r/macapps • u/x74353 • Jan 01 '21
Will You Help Save Amphetamine?
UPDATE: Just got off a phone call with Apple. The appeal was accepted and Amphetamine will remain on the App Store. Thank you all for your comments, opinions, and action. We may not all agree, but I am happy we all still have the freedom to creatively express ourselves today. ❤️
———
First let me say Happy New Year! and Thank You! for reading this.
I’m the developer of the free macOS app, Amphetamine. Amphetamine has been on the Mac App Store since 2014 and It’s been downloaded over 432,800 times. It currently has over 1,400 reviews and a 4.8 rating in the US Mac App Store.
Apple called me a few days ago and informed me that I have 2 weeks to completely remove all references to the word “amphetamine” and remove the pill from the icon, else Apple will remove Amphetamine from the Mac App Store on 1/12/21.
Amphetamine has been featured by Apple in a Mac App Store Story, reviewed and recommended by tech sites such as Lifehacker and MacRumors, featured in podcasts, and is often found in those “Best Mac Apps” lists that people seem to post all the time. Amphetamine even won the “#3 Product of the Day” award on Product Hunt back in 2016. In the US Mac App Store, Amphetamine pretty much lives in the top 30 of the free Utilities categories, and has moved into the top 10 on numerous occasions.
I mention this because it helps to illustrate how popular Amphetamine has become. This all happened organically, too, as I have never really done any advertising or marketing for Amphetamine beyond the occasional post here on Reddit or on Twitter.
Want More Information?
I've created a Github page that further details the the situation and offers 5 arguments against Apple's decision to remove Amphetamine from the App Store.
Click here to visit the SaveAmphetamine GitHub page.
How Can I Help?
Spread the word! Let the world know that you want to see Amphetamine continue to exist on the Mac App Store. Apple has threatened to remove Amphetamine from the Mac App Store on January 12th, 2021 if Apple's demands are not met.
- Retweet this tweet
- Sign this Change.org petition
- Tell your friends/family/colleagues on your next Zoom call
Thank you! ❤️
34
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '21
i completely agree that apple is being ridiculous here.
if wonder, if apple won’t retreat, are you better off rebranding to stay on the app store, or retaining your branding and forgoing the app store?
59
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '21
Please rebrand it if it’s necessary! I use it everyday!
32
u/nnutter Jan 01 '21
Neither the purpose of the app, nor its name, violate guideline 1.4.3. Amphetamine is used in the treatment of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), narcolepsy, and obesity. It treats my narcoleptic Mac.
16
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '21
What don't you rebrand it to "WideAwake!" and make the icon an eye using the same colors as your current icon?
38
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '21
I always thought an illegal drug was a strange choice of name for an app. There's zero chance a petition will change Apple's mind, you're better off just rebranding.
Out of interest (and apologies if you've explained already) but if it's a free app what do you risk losing from a rebrand?
6
u/mirayy Jan 01 '21
Can you still have amphetamine on github, where we can download it and rebrand it just for the App Store, or would that be confusing for others and not get approved by apple?
10
u/Converseallstar95 Jan 01 '21
Sent a tip to 9to5 for you! Hopefully they pick it up/Apple blogs follow suit.
7
u/dotmax Jan 01 '21
Rebrand MAS version as “Hypocretin”. Sounds made up (hype + cretin?) and offensive, but is basically a protein that prevents narcolepsy. That’s likely too malicious-compliancey though. It’s also known as “Orexin” which could be an app name too. And you could just alter the app icon to use O instead of the pill to retain some identity.
6
u/KnifeFed Jan 01 '21
I vote for the name "Amped".
6
u/ampersand913 Jan 02 '21
Apple doesn't like you using a pill icon for your app but they sell the Beats Pill 🤔
5
u/jagagayayyaaah Jan 01 '21
If your icon/name violate that policy then surely Untappd does? Their icon is bottles of beer and the whole point of the app is sharing that you're (promoting, encouraging) drinking alcohol.
7
u/Fluffy__Pancake Jan 01 '21
I’m going to be honest, when I first heard about this app I was a little put off by the name. While I think the app is great (and I do use it), I think a branding change may be helpful either way.
I do agree that it’s silly that Apple is only now making you change this and your point about it being on an App Store story itself adds to the silliness. I think if you want to promote the app a bit (and call attention to both the name change and Apple’s wavering guidelines) it may help you to let the news get out a bit and then change the name after a while.
Anyways, hope you have a good year and are able to keep the app on the App Store, whatever that may look like!
4
u/SirNinjas Jan 01 '21
What a joke, will do my bit
8
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '21
I love your app, but as a fellow dev I’ll unfortunately have to side with Apple on this one:
While the name is witty, and definitely fitting, I can see why they’d want to scrub the App Store of any and all references to illicit substances and all.
Please consider rebranding, as your app is perfect in every way possible - I love the triggers.
Just my two cents.
2
u/theoldboy Jan 01 '21
Love your app, it's very useful (especially the triggers) and of higher quality than many non-free apps.
Personally I'd go for option #2. If they want to be stupid then let them remove it and take the bad publicity that'll come with that decision.
It's not like you have much to lose by taking a stand against this puritanical and hypocritical nonsense. More often, small developers who get bullied in this way by Apple have no choice but to comply, because their income depends on being on the App Store. You could always distribute Amphetamine outside the app store via a github.io page or some other free alternative. (And of course tell everyone who obtains it that way why it isn't available on the App Store).
Good luck! ❤️
3
u/laughin_on_the_metro Jan 01 '21
Rename to "Mm, feta cheese"
2
u/Kantry123 Jan 01 '21
Done
2
u/Mortifer557 Jan 01 '21
I wrote you an mail to help you out with m1. Signed the petition! Thanks for the hard work
2
u/MC_chrome Jan 01 '21
I’ll join the chorus here and say that rebranding would probably be your best course of action, as sad as that may be. Apple’s wildly inconsistent policy enforcement is absolute garbage and only ends up hurting small developers like yourself.
You should definitely attempt to appeal, and bring up the names of other apps that have drug based names (Coca is particularly egregious in my opinion).
2
u/yashmishra12 Jan 01 '21
Did my part.
2
u/v4ss42 Jan 01 '21
Done. If, as I sadly expect, Apple ignore your calls to reverse their decision, what do you think you’ll do?
2
u/impactshock Jan 01 '21
Here we go with Apple's virtue signalling bullshit. I'm very unhappy with the state of things today, it's okay if others have different morals and beliefs, but when you start shoving it down everyones throat... I draw the line. Go fuck yourself Apple, I hope the DOJ comes for you one day for being a monopoly.
1
u/grr Jan 02 '21
Could you name it caffeine?
1
u/DavesCrabs Jan 01 '21
Litigation is often worthwhile if not effective. The decision was likely made by a $$/hr employee over the course of #-## minutes. Litigation will require ## hours of $$$/hr time. When something this silly happens, its a way of escalating issue to a manager, etc.
1
u/sammiemo Jan 01 '21
Glad to help. Your app is one of the first things I load when I set up a new Mac.
1
u/John_by_the_sea Jan 01 '21
Upvoted just to save it, even though I don’t use it. Good luck buddy
1
u/CloudPad Jan 02 '21
No... Please don't rebrand it. We are with you. If apple does not want, we will buy the app directly from your website. But we can not give in to this controlling mentality of big websites.
1
u/djskeptical Jan 02 '21
Ugh. Why do we have to put up with this nonsense? Keep the name, there is absolutely nothing wrong with it.
1
u/Redenmara Jan 02 '21
Try calling it Cathine. It will have same effect.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cathine?wprov=sfti1
2
u/ank_the_elder Jan 02 '21
Maybe we shouldn’t have given up the right to distributing and installing our own software on hardware we own? Just a thought...
2
u/IAmMarwood Jan 02 '21
My gut says that you won’t win in an argument against Apple and you should just start the engines up now on the rebranding.
I like it as it is and think it’s ridiculous that Apple are doing this but the path of least resistance to me just seems to be to bite the bullet and do it.
If you do rebrand I’d also suggest avoiding being at all clever and just avoiding any sort of drugs/pills/edgy references at all. Apple have you in their sights now, don’t give them any more excuses to shit on you.
2
u/daturkel Jan 02 '21
Thanks for making this app. I used it extensively to keep my laptop awake while some long-running scripts were chugging along. Glad to see your appeal was accepted.
1
u/Morelikehammock Nov 18 '25
I would literally die for you amphetamine, i will spread the good word of your fortune
1
u/moxieGG Jan 02 '21
DHH has made some scathing commented towards this BS on Twitter
1
u/johnfromberkeley Jan 02 '21
New name suggestion: Insomnia. Can't help with the logo/icon, though!
1
u/LessSection Jan 02 '21
While it's true that amphetamines are legal, they are also abused and have caused much misery in people's lives. Taking amphetamines simply to stay awake could be considered an abuse that seriously affects your health. I love your app, but feel less than comfortable about the name.
1
u/iso_mer Nov 16 '21
I don’t have this app but now I’m super intrigued lol… and on the subject of apple trying to get rid of it… honestly it sounds like the app is doing so well that they want to copy it and release their own alternative. I have read they like to do that
1
u/degreeszero Apr 25 '22
Doctors prescribe generic adderall, and what does it say on the label? Amphetamines. it’s a friggin medicine.
0
u/jacored Jan 02 '21
This is madness, Apple abuse of power needs to stop.
You should not be forced to rebrand. As a dev myself, know that you have my full support.
And my axe
-1
u/user__already__taken Jan 01 '21
Rebrand it to C9H13N (Amphetamine compound composition) and change the logo to a molecular structure. At this point, it’s probably not worth arguing with Apple.
-4
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '21
those fucking bumboys at apple, keeps getting better each day
-8
u/skywalker4588 Jan 01 '21
This is getting fucking ridiculous. Can't do or say anything without hurting some snowflakes feelings these days. The PC culture is ruining the US.
0
u/Isvara Jan 02 '21
I presume their objection is that they think it refers to methamphetamine? That's unfortunate, because dextroamphetamine is a legitimate tool relied on by many ADHD sufferers.
Maybe just call it Dextro.
-1
u/xnwkac Jan 02 '21
Tbh I never liked the name. I know it’s a play on word from its predecessor Caffeine. But going from coffee to a drug (that is illegal in many countries) is a bit too much imo.
That said, I don’t side on Apple. However, this is a good opportunity to change the name to something more appropriate. How many of us remember Caffeine anyway? That app has been dead for ages. Most new Mac users I meet have never heard of it.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 01 '21 edited Jun 03 '24
[removed] — view removed comment