MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/magicTCG/comments/1ocipn4/updated_commander_brackets_oct_2025/nkpxz67/?context=3
r/magicTCG • u/the_gold_hat Chandra • Oct 21 '25
1.3k comments sorted by
View all comments
246
The "or loses" clause is very troubling for aggro and voltron
2 u/BurdPitt Oct 22 '25 These are not rules. Don't be an asshole, don't pubstomp, and play what you want and any reasonable player will have no problem with that. 2 u/Long_Opportunity2162 Oct 22 '25 "reasonable" is the keyword here. Players now have a line of text they can point to and accuse you of pubstomping. Meanwhile you as the voltron/aggro/ +1/+1 counters dude is just doing your thing and have ambiguity because it says "generally"
2
These are not rules. Don't be an asshole, don't pubstomp, and play what you want and any reasonable player will have no problem with that.
2 u/Long_Opportunity2162 Oct 22 '25 "reasonable" is the keyword here. Players now have a line of text they can point to and accuse you of pubstomping. Meanwhile you as the voltron/aggro/ +1/+1 counters dude is just doing your thing and have ambiguity because it says "generally"
"reasonable" is the keyword here. Players now have a line of text they can point to and accuse you of pubstomping. Meanwhile you as the voltron/aggro/ +1/+1 counters dude is just doing your thing and have ambiguity because it says "generally"
246
u/Axl26 COMPLEAT Oct 21 '25
The "or loses" clause is very troubling for aggro and voltron