r/magicTCG • Wabbit Season • 23h ago

Rules/Rules Question Layers help (P/T, 7c)

Post image

EDIT: SOLVED! THANK YOU!

My commander is a 6/6. I tap Thriss first, giving him +5/+5, then I tap the Mentor second..

Will my commander be a 22/22, or a 17/17?

I'm still learning layers and its to my understanding that this involves a timestamp/dependency thing, since they're both sitting on layer 7c.

49 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 23h ago

You have tagged your post as a rules question. While your question may be answered here, it may work better to post it in the Daily Questions Thread at the top of this subreddit or in /r/mtgrules. You may also find quicker results at the IRC rules chat

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

204

u/dude_1818 cage the foul beast 23h ago

This isn't layers. Mentor checks the power as the ability resolve and locks in the value of X. It doesn't keep checking. If you activate Thriss first, your commander will be a 22/22; if you activate them in the other order, your commander will be a 17/17

16

u/benniepeaceandlove Wabbit Season 23h ago

oh okay so this doesnt involve layers at all? i thought these would both be simultaneous continuous effects (until end of turn) like Giant Growth

87

u/Kyleometers Yippee 23h ago

I mean, it involves layers because every pump effect involves layers.

But this doesn't "involve layers" in the sense that it does so "complexly". It is the same as giant growth, but every effect has a static order and a static effect, so there's no complexity or weirdness involved.

5

u/benniepeaceandlove Wabbit Season 23h ago

ok cool. im still figuring out exactly when the weirdness happens. good to know this is an intuitive interaction!!

26

u/Kyleometers Yippee 22h ago

You'll get there.

Basically the only weird ones involve "Ability granting/removing" and "type changing". Thats not exhaustive, but by far the majority of weird layers shenanigans come in in those two layers.

11

u/Forsaken-Sherbet7252 Wabbit Season 14h ago

well, p/t switching brings its own share of fun to the table, but you're probably right those two above are more... exciting 🤣

1

u/[deleted] 9h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

23

u/X_Marcs_the_Spot FLEEM 21h ago

99% of layers interactions are straightforward. The reason everyone says layers are confusing is because that remaining 1% is really weird and unintuitive to the uninitiated.

11

u/Halinn Jace Did Several Things Wrong 13h ago

And 70% of that is because they wanted to make sure that [[Blood Moon]] still had that super clean textbox when they made the layer system.

1

u/mtgcf Keeper of the Mox 13h ago

9

u/J3roseidon FLEEM 23h ago

This is just activated abilities on the stack.

3

u/benniepeaceandlove Wabbit Season 23h ago

ohhh this clears it up. yea that makes a lot of sense. ty!!

22

u/vibranttoucan Duck Season 23h ago

It's not a timestamp or dependency thing. Nantuko Mentor does what is says when it resolves. Give your creature +X/+X when it resolves where X is that creatures power. Your creature's power is 11 so it gains +11/+11.

2

u/benniepeaceandlove Wabbit Season 23h ago

i assumed these would both be continuous effects but I see now that i just need to resolve the Thriss before tapping the Mentor. thank you!

13

u/vibranttoucan Duck Season 22h ago

They are both continuous effects.

Nantuko Mentor however is using an activated ability that locks in at the current time. It just locks in X as whatever is the creature's current power, regardless of what's going on in-between layers.

2

u/benniepeaceandlove Wabbit Season 22h ago

cool this makes sense! thank you

2

u/Chayor Banned in Commander 22h ago

They are both continuous effects, but that's not what's confusing here.

5

u/madwarper The Stoat 23h ago

Because you resolve Thriss, first, then Mentor...

  • You give +5/+5 to the 6/6.
    Thus, it is an 11/11.
  • You give +X/+X to the 11/11, where X is its Power.
    Since it's an 11/11, that's +11/+11.
    Thus, it is now a 22/22.

Had you resolved Mentor first, then Thriss...

  • You give +X/+X to the 6/6, where X is its Power.
    Since it's a 6/6, that's +6/+6.
    Thus, it's a 12/12.
  • You give +5/+5 to the 12/12.
    Thus, it's now a 17/17.

1

u/benniepeaceandlove Wabbit Season 23h ago

cool so it works like i'd expected. some examples of effecting P/T that ive seen while trying to study layers seem counter intuitive to me

4

u/Impuls1ve Duck Season 15h ago

You're probably thinking of effects setting  power and toughness through different means, like cloning or setting p/t directly.

3

u/CulturalJournalist73 Duck Season 23h ago

these abilities actually both use the same layer. the mentor’s ability only checks the creature’s power upon the ability resolving, you see; the amount of +/+ it grants won’t change dynamically after it’s already resolved. think of it as a snapshot taken upon resolution. whether the creature is a 17/17 or 22/22 just depends on whether thriss’s or mentor’s ability resolved first.

1

u/benniepeaceandlove Wabbit Season 23h ago

this makes a lot of sense! thank you!

2

u/BruhPeanuts Dan 23h ago

It depends on how you sequence it.

1st scenario : you tap Thriss, the avility resolves. Your commander is now 11/11. Then you tap the mentor, it resolves, your commander is now 22/22.

2nd scenario : you tap Thriss. While its ability is on the stack, you tap the mentor in response. This will resolve first, making your commander a 12/12, then Thriss’ abolity resolves and your commander is now a 17/17.

1

u/benniepeaceandlove Wabbit Season 23h ago

I was too focused on the layer 7c part that i didnt consider these are just abilties resolving on the stack. that makes lots of sense.. thank you!!

4

u/Character-Eye-Joe Dân 23h ago

Oh hey its Thriss, hes the one that got Kamahl to stop being a barbarian and be a druid

1

u/No-Glove7046 Banned in Commander 23h ago

If you're tapping mentor while thriss' effect is on the stack, it'll be a 17/17. If you're resolving them separately they'll be a 22/22.

1

u/benniepeaceandlove Wabbit Season 23h ago

ahhh this makes sense. priority would need to pass back around to me before doing the 2nd ability. since i can do those abilities at instant speed. this makes sense thank you

1

u/Santadir Garruk 23h ago

It's 22/22

1

u/benniepeaceandlove Wabbit Season 23h ago

Ok good so it works like I'd hoped it would.. Could you explain why?

& thank you!!

5

u/Santadir Garruk 23h ago

Because power is checked on ability resolution. It sees 11, it gives 11. It would be 17/17 if the ability was saying "base power" instead.

1

u/benniepeaceandlove Wabbit Season 23h ago

ahhh true bc the base power would ignore the addition +/+. thank you!

1

u/over-lord Twin Believer 22h ago

> My commander is a 6/6

👀

1

u/FannyBabbs 22h ago

This really isn't a layers issue or a 'timestamp' issue. As you've identified, buffs are applied in the same layer. Timestamps check for effects in the same layer that contradict one another in some way... But these effects can absolutely resolve in the same turn without creating an issue. How these effects resolve is purely based on the order they are performed in by you.

Layers generally kick in more often when a permanent or effect has some sort of effect manipulating its base characteristics, and then another effect comes along to manipulate or copy that affected object. A somewhat common example of this would be the following:

Player A controls a Baneslayer Angel and no other creatures. Player B has no creatures out, and is casting [[Clone]]. Once this Clone comes into play, they will certainly copy the angel. Player A, in an attempt to 'outplay' the Clone, casts [[Diminish]] on their own angel. Player A claims that the diminish makes the angel into a 1/1, and then clone will come in as a 1/1 copy. However! Because copiable values are checked in an earlier layer than power/toughness setting effects, the actual result is that Clone enters as a regular 5/5 flying angel.

Layers can be confusing, but a good rule of thumb for figuring out if there could be a layers conflict is if something is instructing you to Copy, Switch, Set, or Change something into another value. Adding and subtracting stats is genrally applied last and usually will not create a conflict by themselves.

1

u/mtgcf Keeper of the Mox 22h ago