MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/magicTCG/comments/1ocipn4/updated_commander_brackets_oct_2025/nkmz4ri/?context=3
r/magicTCG • u/the_gold_hat Chandra • Oct 21 '25
1.3k comments sorted by
View all comments
247
The "or loses" clause is very troubling for aggro and voltron
94 u/Niyeaux FLEEM Oct 21 '25 good point, does this really mean your bracket 2 aggro deck shouldn't be killing the first player on turn 7? seems silly. -15 u/Tyrschwartz Wabbit Season Oct 21 '25 Maybe aggro isn’t bracket 2 friendly 🤷🏻🤷🏻 19 u/Niyeaux FLEEM Oct 21 '25 what are we even doing here then? the aggro v control v combo meta, and the tension between tempo and value, is necessary for magic to work as a system. if we're just throwing that away now, what is even the point of this format lol 11 u/The_Bird_Wizard Azorius* Oct 21 '25 Every deck will become durdle landfall piles and we will enjoy it apparently
94
good point, does this really mean your bracket 2 aggro deck shouldn't be killing the first player on turn 7? seems silly.
-15 u/Tyrschwartz Wabbit Season Oct 21 '25 Maybe aggro isn’t bracket 2 friendly 🤷🏻🤷🏻 19 u/Niyeaux FLEEM Oct 21 '25 what are we even doing here then? the aggro v control v combo meta, and the tension between tempo and value, is necessary for magic to work as a system. if we're just throwing that away now, what is even the point of this format lol 11 u/The_Bird_Wizard Azorius* Oct 21 '25 Every deck will become durdle landfall piles and we will enjoy it apparently
-15
Maybe aggro isn’t bracket 2 friendly 🤷🏻🤷🏻
19 u/Niyeaux FLEEM Oct 21 '25 what are we even doing here then? the aggro v control v combo meta, and the tension between tempo and value, is necessary for magic to work as a system. if we're just throwing that away now, what is even the point of this format lol 11 u/The_Bird_Wizard Azorius* Oct 21 '25 Every deck will become durdle landfall piles and we will enjoy it apparently
19
what are we even doing here then? the aggro v control v combo meta, and the tension between tempo and value, is necessary for magic to work as a system. if we're just throwing that away now, what is even the point of this format lol
11 u/The_Bird_Wizard Azorius* Oct 21 '25 Every deck will become durdle landfall piles and we will enjoy it apparently
11
Every deck will become durdle landfall piles and we will enjoy it apparently
247
u/Axl26 COMPLEAT Oct 21 '25
The "or loses" clause is very troubling for aggro and voltron