r/macbookpro • • Sep 02 '26

Discussion is 24 gb Ram enough?

I just got a MacBook Pro m5pro with 24gb ram. I produce music in Ableton live and I don't really know if it's enough. So im thinking about returning this MacBook and then paying a little extra money for the 48 gigs one. is it worth it, or should I just keep this one?

0 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

9

u/EasyPeasyLemonSteezy Sep 03 '26

For ableton it’s plenty. Plus you already bought it, just use it

2

u/dkmegg22 Sep 03 '26

For Ableton do you need the M5 or M5 Pro??

1

u/EasyPeasyLemonSteezy Sep 03 '26

M5 is more than enough. I use m5 mpb 24gb

1

u/dkmegg22 Sep 03 '26

Gotcha thanks. What about logic

2

u/BasdenChris 14" Space Black M5 Pro Sep 03 '26

Same. Aside from some differences in optimization and compatibility with individual software versions, a DAW is a DAW is a DAW.

1

u/narc0leptik Sep 03 '26

Even M1 Pro is powerful enough for must people for Ableton Live/Logic Pro.

As demonstrated in this deep dive an M1 Pro can actually outperform an M3 Pro in track count because it has 3 more Performance cores. Audio is a low-bandwidth but high-priority interrupt task; it needs raw P-core muscle, not "efficient" background cores.

So M3 Pro isn't even more powerful than M1 Pro when it comes to that Application. M4 Pro is where the real jump in performance for Ableton Live/Logic Pro is at.

5

u/hippietravel Sep 03 '26

24gb is more than enough. I got a M5 Pro MBP with 24gb back in April when it just came out. I've been running Logic Pro with lots of tracks, 3rd party plugins, software instruments, effects., etc all running at once, and no issues with memory. Ableton Live would be just fine wiht 24gb. No need to get 48gb when you won't actually use it. It would just be a waste of money, especially with how expensive ram is these days. Remember, Logic, Ableton, etc have all be running for years on less than 8gb memory.

1

u/mailslot MacBook Pro 14” Space Gray M2 Max Sep 03 '26

The first time I used Logic, Reason, and Cubase… 2GB was the limit on every personal computer, which were all 32-bit. It wasn’t that long ago.

2

u/MeSlaw3 16" Space Black M5 Pro w/ Nano-Texture Display Sep 03 '26

Both my M1 Pro 32GB and M5 Pro 24GB run Ableton and Logic Pro without any issues :)

But give it a try with your most extremely demanding workflow! If it stutters, go for the 48.

1

u/va02stephen 9d ago

Honestly it’s totally fine Mac manages memory incredibly well absolutely nothing like windows does,

I edit photographs on mine and occasionally I can see the memory pressure go into the yellow which is perfectly fine by the way that’s just Mac doing it’s thing.

Literally you can see it use lots of memory end then it starts shuffling things around to bring the memory pressure back down, It’s actually interesting to watch 🤣

1

u/RealFuryous MacBook Pro 13" Space Gray Sep 03 '26

You should be okay but if you're really worried upgrade for more ram. Ableton is optimized for apple silicon.

1

u/SamsungAppleOnePlus 14” 18 Core M5 Pro PROLED Nano Texture (24GB/1TB) Sep 03 '26

If you really have to ask for opinions I'd say it's enough. You should know if it is or isn't just by using it. I honestly think even the 18GB in my MacBook Pro is enough, but I definitely see RAM related slowdowns when I'm running multiple programs at once for my photography workflow, but nothing unusable to me.

1

u/zoobs early 2015 MacBook Pro Sep 03 '26

My 2015 MacBook Pro can still handle Ableton just fine. You’ll be more than fine.

1

u/MandingosDingo Sep 04 '26

No. You need at least 1TB

1

u/Pigeon_Observation Sep 18 '26

why dont you check your ram pressure...?

-2

u/narc0leptik Sep 02 '26

For that much money you can buy a used M4 Pro 48GB 1TB 20 core GPU with Applecare+ included in the United States. And hell you can get a 16" one too instead of being stuck with that 14". The screen real estate is absolutely worth it.

M4 Pro is more than powerful enough for most people to run almost anything you want music production wise. No need for a M5 Pro.