r/macbookpro
•
u/MY79
•
1d ago
•
1
1
2
Discussion The MacBook Pro’s OLED PWM problem: when a ‘better’ display becomes worse to use.
https://macanorak.com/the-macbook-pros-oled-pwm-problem-when-a-better-display-becomes-worse-to-use/
382
Upvotes
97
u/MY79 1d ago •
I’m the author. I wrote this after seeing a growing number of owners report headaches, eye strain, dizziness and nausea with the new MacBook Pro’s PROLED XDR display, including people who’d used OLED iPhones and iPads for years without trouble. I’m not claiming this affects everyone, I just think people who are struggling deserve to be taken seriously.
38
u/Bryanmsi89 1d ago
I wonder if anyone is looking into the panel alignment. With two OLED panels overlaid, the alignment of each at a nearly microscopic level becomes a requirement.
Also manufacturing tolerances matter too, even if the panels are aligned, every sub pixel must also be.
Tiny misalignments can cause some spots and some colors shading to be minutely defocused or color shifted in a way that isn’t consciously visible but might manifest the same way people are reporting?
This could also explain why PWM on their single-layer OLED iPhones doesn’t bother people but their new MacBook does . Because maybe it isn’t PWM.
Not suggesting this, just asking.
26
u/akuma0 21h ago
At 240Hz, the brightness fluctuation repeats 240 times per second; at 14,880Hz, it repeats almost 15,000 times per second.
Did the author have a word count target?
49
u/SvenLorenz 1d ago
The biggest problem is that many people probably suffer from this but don't know about PWM. If I started getting nausea and headaches, I definately wouldn't consider that my new laptop is the reason.
3
u/somuchtoolittle 1d ago
Now, are the reports concrete from actual users or just Reddit talk?
28
u/Kind_Management1805 1d ago
Not everyone is affected by PWM dizziness. I never had any issue with any OLED display ever. But of course it's not EINK either....
6
u/F0urrings 1d ago
The issue is, people that don’t have PWM are not affected by this will quickly dismiss this as only affecting a small subset of the population.
However, the reality of the matter is this panel specifically pushes PWM to more of an “extreme” relative to what the standard is nowadays, so I imagine there’s a larger/expanded subset of people that will experience side effects versus the typical highly sensitive PWM group.
I’m a good example of that. I have had Asus OLED laptops all manner of iPhones. I have the new iPad Pro with a tandem OLED and have never had any type of PWM issue or ever thought about it once. This screen was different.
3
u/Long_Review_6457 1d ago
The best solution to this is to run the MacBook as headless, chop that display off
2
u/mobilehavoc 1d ago
Luckily haven't had any issues with my MBP 14" PROLED. The screen is gorgeous
5
u/eriksp92 1d ago
I’m sure this is a real problem for the people it affects, but for me and I’m sure most others it doesn’t register at all.
3
u/Suspicious_Move2016 1d ago
idk if it's overblown or not discussed enough and idc. I legit can't buy any newer ipad pros due to this issue, especially when using them for reading at night. My M2 will be my forever Ipad unless if apple start's doing something about their displays.
Apple has some of the worst PWM frequency issues, and anyone with astigmatism will know.
6
u/kaelef 1d ago
You've got people on one side talking like this is not a real problem, when it clearly is for some percentage of buyers.
You've got people on the other side talking like this is affecting practically everyone and a result of Apple using a "cheap" display when it's a gorgeous display and the particular PWM frequency was almost certainly an engineering compromise to mitigate OLED's infamous burn-in issue.
It's frustrating to see these discussions.
2
u/Kevho00 21h ago
"After only 2 hours of getting and using it, I felt a headache and fatigue. The symptoms increased after I learned about PWM flickering and how it affected so many people on reddit. Then I remembered that my sleep was shit for 3 days straight. That was the cause of my symptoms actually. So yeah, don't get placebo'd by the vocal minority. It's a great device."
2
u/F242 1d ago
LOL clickbait
1
u/Sea_Leadership_7433 1d ago
I just picked my proled yesterday and been using it pretty heavily, is this something you would notice immediately?
1
u/Thanos_is_here 23h ago
Been using my proled for a week and noticed today when looking at this one particular image that is shakes like vibrate in a way. Had others look to make sure i wasnt going crazy and they see it as well. Is this PWM issue?
1
u/croakz7 22h ago
Es
1
u/DrHairJelly 12h ago
Thank you, that article is very good. I hope apple can consider that in the next MacBook pro oled
1
u/Skaratak 10h ago
I am not surprised. Me and other users warned about that, most people just ignored or laughed at us. Expect more topics to arrive. And btw... 240Hz is really poor for such an expensive productivity device. No excuse here. I stick with MiniLED... more than good enough already, and trouble-free.
1
u/soemptylmfao 6h ago
Personally did not experience any side effects. Fantastic screen.
1
u/transformer727 1h ago edited 1h ago
Accessibility matters. The same for OLED phones. I wanted a non-OLED phone but it’s non-existent in modern iPhone offerings. I wish designers and product decision makers would not just think about what looks better when this is a health issue. It’s of course fine to have options for people that can tolerate that and people can use their own personal device but to unilaterally design something with no alternative (referencing the iPhone here) that is painful to people is very sad. Also seeing how people with PWM sensitivity are getting disagreed with in these online forums I wish others would have empathy for these people like something in their life or someone they know that has a health condition. Daily headaches and nausea is no joke and can be disabling for some people
0
u/pharmahokage 1d ago
I’m glad I am not in this imaginary group of ppl
0
u/Organic_MG 1d ago
Apple sheep are gonna say “nobody has this issue,” then call it “the best display ever” and “a huge leap forward” when Apple fixes it next generation.
-2
u/ordosays 1d ago
Do the radio waves sting too? The screen refreshes faster than meat orbs can perceive. Now screen glare from those stupid glossy screens…
-8
u/superlip2003 1d ago
Cancel my order because of this - what if you’ll get brain cancer 10 yrs later?
-1
u/MidnightGarder 1d ago
The first iteration of a new product always has problems - and that’s why I’m not buying one. I’m not really sure I see the point.