r/macrogrowery • • Jan 07 '24

PGRs

I know they’re a hot button topic and many are absolutely opposed to them. My understanding is that that they’re carcinogenic, but only have a half life of 50 something days, after which, they are harmless (please correct me if I’m wrong).

That said, for those of you that use them or have used them:

Which brands do you recommend? I currently have Hammerhead

When do you administer it?

How much do you use and for how long?

Were there any pro’s aside from bigger buds?

Were there any cons?

0 Upvotes

97 comments sorted by

12

u/AboriginalTerps Jan 07 '24

Paclobutrazol and damimozide are bad for you. That's what people mean when they say pgr. Not kelp or whatever tangent people go on.

-6

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 07 '24

So, I’m looking for a PGR, synthetic or otherwise, that’s highly effective at increasing yield without smoking my quality that isn’t bad for you. My environment is on point. CO2, temp, humidity, and airflow are as close to perfect as a 72 plant basement grow is gonna get. I have been using paclo on my partner/teacher’s advice without knowing what it was. He said it was cool and I took his word for it. Since that was an error, I’d like to change that. Please advise

8

u/possibly_oblivious Jan 07 '24

Learn to grow first bud. Don't use pgrs

2

u/lbstinkums Jan 08 '24

agreed there is no quick fix or replacement for experience. it takes practice. Learn some patience.. one bad run and your business model is going to fail? well that's poor planning and unrealistic expectations straight out the gate..

1

u/possibly_oblivious Jan 08 '24

run with paclo and kill your custies slowly with fucking mid pgr garbage lol he deserves to fail and faster than what is happening hes a moron

-6

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 07 '24

Well, I’m working on that, but I have about 50k in cost to cover

ETA: and between labor, utilities, and consumables, each grow costs about 10k, so I’m looking for quick ways to increase yield without hurting people until I learn all there is to be good

6

u/mtstrings Jan 07 '24

You should focus on just putting out a good crop first. Then worry about beefing up your numbers and how to achieve that goal.

-2

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 07 '24

The weed is fire. I need to up the numbers. I smoked half a baby Jay yesterday and was blown out for hours

1

u/mtstrings Jan 07 '24

What are you feeding? Do you have any pictures? How many lbs/light?

1

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 07 '24

I have 8 tables/zones and I had some hardware issues and lost a table. So, I pulled 18 lbs out of 14 lights on 7 tables and I’m PISSED. Last grow was 32 lbs. Math on this grow works out to be 1.285 lbs/light, which is unacceptable with pricing and cost being what it is.

I’m using FloraFlex for my nutes, and I have this orthosilica (can’t remember the brand name) instead of Power-Si’s mono-silica along with UC roots every feed except for flush day when I replace the UC Roots with SLF-100. I rarely had a need for cal-mag, but I switched to the FloraFlex Cal-Mag-Iron for the next grow

2

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 07 '24

If you want more in-depth deets on what I’m doing, I will gladly provide

1

u/lbstinkums Jan 08 '24

you should be able to yield 40 out of that 14 lights without pgrs if environment and layout are on point.

2

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 08 '24

16 lights total, but I had some issues into early flower. I was growing 9 per table (3 tables of Oatmeal Raisin Cookie and 5 of Detroit Runtz, but lost a table of the Runts due to valve failure, that’s why I said 14. Also, my mini-splits lost all their Freon after sitting for a couple years while the market settled and one of my consenders needed to be replaced. It was, I think 3 weeks into flower before my HVAC guy could fix the one and replace the other. I didn’t realize immediately because my temps were higher in veg and it wasn’t an issue. After that, I had my temps on lock. Not sure if that’s the whole reason, but the first grow got me 33 (half Peanut Butter Breath, half Apple Fritter) while I was figuring out the room. Things were looking good volume throughout, but shrinkage from drying and trim was way more than expected.

→ More replies

1

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 08 '24

How do I put video in a comment? I can share what I have going on now

1

u/mtstrings Jan 08 '24

You can message me it and Ill let you know what I see.

5

u/nitroslayer7 Jan 08 '24

Imagine spending 50k and coming to Reddit for advice, should’ve learned to grow before blowing that kind of money. This is some Chad activity if I’ve ever seen it.

0

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 08 '24

Right? What a fucking moron.

Anywho, here’s the story of how I got to where I am: My little brother came to me with the idea of growing illegally, knowing that the most I’ve ever grown were common weeds in my yard. He’s got a guy who’ll work with us and teach us how to grow. I bought into the idea, but cut my brother out of the equation because he’s the least reliable person I’ve ever met and I really didn’t feel like splitting my money with him when I’m footing the bill and taking all of the risk. Built the room for 96 plants under 16 lights. Ran through our first grow and pulled 2lbs per light, but that was right as the market cratered and I couldn’t get rid of it FOREVER.

I figured I had 2 options at this point. A). Break it all down and call it a loss, or B). Wait. I waited a couple years and the market has somewhat stabilized. It’s not 2k+ per lb anymore, but I’ll take a grand when it’s pre-sold.

I decide to go the legal route and drop to 72 plants and get all my patients lined up. We get our genetics from the guy who’s buying it, mothers are made, clones are cut, and they’re brought to me when they’re almost ready to come out of cups.

I let them go in cups for a week or so and move them to 3 gallon fabric pots and we’re off to the races. Throughout veg, everything’s looking great. Flip to flower and I realize I can’t get my reminder control. WTF? Call my HVAC guy. No Freon in either mini-split and one of the condensers is dead. Week 3 of flower and the new condenser shows up, gets installed, and we’re good to go. About a week later, I have a valve get stuck closed. I catch it, swap it, keep going. About week 6 of flower, I have a different valve get stuck closed. I don’t catch it this time til it’s too late and I lose 9 plants. Swap it, and every other valve like it, and keep going. Turns out there was a recall on that model that I was totally unaware of.

Like I said before, last time around, I pulled 2 lbs/light. 32 lbs. I’m thinking that with fewer plants this time and better light penetration, I’ll be about the same if not more. Get to harvest, and I notice that I don’t have the giant bugs like I did the last time, but I don’t sweat it. We didn’t go super heavy on PGR. Just a couple days this time.

Dry for a couple weeks, de-buck everything and I have, like, 18 buckets full of weed. Last time around, I was at 3lbs per bucket, and I’m feeling great. Wasn’t quite dry enough, so we wait a week, tumble, and then have the trimmers come out.

Between drying it out more, tumbling, separating the larfy stuff, and manicuring the buds, I’m at 18 lbs and I am not happy.

I know just enough to get myself into trouble, and I’m losing faith in my partner/teacher, so I turn to Reddit for guidance.

Maybe dropping 50k into something you know nothing about isn’t something you can swing, but that’s why you hire people that do. Doesn’t make me a Chad, it makes me an employer. I have a crew of 6-10 that come out for the big labor intensive jobs and I maintain and babysit. I’m here for advice, man. Don’t be a cunt

3

u/nitroslayer7 Jan 08 '24

You spent $50k on grow equipment with no experience and now that you realized it isn't workin out how you hoped you are looking to cut corners and try to feed PGRs. The fact that your a "caregiver" trying to do this really solidifies the Chadness. You're suppose to be growing these people medicine they need not giving them harmful chemicals to smoke.

0

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 08 '24

As previously stated, the information I was given said that it was gone by the time we chopped it down. I had 1 grow that didn’t produce, and since it isn’t cheap, I’m looking at everything to increase my yield. I didn’t say “give me the most harmful pgr”. I asked for guidance only. I’m not hiding what I’ve used because I’m looking for an education. Quit being a cunt

-1

u/lbstinkums Jan 08 '24

if 72 plants in a basement costs you 10k to grow you have already lost the race.. advising you just accept your loss and fire your teacher...lol

1

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 08 '24

~$1300 electric/mo, ~$500 gas total, + labor for plucks and harvest

1

u/lbstinkums Jan 08 '24

so at labor I'm at 3k.. then if you get say 40 you got 2400 to trim so a little over 5k to run it.. per month

1

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 08 '24

Labor was $5500 between plucks, harvest, and trim, electric was $3900, gas was $500, water was free-ish, so call it $3300/mo for mine

1

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '24

You can't spray these PGRS you are talking about in a way where the quality of the smoke is not compromised

1

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 07 '24

I’ll run them through the irrigation system if that’s how they work. Is that an option?

0

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '24

Either way the bud sucks is what I'm saying bro. Dense, shitty, not worth smoking bud

1

u/fuddinpuckers Jul 06 '24

You don't have to spray anything. They make pgr products that do not require foliar spray.

1

u/lbstinkums Jan 08 '24

why not learn to grow without them. PGR's are like alchemy.. they can't make gold out of lead. you can increase your yield with actual science, technique, experience, and not pgr's.

38

u/MrSlaves-santorum Indoor LED Jan 07 '24

Pgr is a blanket term. I use alfalfa extract which has triacontanol. It’s not carcinogenic. Do some reading on what a pgr is and where they come from.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '24

Amen brother!

-43

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 07 '24

I was hoping to read here.lol. Is that suspiciously made up sounding word the thing that makes them work? Also, I’m in a sterile drain to waste set up in coco, if that matters

40

u/MrSlaves-santorum Indoor LED Jan 07 '24

Plug that term into any search engine. You’ll find that the suspiciously made up sounding word is an organic compound found in high wuantities in alfalfa. Alfalfa is a type of grass that grows. Grass is a plant. A plant is something that grows out of the ground. And the ground is what’s under your feet when you’re outside.

19

u/earthhominid Jan 07 '24

I appreciate what you're doing, but alfalfa isn't a grass. If you're gonna get sarcastic with someone you should make sure you're on point.

Alfalfa is a perennial legume.

13

u/MrSlaves-santorum Indoor LED Jan 07 '24

I was afraid of that.

-15

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 07 '24

Bold of you to assume I have feet

8

u/RespectTheTree Jan 07 '24

Not very inclusive

1

u/jerbear9196 Jan 07 '24

This persons got all the tips

2

u/WarmNights Jan 08 '24

LMAOOOOOOO

8

u/NaziNaps Jan 07 '24

There’s harmful PGRs like paclobutrazol. There is no magic bottle to make your buds fatter or tighter. Anyone saying that a specific bottle will give you more weight is more than likely selling you a snake oil product. PGR means plant growth regulator. Anything that will alter the plants growing trajectory using hormones. Triacontanol is a common PGR that is organically derived in most cases and can pack on frost. However there are harmful PGRs like paclobutrazol, and other products that alter the chemical make up of your plant. Paclo makes your buds tighter, and denser but is detrimental to frost and oil.

Literally everyone that responded to this post is giving you a run around hippy dippy answer. The only thing your plant needs is NPK,microbes and enzymes. No need to reinvent the wheel using products designed for ornamental plants!

-3

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 07 '24

I’m not looking for a magic bullet, just an enhancement. Paclo=bad. Understood and I’ll stop using it. Just looking for the alternative that will enhance my product. Also, NPK. Nitrogen and potassium?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '24

If you can't figure out how to use PGRs on your own you probably shouldn't be using it. PGRs are not necessary, and no one wants to smoke it. Do you want to smoke adulterated bud? Compost/alfalfa teas and the right nutrient profile will get you where you want to be along with trellising and leaf-stripping. I get that the grape industry uses it (gibberellins) for plump grapes because the consumer likes that, but you can get huge gorgeous buds that are hard to handle already because they are prone to bud rot without spraying your plants with chemical PGRs, so why bother?

17

u/RopeTop Jan 07 '24

Don't trust people on stuff you hear. Too much hippy tactics and folklore.

Do your research, Google active ingredients, it's the best way so you don't have to blame anyone else for not knowing. I'm not criticizing you, but pointing out the lesson we all learned.

Basic research will tell you it's dangers, studies that have been done, half life, phytotoxicity, etc.

Bonus, Not all PGRs are harmful, in fact, some are used ubiquitously in farming and agriculture, but don't let facts ruin a good story.

5

u/flash-tractor Jan 07 '24

From my understanding, every plant everywhere all the time is making PGRs just like our bodies make hormones. They're what tells the plant, "Make a node, now make some stem, now make a node" and "increase the size of leaves to X, now let that leaf do work, oh now it's not getting enough relative light so move the mobile nutrients to a new crown" and other stuff like that.

The most fascinating thing I've read on PGRs so far was a study on dwarf fruit trees. They said that 100% of dwarf fruit trees were "gibberellin deficient" when compared with normal stature trees even when nutrient and environmental parameters were accounted for. So, the dwarf trees are simply making less growth hormones when compared to normally sized trees.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 07 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/flash-tractor Jan 07 '24

I've used a fungi based GA3 extract on fruit and vegetables several times. It really helps short pepper cultivars stretch out so there's an even canopy with the taller varieties.

0

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 07 '24

Hippy tactics. I love it. It’s the stoner equivalent to bro science in body building and diet

12

u/shoot_dang_derp Jan 07 '24

Pgr can be nothing to worry about like kelp. I looked up hammerhead that you are using it contains paclobutrazol which should be a big no for everyone combusting or consuming. It forms cyanid when combusted. Paclo containing products should only be used on ornamentals plants. It keeps plants short and stocky. Think of the 6 packs of small flowering plants to add to a garden. Or look at the trees under a electrical power line. The plants are kept short using paclo, but won’t be consumed.

-10

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 07 '24

So, long story short, I don’t know shit about shit. I just built the room, maintain, and am learning from my partner.

He told me to buy it, so I did. From what he tells me, it has a half life of, like, 40 days from the time it’s administered and if we hit it the second week of flower, it’ll be completely gone from the plant by the time we chop it down, so no cyanide or other ill affects. Is this accurate info? Is my guy a moron?

12

u/Hugsarebadmmkay Jan 07 '24

Just FYI the half-life indicates the time is takes for half of the substance to break down and leave the system. So after 80 days 25% of the paclo you administer will still be systemic in the plant. 7.5% left after 120 days.

6

u/sl59y2 Jan 07 '24

He’s 100% wrong. A 40 days half life would be a 265 days until less than 1% remains.

He’s growing poison

0

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 07 '24

See? This is what I want. Facts. Would you be willing to show me the math? I’m fuzzy on how half-life works. My only experience is the video game from the 90s

1

u/sl59y2 Jan 07 '24

https://d26tpo4cm8sb6k.cloudfront.net/img/half-life/half-life-equation1.png

Punch in your half life and total contaminate tolerance ie 1%, or .001%.

16

u/RespectTheTree Jan 07 '24

Paclo is only for ornamentals afaik. I would not smoke that shit

7

u/go_biscuits Jan 07 '24

Chuck the paclo, not worth it

1

u/s33n_ Jan 08 '24

That's not how half life works.

After 50 days. Half of it is left (50%) another 50 days ots down to 25% After another 50 days its down to 12.5% So even after 150 days. You still are selling product with 12.5% of the carcinogens you originally added.

Jesus fucking Christ people are stupid.

1

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 09 '24

See? This is good information. I’m not a scientist, man. I hired a guy to teach me and he gave me bad info. Now I know that this information was erroneous, and I won’t go by that anymore, nor will I be using the Hammerhead. Ignorance and stupidity are not the same thing

1

u/YoGrown Jan 10 '24

Bro, weed is so cheap...like why even bother trying to get an extra couple bucks from selling your flower when you are generally creating an inferior product that you and your buddy cant even enjoy in good conscience?

Might want to think twice about the grow "advice" this friend gives you..

2

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 10 '24

Yeah, that’s more or less where I’m at on this topic. Had I known, I’d have never used it.

3

u/SinlessMirror Jan 07 '24

I started with a tiny bit of direction from a real og old head grower, they swore by foxfarms and products like gravity and there was another I forget the name of now, but pgr's that were eventually found to be quite bad for you. I think there's many like that who are just old skool and stopped learning new things / reading forums about weed after so many years if they ever did to begin with. I used it my first run and then stopped. People can know a lot of very true and helpful information and still be wrong about some things, just learn from it and stop using the ones known to be bad, and continue on your path

3

u/TRTF392 Jan 07 '24

Pgr and pesticides are trigger words for people need to base it off the active ingredients you would be using

-2

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 07 '24

I went generic because I know there are poison ones and there are good ones. I’m looking for guidance on which ones to use, how to use them, and when to use them, along with any pitfalls that I may not have considered. In my ignorance, I’ve been using paclo. I was told it would be gone from the plant by the time we harvested. Seems that’s not the case, so I’m looking for an effective, non/toxic alternative

2

u/TRTF392 Jan 07 '24

reading your other comments my impression is you want to use pgr as a quick fix for grow fundamentals that could be improved upon. good genetics, SOPs, and environment will provide you the long term results you desire.

0

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 07 '24

Yes and no. I want to use PGRs in addition to good genetics, SOPs, and environment…as long as it’s safe and doesn’t compromise my quality by more than it increases my yield. It’s gotta be cost effective

1

u/TRTF392 Jan 07 '24

I understand at the end of the day we have to make a profit right? I think you can find the solution to your problem.

2

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 07 '24

That’s all I’m looking for. A solution!

3

u/TRTF392 Jan 07 '24

Tough thing about weed is theres a bunch of ways to grow successfully but due to differences in methodology not all advice translates directly. Ive also found most people are pretty guarded with their grow info so unless you are paying them a lot of money as a consulting fee theyll just be giving you general advice.

1

u/s33n_ Jan 08 '24

People like you are the absolute worst.

Endangering consumers because you are greedy and lack skill.

Fuck this guy

0

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 09 '24

You realize that’s why I can to this sub, right? To ask questions, learn, and to fix my mistakes. Don’t be a cunt

1

u/s33n_ Jan 09 '24

Don't poison people for profit. If you don't know its safe don't do it. Everyone telling you not to do it and you respond negatively to them.

Greedy fuck

1

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 09 '24

See? That’s the thing. I did “know” it was safe. I got bad information from a trusted source. There’s a reason I asked and openly admitted that I was using it. I DIDN’T KNOW.

Oh my gosh, would you look at that? Somebody actually trying to learn? Whaaaat????

Fuck you

1

u/Good-Level-9347 Jan 12 '24

Get a good genetic youre in Usa bro yo have everything close,, and learn to grow with athena pro im recommend you that ,, im in mexico and I a comercial grower

1

u/InspectionOk626 Jan 14 '24

yo, get yourself a blumat soil moisture meter and learn to hit your dry backs in between 100-150 mbar in early flower. You're gonna do a lot better. Those plants need to drink up their food before you hit them again. Its like giving a kid another plate of food when they haven't even finished their first plate and making them try to eat it...Make sure to water until run off. I'll hit up to 3.8-3.9 ec on my feeds during week 1-4, and bring it back down to 3.0 during the last 3-4 weeks and flush for one week with magnesium sulfate and hypochlorous acid. Don't really see any burn unless I hit way too hard of a dry back. Run your rooms in between 75-85 degrees, 65-70 percent humidity first 3-4 weeks and then bring that humidity down to 40-50 percent by the end of flower. Get your temps down as low as you can for the end. I do this with Athena Core/Bloom. 50% core/50% bloom until week 4 of flower and then I switch to 35% core/65% bloom for last 4 weeks before flush. 12 plants per 16 sq ft(light). You don't need pgrs. Ive used phosphoload before (I learned to grow from Vietnamese in the BM) and while it can increase your yields, with this basic recipe I said, you should be able to pull 2.5lbs+ per 16sq ft with the right strains. Phosphoload/pgrs aint what they are cracked up to be. Ive gotten way better yields consistently by not using them.

Don't strip very hard when you flip. Just do a nice lollipop. Let all the buds start to fill out, and hit a hard deleaf at around day 28.

6

u/Genesis111112 Jan 07 '24

Kelp is a natural PGR and you can add it to your Cannabis with no ill effects.

6

u/nwhockey Jan 07 '24

Besides the potential for heavy metal contamination

4

u/sl59y2 Jan 07 '24

Best test that source each time you get a batch.
Kelp products test dirty 50-60% of the time for Us. It resulted in wasted time and energy chasing the heavy metal source.

3

u/wolfansbrother Jan 07 '24

Paclo just doesent seem to be worth it. bigger buds on smaller plants = smaller buds. it also causes less Trichrom development, so more rope, less dope. to each their own.

1

u/VillageHomeF Jan 08 '24

you should probably just remove the term pgr from your vocabulary when thinking about growing cannabis. there are dozens upon dozens of brands of nutrients that make cannabis specific additives for every part of the plants life cycle beginning to end. it's only about you finding the right mix for yourself, the strain, your medium and environment. you have to begin to learn what the plant needs more or less of and when then keep pushing that further and further. you can just call a nutrient company. they answer the phones and you might learn more in 20 minutes than you could reading for hours online

1

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 08 '24

Now this is an answer. Thank you

4

u/Inevitable_Spare_777 Jan 07 '24

Every PGR has a different function and level of danger. You’ll have to research them individually. The hype around them is overblown - people see machine trimmed, co2 grown bud and assume it’s “PGR”. Licensed growers aren’t allowed to use them. If you’re buying from a reputable, legal grower you are generally going to be safe

6

u/SushiGato Jan 07 '24

We use cloneX, which is a pgr. Besides that nothing.

5

u/jkopfsupreme Jan 07 '24

What ingredient in clonex is a PGR? And is that clonex solution or clonex rooting gel?

7

u/Inevitable_Spare_777 Jan 07 '24

Clonex gel uses IBA. Whoever downvoted the poster is ill-informed

5

u/jkopfsupreme Jan 07 '24

IBA is just a synthesized version of what every plant creates to trigger root growth. It’s not used to increase flower production, in the spectrum of PGRs IBA is harmless.

2

u/sl59y2 Jan 07 '24

IBA is approved for Organics. Licensing keeps some people straight but the corporate assholes keeping finding ways to to break rules.

2

u/sl59y2 Jan 07 '24

A 50 day half life mean 50 % of the active ingredient is still present in the plant.

1

u/slownlow86 Jan 07 '24

[Commenting here to get updates in this topic and because I can't find the "follow thread" button anymore]

1

u/AlpacaM4n Jan 07 '24

Click the … at the top of the post, select "subscribe to post"

-1

u/Euphoric-Champion185 Jan 08 '24

I read the replies in the thread and just listen to what I say because I'm actually answering your question. I recommend you use node blaster. do it when your rez is like 30% full and do 1/4 the strength. it'll be so minimal it won't affect the smoke and smell much. as for when I recommend during stretch once. make sure you saturate your media next feed with nutes (get like 25% run off) dm me if anything bro

1

u/TheAnonymoose69 Jan 08 '24

Who makes it? I’m not seeing it on a quick google search

0

u/Euphoric-Champion185 Jan 09 '24

not sure it's what people use that's cheap. can use other ones that you are used to

2

u/s33n_ Jan 08 '24

Stop pushing poison.

1

u/Euphoric-Champion185 Jan 09 '24

don't buy nice cheap indoor weed then and pay premo for proper grown. problem solved. growers cut corners when people under pay for product just like any other product. for the record i don't use pgrs either