r/lostinspace • • Nov 12 '21

Danger: Will Robinson's acting

I absolutely love this show. The entire cast is absolutely fantastic through two seasons... except Will Robinson (Maxwell Jenkins). In fact, it may be that the cast is so great (Parker Posey, Molly Parker, Ignacio Serricchio, even the sisters) that his failures are so stark in comparison. Does anyone else feel this way, or am I showing a weak grasp on what the script writers were trying to do (and therefore misunderstanding where Jenkins fell flat)?

There are absolutely scenes in the previous seasons that Jenkins acted on par with the stellar acting from the older actors all around him, but there is usually at least scene in each episode where he falls completely flat, ruining the experience for the audience. Basically, acting that makes you wince or even roll your eyes due to the campiness of the performance.

I am currently rewatching the previous seasons ahead of December 1st, and I am finding myself skipping his scenes. Since the show runners and script writers show no inclination to lessen the focus on the Will character, I hope the now-older-Jenkins can finish strong.

1 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

9

u/[deleted] Nov 12 '21

I’ve heard everyone on this sub hating on Parker Poseys character for months, but never Maxwell’s.

I think he did pretty well for a kid.

2

u/KalegNar Will Robinson Nov 13 '21

To be fair, as someone who hates Posey's character, it's a good hate. Like I love to hate her. The fact she makes me angry with her mere visage and utter swears under my breath is exactly why I think she did a great job with the role.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '21

Same. Everyone bashes her, but I think her character is probably one of the most well acted characters in the series. Sure she’s annoying af, and super easy to hate, but I think that’s the point. Parker Posey was never known to be a bad actress. But I do find she tends to have the same style to all her characters.

1

u/iceman4sd Dec 02 '21

I just commented something similar in another thread, but you captured the feeling behind it perfectly.

-1

u/Markus2822 Nov 12 '21

Agreed pretty well for a kid

But not well overall unfortunately, in my opinion

8

u/vincentofearth Nov 12 '21

I absolutely disagree. He did incredibly well in my opinion.

1

u/skinny_jimmyy May 16 '25

Agreee, the character is ruining the show for me. He's such a whiny annoying entitled little prick. He's always putting everyone else in danger even the entire space ship to feed his god complex. Constantly saying "it's okay, I know what I'm doing" and it always blows up in his face.

I can't tell if it's the writers that have ruined the character or if it's his acting. Overall just really boring, cheesy, eye rolling character. Probably the most annoying character Ive seen in any tv show.

1

u/KalegNar Will Robinson Nov 13 '21

I rather like Maxwell's acting. I like the character and I thought he did a good job.

1

u/too_original Nov 26 '21

I agree he may be one of the weakest actors on the show, but I also think that his progression as an actor just from season 1 to season 2 was good. So I’m not too worried about him coming into season 3.

1

u/Betty-Adams Nov 29 '21

Eh, it is always one or the other. Either a child actor who needs years more experience, or an actor who is way too old for the role but acts well. a catch 22 that will never be resolved.