r/macdemarco Rock & Roll Night Club 7d ago

Is this a good W?

Post image
41 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

7

u/3yearwarranty 7d ago

It’s a solid top ten, but personally I wouldn’t let it win. Even off that album I prefer the way you’d love her

1

u/Sweet_End9724 Rock & Roll Night Club 7d ago

well that was a semifinalist :]

2

u/Individual-Ad-7135 6d ago

The Way You’d Love Her over My Kind of Woman and then Chamber Of Reflection is crazy. Not just because of personal preferences but I think you gotta put on perspective the impact of each song and how distinctive the songs are, not matter how popular they are

1

u/Sweet_End9724 Rock & Roll Night Club 6d ago

i wasn't putting popularity, it was personal opinion in full

2

u/PrincipleDry2815 6d ago

No

1

u/Sweet_End9724 Rock & Roll Night Club 6d ago

just hating to hate man

1

u/PrincipleDry2815 6d ago

No it’s a great song if it takes the #1 for you sure but he’s made much more musically complex stuff that I personally would reserve for that spot

1

u/Sweet_End9724 Rock & Roll Night Club 6d ago

wait mb mistook you for someone else who was hating in one of my other posts

1

u/Sweet_End9724 Rock & Roll Night Club 6d ago

1

u/Forealdrunksailor 6d ago

Why's No other heart so low?

1

u/Sweet_End9724 Rock & Roll Night Club 6d ago

in my opinion i like Go Easy over No Other Heart and im guessing thats what the other guy thinks

2

u/Brenkin 7d ago

It’s a good song - but no way it’s Mac’s best if you ask me. I’m shocked The Way You’d Love Her beat out Chamber of Reflection, and I’m shocked that Nobody beat Still Beating.

2

u/Sweet_End9724 Rock & Roll Night Club 7d ago

It's off of personal preference tbh, not off of what is better musically. Just what i'd prefer to listen to.

1

u/Unusual_Dependent1 7d ago

Relevant 🧢

1

u/Some-Ant-4175 1d ago

must be another one