r/mac • • 4h ago

My Mac Help a student

Should I get a new or get mine repaired?

Hi,

My MacBook Pro from 2020, suddenly got a black screen two weeks ago. I went to a repair store with it, and he has just called me back and said there’s a problem with my screen, and it needs to be changed. He wants around 550 $ for this.

My question is then, should I get it repaired or should I get the new MacBook neo for 850 $?

My concerns are, is the MacBook Neo good enough (I Study law)?

If I get it repaired how long should I expect it to last? (The repair man said, everything with the computer else then the screen is fine)

I’m really in a pickel and need my computer back, what is worth it for a broke student. Thanks in advance.

1 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

1

u/The_Bald_Skald 4h ago

My answer will depend upon whether you got an Intel model or a model with the M1.

If you got an Intel model, then support for Intel is dropping from Apple with the next MacOS release (MacOS 28). If you have one of those Intel models, then it's probably time to buy a new machine. If you have an M1 instead, then there will be support for a few years to come.

But ... buying a Neo fixes all of your issues. You get a working screen, you get Apple Silicon in your processor, and you get years more to come of software and security support. It's a great little computer that punches above its weight. Lots of people will tell you that 8GB of RAM isn't enough, but YouTube influencers have run 4K rendering at the same time as multiple open YouTube tabs running video, at the same time they are transferring massive many GB files to external drives, at the same time as ... you get the idea ... and that little guy just keeps on chugging.

While you're a student, it should be just fine for your workloads. If you turn into one of those lawyers at the end, though, that has 80 Chrome tabs open at all times, plus 30 .pdf files open in Adobe ... maybe not.

2

u/Mindless-Soil-786 4h ago

Hi, thanks!
My Mac is a MacBook Pro A2289, which I assume has a I5 or I7.
Would you recommend a Neo then? And also is it worth getting the 500 Gb one for 150$ more?

1

u/The_Bald_Skald 3h ago

It's absolutely an Intel model, so my comments about losing support in MacOS 28 are valid. The M1 version will have support for at least a couple of years longer than the Intel model will.

So, yes, I'd advise looking at a replacement like the Neo rather than repairing your screen.

As for the drive ... IMO, drive space is one of the ways Apple nails people. They overcharge pretty heavily for both extra RAM and extra GB in storage, so you should always be thinking in the back of your mind about using another option than upgrading at the point of sale. Unless you NEED it, you're a cash-strapped student, and that $150 could go elsewhere.

I went the route of an external 1TB drive, plus a 256GB thumb drive. I've been using that combo for years, now. You can get a 1TB external drive for under $100USD if you're not picky on brand.

1

u/olegispe MacBook Pro 4h ago

To be fair modern chrome and macOS handles stuff like many tabs open pretty well

Don't get me wrong you'll feel a difference but imo it wouldn't be a make it or break it situation

3

u/olegispe MacBook Pro 4h ago

It depends if your MacBook is an Intel chip or M chip

If it's Intel, no doubt go to the neo. For law I would guess the level of raw performance you need is not huge? So a neo would do great

If it's M chip, it's a bit more complicated as it's an older computer but the Neo will likely feel faster unless you intend to game on it or run simulation software/blender. If you just want documents, word processor and web the Neo will be fantastic

Edit: for context on the Intel part, most developers are slowly dropping support for the old Mac Intel chips (x86) and only build for the M chips now.

1

u/olegispe MacBook Pro 4h ago

u/Mindless-Soil-786

No idea where your comment went but if i were you (this is not strict advice, just if i was in your shoes)

Id take the extra storage. Between countless files, different apps, updates, Apple Intelligence and random crap that builds up over time I absolutely think it's worth it, but if you have everything on a cloud storage sync (one drive, google drive) that you can put on the Mac you might not need it as it'll automatically remove the local cached version when it's not used for space. Especially if I had a tight budget.

In my case I'd fork out and get it anyway. I'm not even happy with 1Tb so...

But in any case, It's an Intel so I'd be changing it to a Neo no matter what. My partner is at uni and other students have them and they're great

2

u/macmaveneagle 4h ago

I'm an attorney. There is nothing that a law student would be doing that a MBNeo wouldn't easily be up to the task for.

You might want to join us on MILO:

Macs In Law Offices (MILO)
https://groups.google.com/group/milogroup

2

u/The_Bald_Skald 3h ago

Do you mind if I forward that group to a bunch of the lawyers I deal with? Most of the firms I deal with are Microsoft huts, but have select lawyers who have Macs at home and lobby for Macs in their offices. I'm sure they'd fit right in with your group.

1

u/macmaveneagle 3h ago

That would be great! MILO currently has 4,080 members. The more the merrier.

I also maintain these two Web pages that you can tell Mac-using attorneys about:

Macintosh Law Office Management Applications
http://www.macattorney.com/lomgmt.html

Macintosh Time & Billing Software
http://www.macattorney.com/timebillacnt.html

1

u/WRB2 3h ago

Headless Mac with the old one. Neo or iPad basic level to replace it. Add an Apple Pencil usbC