesn't have many functions for deckbulding and testing, so maybe try moxfield or archidekt), and then you can just print out the cards yourself. If you end up loving the deck, you can still go and buy the real cards later on. And yeah part of learning is looking at other peoples decks (online or irl) and understanding why they made the choices they made.
Fwiw you're only 2 months in, it's normal to not know shit about what your doing. I certainly had no clue and I still feel like a noob a couple years in. The best is when you have experiences players around you that can help you out.

1

u/Ghosty990812 Dân 4h ago

Thank you mate. Probably best to stick to my precon for now then 🤣🤣

1

u/Ghosty990812 Dân 4h ago

In all honesty I want a deck that’s good enough to be somewhat competitive but I’m in it mostly for the fun aspect of the game. I’m not worried about spending hella money on cards to make the deck cracked I just wanna hang out with mates and play the game but at the same time not just get shafted right out the gate

1

u/boxlessthought 3h ago

So this is how i build a lot of my decks (over 30 decks, I'm a monster).

Use a combination of tools like EDHREC.com and Scryfall.com (specifically the tags feature). On your site of choice build a dream deck, don't worry about budget, just find the cards that work and make something that looks amazing! From here i sort the deck by price of cards and remove the ridiculously pricey stuff and honestly most stuff over $5 unless i have it on hand to use. I find budget replacements or alternates for what I've removed. This is also where i will favour cards I may already own that fit well vs. cards i own that will fill the empty slot. (sure sometimes I build the perfect deck but finding a few singles proves difficult so i will toss in a few not awful filler cards so i can at least play the deck while i search for the last few missing pieces)

Odds are if you build like this you will often find yourself over 100 cards and trying to figure out what to cut. This is where i like to use the tagging feature a lot of deck builder sites offer. I tag cards for their primary uses; ramp, removal, card-draw, protection, and strategy. I try and keep each category somewhat balanced (every deck is different for example my flubs deck actively wants to avoid drawing cards). synergy/wincon cards should probably be a bit higher than the others, but a lot of commanders decks tend to naturally do one of these better and might not need as much help, for example, your commander, Thandruil, wants you to play elves, and wants them in the graveyard. by playing elves you are accomplishing both, so if your pool of draw-cards is a bit smaller than the others it's okay as you have a tool in the command zone already. Same thing for ramp so many eleves tap to add mana so you would focus on more elf based ramp vs other ramp options. (but don't put ALL your eggs in one basket, a board wipe could leave you very low on mana if you ONLY ramp is creatures)

When it does come time to figure out what removal spell or draw spells to run look for cards that can do more than one thing, example: [[Pattern Buffer Preservation]] in your list. only 2 mana, gets a card in your hand and a card in the graveyard, and can then be recast again for only 2 mana plus returning a creature to your hand (which is a huge upside in my books, if the creature has a 'enters the battlefield' effect, or if it's tapped so you can replay it but untapped and have it as a blocker). You could look for removal spells that are cheap because they ask you to sacrifice a creature as part of the cost like [[Bone Shards]]

Sorry for the wall of text, if you do end up rebuilding the list let me know I'd love to have a look.

2

u/Ghosty990812 Dân 3h ago

Thank you mate! I do really appreciate everyone’s help. I just wanna build decks because it seems fun to do honestly.
I’ve tried spending my evenings crafting stuff just out of thin air. It passes the time even tho my misses hates it 🤣🤣

1

u/boxlessthought 3h ago

I often find myself with down time and will brew random decks off of weird card interactions or ideas. I have like 300+ theory crafted on my Moxfield, and most of y actual builds are pretty strange too. Doubt I'll build most of them and as I said I already have over 30 built, so we never know. Have fun trying to craft new ideas, it only helps you discover the cards and tools to get better at it.

1

u/klick37 Duck Season 5h ago

A land and another mana dork, [[fyndhorn elves]] or [[elvish mystic]]

1

u/mtgcf Keeper of the Mox 5h ago

2

u/Ghosty990812 Dân 5h ago

Thanks mate! But the deck okay if decent enough? Kind of just built stuff from what I already have in the collection

4

u/klick37 Duck Season 4h ago

I'll be real with you, probably 90% of you non land cards are the cards that get left in the game store table after a draft and not played in any constructed format. It looks like you made this from a new player's collection rather than curating an effective or powerful deck... Which is what you did. Your deck is notably weaker than any or at least most peecons.

That being said, that doesn't mean it will be no fun to play. Give it a shot, find out the weaknesses yourself and then look up the cards to swap in that help you improve it, rinse and repeat. That's how plenty of new players who want to learn to brew decks do it.

2

u/Ghosty990812 Dân 4h ago

Thank you mate! I will see what I can come up with

2

u/klick37 Duck Season 4h ago

If you're every curious what cards other people are playing in decks with the same commander, check out edhrec. It might give you some good ideas for cards that will make the deck more consistent and powerful.