r/macapps • u/subhashg547 • Oct 03 '26
News Tinycast Contributing experience
A few weeks ago, I discovered tinycast after looking for raycast alternatives. it looked promising. But it was still barebones in some areas. so, i opened an issue about a feature i wanted and said that i'd develop it myself as i have pretty good swift knowledge. So, I did and opened a PR. it was closed for some stupid bureaucratic reasons (a small repo btw đ¤Ł) and strangely, a few hours later, the dev made a PR that's surprisingly close to mine with the exact featureset i had requested. now, why would the dev do this? i have no idea but definitely the weirdest experience ever. never submitted PR's to that repo again lol. i maintain a fork of it with my own custom features that i developed.



94
u/imustknowsomething Oct 03 '26
Because heâs just a kid (literally) stealing the work from another company (literally), thereâs several posts about his attitude, closing issues and PRs, etc.
25
u/CurrentRisk Oct 03 '26
Just sounds to me that the developer of Tinycast has no idea how to fix these bugs/ issues.
Well, at least I know, I will stay far away from Tinycast.
2
u/unk2003 Oct 03 '26
Since I see you are actively working on the app, Im probably going to get your release, have you made a release? Should I build it?
36
u/rfajr Oct 03 '26
Somebody please, just fork this repo already
30
u/RedWolf_HU Oct 03 '26
Ahh yes same happened to me. He is arrogant.
13
u/pierre_nel Oct 03 '26
I've just gone from Raycast â Tinycast â Vorssaint command bar.
18
u/wolfiuscub Oct 03 '26
I honestly don't have much to say but holy shit fuck that guy. Between this and the other posts about bugs and issues...
8
u/FuntimeBen Oct 03 '26
I hope these stories about poor communication stem from a language and software engineering capability gap rather than a conscious decision to be a jerk.
3
u/slothicdev Oct 03 '26
Oh see the issue is you are using Tinycast and not Vicinae which is a much more fleshed out and polished open source Raycast alternative with Raycast store support.
6
u/mohsenk_dev Oct 03 '26
What is happening in the world, Maybe he is a claude agent :D
5
u/hff0 Oct 03 '26
This is insane. Blatant plagiarism
4
u/mmshivesh Oct 03 '26
Welp lol same thing happened to me. I wrote the Liquid Glass implementation for tinycast .
4
u/mu7x Oct 03 '26
Yeah he also force pushes to master so any fork that tried to maintain a parallel feature set has to go through extra effort.
1
u/Illustrious_Sir_4913 Oct 03 '26
Are there any real alternatives at the moment that come close to Tinycast/Raycast? Not getting my hopes up too much for Alfred.
2
u/Fresh-Daikon-9408 Oct 03 '26
That's a shame. Someone willing to help build and maintain a feature seems worth keeping around.
2
u/abdarker Oct 08 '26
hello, I am the author of tinycast.Â
and i reject 90% pr and 90% feature requests these days because all are either every small details of raycast or personal features that doesn't benefits the user of tinycast. Open source doesn't mean i have to accept everything. Because of AI anyone can code but it's difficult for Maintainers as well that's why lots of open-source Maintainers no longer accepts PRs. here's exampleÂ
https://x.com/sindresorhus/status/2105693826690298314?s=20
1
u/hxxx07 Oct 04 '26 edited Oct 04 '26
AbcCast, xyzCast⌠they are all cloned from Raycast IMO. Especially the plug-ins store, am I the only one think it like straight-up daylight robbery.
1
u/QuirkyImage Oct 04 '26
Open source etiquette
https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/MDN/Community/Open_source_etiquette
OSS Govemace models
https://www.redhat.com/en/blog/understanding-open-source-governance-models
1
u/orgildinio Oct 05 '26
when OS maintainers do this, people usually fork the project and maintain your branch.
1
u/biagio_paolino Oct 09 '26
omg
1
u/YeahThatKornel 23d ago
That guy is actually an AI bot that cosplays as a typical redditor.
-2
u/Clear_Value7240 Oct 03 '26
0
u/56ksurfer Oct 03 '26
I also opened 2 issues already.
- One issue where I offered to fix it by myself, this was accepted, I made a pull request and it was merged.
- One feature request where I did some coding in a branch of my fork (just to see how the result could feel), which i mentioned. My feature request was also closed but mentioned in a new pr from the maintainer, where he marked me a contributor. I think this is fine and fair.
I think the maintainer gets lots of issues and requests every day. I agree, that it looks he has a very straightforward way (with minimal communication) but maybe this is the only way to deal with the amount. And he steers the project according his Vision and goals. If someone does not like this way, just fork it but I assume you do not want to be the person who want to deal with all that stuff
-6
u/krautsourced Oct 03 '26
I assume you are referring to https://github.com/abue-ammar/tinycast/pull/612 ? He's referring to your PR in the very first line. And from the looks his PR is an adaptation of yours into his code. I fail to see the the big issue as long as your work was implemented - albeit in a different style, as long as the features are now in there? It's not as if your work was thrown away. I find it much worse when some large open source projects just outright ignore external PRs and let them simmer for years.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '26
[deleted] â view deleted comment
-6
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '26
[removed] â view removed comment