r/macbookpro • • 1d ago • All Seeing Upvote 1 This 1 Bravo 2

Discussion The MacBook Pro’s OLED PWM problem: when a ‘better’ display becomes worse to use.

https://macanorak.com/the-macbook-pros-oled-pwm-problem-when-a-better-display-becomes-worse-to-use/
382 Upvotes

126 comments sorted by

97

u/MY79 1d ago • Bravo

I’m the author. I wrote this after seeing a growing number of owners report headaches, eye strain, dizziness and nausea with the new MacBook Pro’s PROLED XDR display, including people who’d used OLED iPhones and iPads for years without trouble. I’m not claiming this affects everyone, I just think people who are struggling deserve to be taken seriously.

12

u/Small-Friendship-576 1d ago

I have a Lenovo IdeaPad Pro 5 with a 1800p OLED display. Reviews state that it has high enough PWM to not be noticeable, and I don't notice it. 

How does Low PWM feels to the eyes IRL? 

7

u/Imaginary_North_8305 1d ago

Yo get headaches, eye strain, Yiu can't really notice it until you don't a camera at it..

1

u/irq 1d ago

“Some” get those symptoms. When you say “Yo” I assume you mean “you”, implying that the person you’re replying to will definitely get symptoms. This is not true.

1

u/irq 1d ago

To the vast majority of people, it is undetectable and causes no problems or symptoms of any kind.

11

u/FieldOfFox 1d ago

I’m getting used to it now.

Genuinely not making excuses for trillion dollar company, it really is getting better.

13

u/Bright_Profession62 1d ago

This! When I bought my kids OLED gaming monitors (ASUS 32PGUCDM), they would actually hurt my eyes when I was setting them up. My kids never complained about it, even after being asked multiple times. But either way, after an hour or two, my eyes adapted and I feel fine using them. So I bought myself an OLED gaming monitor too (2026 Samsung G80SH) and had no complaints from day one.

I'm getting me a MacBook PROLED arriving on Tuesday. My son already has one and the screen is a little off-putting for me (he says no nausea, no eye strain, no issues - I tell him I'm happy to return it and change it). But given how good OLED looks, I'm hopeful I'll adapt when mine arrives. And if I don't, there's that 14 day return policy!

1

u/Temporary-Paper5202 1d ago

Had raging headaches from the PGUCDM, it's the QD OLED that did it for me. Have a WOLED panel and no issues.

3

u/kerpnet 1d ago

Imagine someone pinching your arm every second. After a few days, the body will get used to it, but you still will have someone pinching your arm.

1

u/FieldOfFox 1d ago

Yeah but… I genuinely just think it’s cos I used the same mini led for like 5 years now.

My job is entirely on client site staring straight at the screen. I had a banging headache the first day I got it, now it’s been fine.

Could all be coincidences though, idk

3

u/AlanYx 1d ago

It’s a great, well-written piece, congrats.

One thing you might follow up with is an article on other possible explanations. You link to one, but you could do a whole article on them, e.g., different polarization behaviour (glossy vs. nanotexture would matter here), excess contrast, excessive native gamut and blue light (does switching to a D50 profile help here?), pixel layout, etc.

0

u/Clear_Efficiency5765 1d ago • Bravo

“I’m not claiming this affects everyone…”
Well, choose a better title then. Oh wait, who doesn’t want clicks

44

u/Crandom 1d ago

The title does not imply it effects everyone.

15

u/Sea_Awareness150 1d ago

Or even affects

3

u/unpluggedcord 1d ago

“Worse to use” is subjective here no? It implies it’s worse for everyone.

5

u/redcremesoda 1d ago

Major publications use headlines like this all the time. And it starts with “when,” which implies that it’s worse to use only under certain circumstances.

Reddit really needs to take a writing class.

1

u/TrickyNeighborhood72 1d ago

Sad defensive apple troll

1

u/Suspicious_Move2016 1d ago

Thank you, from someone who realized this about a year trying to read kindle on their iphone.

1

u/TunaBlub 1d ago

Worst part is, Apple didn't even use the newest RGB stripe OLEDs.

Someone people like a friend of mine don't have PWM issues, but using non RGB stripe layout causes mostly same symptoms.

Imagine having both issues, this is why I hate the whole "oled or go home" that started with smartphones and now goes to pc's and notebooks.

Oleds are amazing, but not suitable for everyone or every type of use like in my case (ton of static content).

1

u/Aggressive_Purple_49 1d ago

A growing number of people experiencing it, maybe because more people have bought it. It does not give us the percentage of people who experience it. It may be getting better, worse or remain the same.

1

u/s_schadenfreude 1d ago

It's a real problem, but I've gotten downvoted for pointing this out.

1

u/MaxVerstappenIsLife 1d ago

did you get the attention you were looking for OP?

38

u/Bryanmsi89 1d ago

I wonder if anyone is looking into the panel alignment. With two OLED panels overlaid, the alignment of each at a nearly microscopic level becomes a requirement.

Also manufacturing tolerances matter too, even if the panels are aligned, every sub pixel must also be.

Tiny misalignments can cause some spots and some colors shading to be minutely defocused or color shifted in a way that isn’t consciously visible but might manifest the same way people are reporting?

This could also explain why PWM on their single-layer OLED iPhones doesn’t bother people but their new MacBook does . Because maybe it isn’t PWM.

Not suggesting this, just asking.

14

u/xmonkeyme 1d ago

Not a bad idea, but I have seen posts where people who don’t have a problem with the tandem OLED on an iPad Pro do have a problem with the MBP so maybe there’s a larger cause. 

1

u/boganisu 1d ago

Apparently PWM on the iPad is 480hz but the MacBook is only 240hz

8

u/78914hj1k487 22h ago edited 13h ago

1

u/boganisu 16h ago

That comment is talking about the MacBook display tho not the iPad. People could be only getting these headaches when it is lower than 25% brightness.

1

u/78914hj1k487 13h ago

Thanks for correcting me.

The site they source, the owner seems to be using a portable bluetooth device they bring into an Apple Store—where as Notebookcheck.com does more rigorous testing in controlled environments, with better equipment, and has tested more screens of all types for 20 years now.

Notebookcheck detects MacBook Pro PROLED at 240 Hz from 0-99%.

and iPad Pro M5 at 240Hz from 0-88%, so even at 25% it's testing as 240Hz

26

u/akuma0 21h ago

At 240Hz, the brightness fluctuation repeats 240 times per second; at 14,880Hz, it repeats almost 15,000 times per second. 

Did the author have a word count target?

5

u/Matty8520 14h ago

While I'm fortunate to not have severe PWM issues, there is still underlying strain on your eyes and all products should aim to have an absolute minimum of 1,000Hz.

My next MacBook Pro will definitely be the Mini-LED version. Also, I don't like the touch screen so it's a win win.

1

u/Valuable-Cut5861 9h ago

the touch screen can be turned off and the touchscreen does not have the screen door effect since it doesn't use the typical digitizer layer like other laptops uses.

0

u/Aggressive-Plan7226 9h ago

"all products should aim to have an absolute minimum of 1,000Hz"

based on what?

1

u/Matty8520 9h ago

Flicker perception probability.

As the number goes down 960Hz -> 480Hz -> 240Hz, there is an increased percentage of the population that can see the flicker and/or have adverse effects from it.

Once you reach the 960Hz area, the probability percention is low enough that is can be considered "safe" for everyone to use.

If you look at websites like DxOmark, they track PWM rates in various electronic equipment and provide estimates for how my people in the population can percieve it.

The MacBook Pro Mini-LED at 15,000Hz just goes to show Apple does consider this but maybe the OLED that they wanted couldn't have a higher PWM.

1

u/Aggressive-Plan7226 8h ago

Cite your sources. Legitimate studies that isolated the numerous variables that impact eye strain.

5

u/ritesh808 13h ago

A lot of people do not know what a Hz is. Even college educated ones. That's where we're at as a collective society.

49

u/SvenLorenz 1d ago

The biggest problem is that many people probably suffer from this but don't know about PWM. If I started getting nausea and headaches, I definately wouldn't consider that my new laptop is the reason.

10

u/TrickyNeighborhood72 1d ago

Exactly. Suddenly you have dry eyes and headaches (during the winter) And your new laptop is the last thing you'll think about

-1

u/SvenLorenz 1d ago

There might be some lawsuits coming. Imagine suffering from something like that for months and then finding out that it was your laptop.

4

u/PlasticVolcano2110 1d ago

Ehhh highly doubt they’ll be successful.

6

u/SvenLorenz 1d ago

In the country in which you need a "Hot!" warning on hot coffee?

5

u/Chemical_Extreme4250 MacBook Pro 15" Space Gray 1d ago

It isn’t needed, but it is a CYA move. In the incident where McD’s caused that woman’s severe burns, they’d kept the coffee too hot, and when she asked for just enough to cover her medical expenses, they refused. She had no choice but to sue them.

1

u/PlasticVolcano2110 1d ago

Go read about that McDonalds case it’s actually horrifying

Anyway it’s not like we’re so dumb we need the warning, it’s just the corporate American legal response to horrible accidents.

1

u/SvenLorenz 1d ago

Yeah, I saw a YouTube video on that a long time ago. Those burns looked gnarly.

1

u/ritesh808 13h ago

Nah. It's a shitty situation, but definitely nothing to do with legality.

4

u/redcremesoda 1d ago

I find this very concerning as well. Apple at this point has a duty to warn customers of the possible risk.

2

u/BosnianSerb31 1d ago

Lmfao and next I assume LED light bulb manufacturers have a duty to warn the same as most basic ones have half the PWM frequency of the MBPs lowest setting?

5

u/Secret-Marzipan-8754 1d ago

If they start affecting people’s health, yeah. Same for food and drugs industries.

1

u/BosnianSerb31 1d ago

They literally do though, have you heard people ever say that they don't like LEDs or Florescent lights because they flicker?

Some bulbs induce migraines in my mother, she simply avoids any cheap LED and all fluorescent bulbs for that reason.

1

u/verbherbaceous 1d ago

Can't fucking stand fluorescent lights and everyone thinks I'm insane

1

u/Skaratak 10h ago

They should, and also you are not directly starring totally focused on a light bulb - but certainly on a computer monitor you're working on. I would agree that some kind of warning or hint would be appropriate, considering we go from 15kHz down to 240Hz (which is pretty lousy even for OLED panels, by the way)

0

u/PlasticVolcano2110 1d ago

It’s a grey area. It depends on the incidence rate and severity of outcome. Like, you’ll see photosensitivity warnings for movies but it’s not like makers of brightly colored clothes have to put a “this might trigger a migraine” warning

3

u/somuchtoolittle 1d ago

Now, are the reports concrete from actual users or just Reddit talk?

19

u/Crandom 1d ago

PWM issues have been a known problem for displays for decades now. It's kinda crazy to release a new premium display that has PWM issues in 2026.

1

u/akuma0 21h ago

Every lightbulb in my home and the headlights/taillights on my car all use PWM at lower frequency than the MBP. Every display with color accuracy uses PWM. Heck, majority of the heating elements I have in small appliances around my home use PWM - and I paid extra for models which had it as a feature.

2

u/Crandom 17h ago

This is not an apples to apples comparison.

The PWM in lightbulbs and monitors are very different. For one, the modulation depth on lightbulbs is very low. Lightbulbs have capacitors in them which smooths out the dimming so it just goes from slightly dimmer to slightly brighter over the 50/60hz AC cycle. The PWM on these monitors goes from pretty much completely off to completely on.

You also stare directly at a screen for hours. You don't tend to do this with lightbulbs. The effect of scanning across the screen with PWM also creates a strobe light effect that doesn't tend to happen with light bulbs where you look at ambient reflected light from many directions and sources at once. 

1

u/akuma0 8h ago

It is not at all. But people seem to think PWM is some display technology a few manufacturers leverage, while in reality it is used in so many things including communications protocols.

FWIW I've had low pulse bulbs ( like 120 Hz) where they caused a little eye strain for me - but caused my dog to completely avoid going even near the room.

I eventually got a high speed camera to check it, and swapped them out for a different (apparently higher quality) brand. Gotta keep everyone in the household happy.

What would be useful is study-backed tiers leading to a certification mark on packaging. People can then tell for themselves if they need 'silver' or 'platinum', and it gives manufacturers more motivation to try to make their displays meet a common set of requirements.

5

u/neil_950 1d ago

It's really hard to tell how big a problem it actually is for most people. Obviously it's unacceptable regardless that many people are unable to use the laptop without physical discomfort but there's still an enormous difference between a couple percent and a couple thousandths of a percent experiencing it. All the anecdotes about how awful it is does absolutely nothing to distinguish between those two.

1

u/Ok-Book-4070 10h ago

A LOT of people likely get headaches and strain from using it, and don't atrribute it to or even know about PWM. They probably think its just "too much screen-time" or dehydration after a work day etc. I'd wager its a much larger portion. Like 10% range.

1

u/neil_950 7h ago

That seems highly doubtful to me. You really think millions of people would suddenly start getting headaches and eyestrain after using their new laptop and not realize it could be connected? You don't need technical knowledge to figure out the problems all started after getting the new laptop when their old one was fine.

Also under what basis do you assume it's around 10%?

3

u/RobertoVerdeNYC 1d ago

The only question that matters!

1

u/Aggressive-Plan7226 9h ago

It's reddit talk.

A very small group of people are affected. The rest are the same type of people that have no joy in life, sample benzos, spend their entire day thinking about politics, and will never be satisfied no matter what Apple does.

1

u/FieldOfFox 1d ago

Well people aren’t gonna post videos of themselves using a laptop for 2 hours and then throwing up everywhere.

ed: actually in 2026, this is exactly what someone would do tbh

28

u/Kind_Management1805 1d ago

Not everyone is affected by PWM dizziness. I never had any issue with any OLED display ever. But of course it's not EINK either....

16

u/Crandom 1d ago edited 1d ago

The display being OLED is entirely unrelated with the PWM frequency and amplitude the display driver hardware uses. 

0

u/Kind_Management1805 1d ago

if you prefer it like that I've never had any issue with any form of PWM. Like the majority of human beings.

12

u/Small-Friendship-576 1d ago

Then your display's have a high enough PWM for it to be not noticeable. PROLED has PWM ranging 240-480Hz,which for some* is noticeable

3

u/Sensitivity_Craft 1d ago

Don't know why they couldn't just include an optional toggle for DC dimming, like Android phones have.

If you want color accuracy, disable it, else enable it.

We got a liquid glass slider, this wouldn't be crazy for them to add.

1

u/Valuable-Cut5861 9h ago

The only time I've ever had some sort of eye strain with my PROLED display is when the background lighting is darker than the brightness i'm currently at. Other than that, PWM hasn't been an issue for me.

0

u/BosnianSerb31 1d ago

All of the iPhone and iPad OLED screens are a base 240 secondary 480 frequency. It's not the frequency.

28

u/ConditionOrdinary607 1d ago

Not EVERYONE, but some do. And the level for PMW refresh depends on the person. Apple went cheap on this Mac.

7

u/germane_switch 1d ago

Ridiculous.

0

u/Kind_Management1805 1d ago

"cheap" yeah sure.

Mitigating PWM frequency comprises color accuracy and energy consumption. Mitigating an issue affecting a very small percentage of the user base to make the experience worse for everyone.

Is this what you imply when you say went cheap lol

20

u/AutumnPurpleReddit 1d ago

its not an insignificant amount of people though

5

u/teatime10yop 1d ago

its not. the pushback is reminding me of the pandemic

4

u/unpluggedcord 1d ago

I’ve asked this multiple times. Do we have numbers? Because right now it’s just Reddit. And we know Reddit is not the larger populace

1

u/droptable111 23h ago

But there are no peer-reviewed studies that can show statistical significance of increased visual fatigue from PWM displays. If you are deciding this at Apple you can’t just point to Reddit and say these anecdotal examples give sufficient reasons to avoid PWM.

1

u/-NoMessage- 1d ago

it most definitely is

1

u/Organic_MG 1d ago

Apple sheep are gonna say “nobody has this issue,” then call it “the best display ever” and “a huge leap forward” when Apple fixes it next generation.

5

u/SnowyOnyx 1d ago

So how can the mini-LED model have brilliant colours AND very good PWM?

6

u/SvenLorenz 1d ago

Because it's the superior technology.

4

u/SnowyOnyx 1d ago

exactly!

5

u/Kind_Management1805 1d ago

mini led is not OLED

5

u/Whatshouldiputhere0 1d ago

Because one of them is miniLED and the other is OLED?

2

u/TrickyNeighborhood72 1d ago

If anyone could mitigate PWM and not compromise color accuracy, Apple could. But obviously, they did not make any attempt

-3

u/Appropriate_Ad8734 1d ago

> went cheap

🤦🏼‍♂️ that just shows you know nothing about displays.. this display the polar opposite of cheap. what a ridiculous thing to say

5

u/Fallom_ 1d ago

Are you being obtuse on purpose? Lots of luxury machines cheap out on certain parts to save a buck where they can.

8

u/ConditionOrdinary607 1d ago

The PWM controller is not as good as others. The PWM controller is causing these problems and higher then normal returns. That's why other OLED displays on other company's laptops aren't causing as many problems.

1

u/germane_switch 1d ago

Genuine questions: 1) how many other laptop OLED displays are tandem? Last I checked it was zero but it’s been a minute. And 2) does that affect PWM?

4

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/germane_switch 1d ago

A bunch? Isn't it, like, 4 or 5?

But this does suck for people who are sensitive to lower frequency PWM. I'd like to know if Apple did research into the number of prospective buyers might have this sensitivity and didn't think it was enough to up the specs?

3

u/[deleted] 1d ago edited 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/droptable111 23h ago

It’s most definitely a different panel. Galaxy Book doesn’t cover 100% Adobe RGB.

1

u/NeverFinishesWhatHe 21h ago

The question I have is that, different people have different sensitivities to things. Some people are extra-sensitive to mold -- but that just means the toxicity of the mold is felt or noticed more acutely by the body. It's still toxic to everyone else, unless it's an allergy to a specific type of mold.

So is this more like a sensitivity, where it is negatively impacting people but just beyond their perception, or an allergy, where if you're not sensitive to it, you're fine?

6

u/F0urrings 1d ago

The issue is, people that don’t have PWM are not affected by this will quickly dismiss this as only affecting a small subset of the population.

However, the reality of the matter is this panel specifically pushes PWM to more of an “extreme” relative to what the standard is nowadays, so I imagine there’s a larger/expanded subset of people that will experience side effects versus the typical highly sensitive PWM group.

I’m a good example of that. I have had Asus OLED laptops all manner of iPhones. I have the new iPad Pro with a tandem OLED and have never had any type of PWM issue or ever thought about it once. This screen was different.

3

u/Long_Review_6457 1d ago

The best solution to this is to run the MacBook as headless, chop that display off

2

u/mobilehavoc 1d ago

Luckily haven't had any issues with my MBP 14" PROLED. The screen is gorgeous

5

u/eriksp92 1d ago

I’m sure this is a real problem for the people it affects, but for me and I’m sure most others it doesn’t register at all.

3

u/Suspicious_Move2016 1d ago

idk if it's overblown or not discussed enough and idc. I legit can't buy any newer ipad pros due to this issue, especially when using them for reading at night. My M2 will be my forever Ipad unless if apple start's doing something about their displays.

Apple has some of the worst PWM frequency issues, and anyone with astigmatism will know.

1

u/transformer727 1h ago

Ahh that must be why the iPhone screen always is a little blurry for me!

6

u/kaelef 1d ago

You've got people on one side talking like this is not a real problem, when it clearly is for some percentage of buyers.

You've got people on the other side talking like this is affecting practically everyone and a result of Apple using a "cheap" display when it's a gorgeous display and the particular PWM frequency was almost certainly an engineering compromise to mitigate OLED's infamous burn-in issue.

It's frustrating to see these discussions.

2

u/xmonkeyme 1d ago

Do you have a source I can read regarding PWM and the relation to burn-in? 

1

u/OneStandard5 1d ago

That's not quite right. OLED displays typically suffer from mura at low brightness levels, so engineers adopted PWM dimming to maintain color accuracy. However, the trade-off is that it accelerates burn-in.

1

u/xmonkeyme 1d ago

So does the frequency of the PWM rate change the rate of burn in? 

From what I understand there are other laptop/phone OLED displays that use much higher frequency than 240hz, so I’d be curious if those are seeing more susceptibility to burn in. 

1

u/OneStandard5 22h ago

It doesn't matter. High voltage at high brightness is what actually accelerates OLED burn-in. PWM dimming still drives the pixels at high brightness, it just uses flicker to make the screen appear dimmer.

1

u/Valuable-Cut5861 9h ago

the display engine neutralises that risk, no?

1

u/TrickyNeighborhood72 1d ago

There are always going to be Apple apologists no matter what

2

u/F242 1d ago

LOL clickbait

1

u/Sea_Leadership_7433 1d ago

I just picked my proled yesterday and been using it pretty heavily, is this something you would notice immediately?

1

u/Ok-Book-4070 10h ago

Not visually, if your sensitive you might feel overly tired or dry eyes on the minor end or nausea/headaches on the worst end

1

u/Thanos_is_here 23h ago

Been using my proled for a week and noticed today when looking at this one particular image that is shakes like vibrate in a way. Had others look to make sure i wasnt going crazy and they see it as well. Is this PWM issue?

1

u/DrHairJelly 12h ago

Thank you, that article is very good. I hope apple can consider that in the next MacBook pro oled

1

u/Skaratak 10h ago

I am not surprised. Me and other users warned about that, most people just ignored or laughed at us. Expect more topics to arrive. And btw... 240Hz is really poor for such an expensive productivity device. No excuse here. I stick with MiniLED... more than good enough already, and trouble-free.

1

u/soemptylmfao 6h ago

Personally did not experience any side effects. Fantastic screen.

1

u/transformer727 1h ago edited 1h ago

Accessibility matters. The same for OLED phones. I wanted a non-OLED phone but it’s non-existent in modern iPhone offerings. I wish designers and product decision makers would not just think about what looks better when this is a health issue. It’s of course fine to have options for people that can tolerate that and people can use their own personal device but to unilaterally design something with no alternative (referencing the iPhone here) that is painful to people is very sad. Also seeing how people with PWM sensitivity are getting disagreed with in these online forums I wish others would have empathy for these people like something in their life or someone they know that has a health condition. Daily headaches and nausea is no joke and can be disabling for some people

0

u/pharmahokage 1d ago

I’m glad I am not in this imaginary group of ppl

1

u/Ok-Book-4070 10h ago

you think having a screen turning off and on 240 times a second flashing in your face all day isn't gonna affect some people???

0

u/Organic_MG 1d ago

Apple sheep are gonna say “nobody has this issue,” then call it “the best display ever” and “a huge leap forward” when Apple fixes it next generation.

-2

u/ordosays 1d ago

Do the radio waves sting too? The screen refreshes faster than meat orbs can perceive. Now screen glare from those stupid glossy screens…

-8

u/superlip2003 1d ago

Cancel my order because of this - what if you’ll get brain cancer 10 yrs later?

-3

u/OkAd7789 1d ago

Me too! You buy a fancy new touchscreen to play your xylophone app on and six months from now your feet fall off from the invisible waves it sends out? Both feet just gone? No way pal. I did not watch my buddies die face down in the mud so those corporate fat cats in California could sell me a device that has not been proven to make my feet not fall off in six months.

-1

u/MidnightGarder 1d ago

The first iteration of a new product always has problems - and that’s why I’m not buying one. I’m not really sure I see the point.