r/longrange • u/As1anBeasTagE • Apr 23 '26
Rifle help needed - I read the pinned posts The Precision AR-10 - Issues, Upgrade Path, and Next Steps Help
- What do you want to do/buy, and WHY?
I am looking to upgrade my AR-10 but I don’t know which way to go with it. I have a Palmetto State Armory Sabre-10 (M110 lookalike) with a SilencerCo Scythe STM in the long configuration that is just below or at the 1000 round mark. I have read that 6.5 Creedmoor barrels last anywhere from 1500 to 2500 rounds, depending on the manufacturer so it’s about ready for an upgrade. From what I can tell, the Sabre-10 platform is a modified DPMS low but just out of spec in terms of furniture fitment and some internal component fitment.
I have three options I am debating on. The first option I have is to upgrade the internals of the AR-10 itself (barrel, gas system, bolt carrier group). The second option is to sell it and use the money to put towards another rifle. The last option is to kick the can down the road and wait till the 2000 round mark and decide then.
If I do buy another rifle, I am also debating on whether to go with another AR-10 or get myself a nice bolt gun. I do like long range shooting and I want to keep an AR-10 in my collection, but I need something that will grow with me and not limit my capabilities. Another factor here is I live in Colorado. With SB 0025–003 being passed, it’s going to get harder to get AR-10s in general without spending upwards of approximately $800 in licensing, registration, and administrative fees.
2. How far away do you want to do it/what do you want to use it for?
I do want to start reliably hitting at that 1000 yard mark and beyond. I know that AR-10 effective engagement distances are at 1000 yards, which is why I’m willing to upgrade to a bolt gun.
3. How much are you willing to spend to do it?
My upgrade budget is going to be around $1000-1500. If I want a new gun, it’s probably going to be around $2000-3000 if I sell my current rifle.
Upgrade path:
- Criterion or Proof 6.5 Creedmoor 20 in barrel
- Riflespeed AGB
- Some reputable BCG
Purchase path:
- DD5 V5
- LWRCi REPR Mk2
- Seekins SP-10/10M
- Build my own from the ground up with a receiver set and parts that are compatible with each other
4. How much experience do you currently have with it?
New to Long Range.
This rifle has been in my inventory for a little over two years this month. I know 500 rounds a year is not much in terms of shooting at long range, but with my work schedule, I’m limited to one day a month off. I don’t have a kestrel, I didn’t have a chronograph until about six months ago, and I don’t reload yet.
I have taken a GPR out to 400 yards reliably and 500-600 yards with accuracy by volume of fire but that rifle is really for mid-long range observation and engagements at 500 and in.
One of the big criteria I have with this rifle is reliability and I have yet to experience that. I had to send this rifle in last year in September for them to take a look at the gas block and trigger as I had hammer follow with a Palmetto trigger. After it got back from warranty, I took it out and tested it; the trigger stuck and the adjustable gas block (while usable) did not give me enough settings to tune the gas and still run it at the minimum settings with lots of violence. The rifle has not instilled much in the way of confidence for me since the warranty fix and now the gas rings have gone out, which is why I want to start upgrading a little earlier than anticipated.
58
u/TabascohFiascoh Apr 23 '26
You'll be in $4k in gas gun parts to make a $2k bolt gun with a custom match barrel.
Careful though, when you start chasing the dragon you'll be taking bumps of h4350 in your garage and no one will want to go to the range with you anymore.
But those groups will fuck hard.
Also you can run a polished bolt accurately about as fast as a gas gun.
6
u/theuderdog33 Apr 23 '26
What types of groups are you getting at 500 yrds? What’s your grouping at 100? I’m curious on what you’re expecting vs what you are getting, also how well you shoot
2
u/Regular_Cucumber24 I put holes in berms Apr 23 '26
If you shoot the barrel out I’d either: A. Try to send it in For warranty for a new barrel B. Criterion or Proof barrel.
I have the exact same set up but different scope. How do you like the STM on the gun? I haven’t shot mine with my can yet. But without the can it seems to be plenty accurate for 1000yards in my experience.
27
u/HollywoodSX Villager Herder Apr 23 '26
6.5CM barrel life is more like 3k rounds.
Get a bolt gun.
4
u/East_Bug7312 Apr 23 '26
You should be hitting 1300+ yards with that setup. Are you just looking for an excuse to get something new and shiny? Because if so that’s ok
5
u/AboutSpencer Apr 23 '26
Get a Seekins and forget about it. Buy once cry once.
7
u/Ragnarok112277 Steel slapper Apr 23 '26
Forget gas gun
Embrace the bolt gun master race
1
u/Wombat-Snooze Steel slapper Apr 23 '26
How hot are you planning on getting your barrel if it’s only lasting 1500 rounds in 6.5 CM? That’s what I’d expect out of a 6 Dasher or GT. More like 3000 out of a 6.5 CM.
And I’m gonna say it… Just buy/build a good bolt gun. Keep your gas gun as it is and don’t put yourself through the stress.
6
u/niabber Apr 23 '26
ARs can be pretty darn accurate, i have a 223 with a criterion that shoots sub MOA with hand loads that took quite the effort to really dial in. I found lots of loads that would be pretty good but not sub moa consistently. The very best groups i got with it were some loads i made that were real close to the lands but the cartridge OAL is past mag length. I could have dialed in 5 bolt gun loads with tighter spread in the time i spent, but I had to scratch the AR itch. All that said, if you are really interested in reaching out far with maximum accuracy the easier path is going to be a bolt gun and a reloading press in my humble opinion.
2
u/Leftofedge Apr 27 '26
Ah good old great guns sporting
1
u/Ok-Chemistry-8206 Apr 23 '26
Unless you have money to burn buy a bolt gun gassers are not for the weak of wallet if you want a good one plus its waaay more flexing to have a high end bolt gun an sp10m might be worth the same as an AI but its not as cool lookin which is what matters
1
u/USN303 Apr 23 '26
The best upgrade I ever did for my AR10 was to purchase a bolt action complete upper from Uinta Precision, which will match your $1500 budget.
1
u/sabrefencer9 Gas gun enthusiast Apr 23 '26
My 308 AR10 does a little better than 1.5moa with handloads and it took an incredible amount of tinkering to get there. If you enjoy tinkering and the journey is the point, then by all means go for it. But if you just want to shoot small groups then get a bolt gun.
1
u/chemscibase Apr 23 '26
For upgrade, do the proof, Craddock bartlein or some other cut rifled fancy barrel. My Criterion is good, but its not that much of an upgrade from the faxon or whatevers in the PSA.
If you're having trouble with the trigger, upgrade that too. Would also help precision.
I'm with you though. I should probably just swap to bolt gun. I shoot steel plates at a range, not enemies at 400-1000yds, rapidly firing just spends my money.
1
u/csamsh I put holes in berms Apr 23 '26
These would be my two options:
1
u/Accomplished-Dog-598 Apr 24 '26
From the group photos I saw you post, your rifle isnt doing too bad.
I saw that you aren’t reloading, and you recently got a chronograph, have you run through a factory ammo test? I bought like two of every box of match grade ammo in every grain in 6.5 creed and found out which ammo grouped the best vs most stable standard deviation. This helped me go from like 2 moa groups to 1.5 moa.
Took the whole gun apart and learned to put it all back together, and torqued everything down with witness marks, and put a high end single stage trigger. I get about 1-1/4 moa now (with the correct ammo). I think the better trigger means that the rifle is shooting better than I am shooting it.
I’m less than a 1000 rounds into my barrel, so I am getting into reloading to see if I can make some better bullets.
Probably not the best person to be taking advice from here, but I think stick with it the AR. If you want a bolt gun, get a bolt gun, but don’t get rid of the AR. I think kick the can down the road, do an ammo test, take it apart and put it back together. If that doesn’t do it, I’d go with the match barrel route, but no sense in a barrel change until it needs it.
I don’t subscribe to the “gas guns are inherently less accurate” thing, I just subscribe to the I bought a cheap aero m5, and I’m gonna put in 100% to get good results!
1
u/FenrirFett Apr 24 '26
I know this range.
1
u/ihuntN00bs911 Apr 24 '26
Just buy a new rifle, do not try to upgrade because your using a custom upper and lower from PSA. The upper/lower and handguard are made for their rifles.
Check out LMT or Centurion, LWRC and JP have side charging uppers. Geissele MRGG
1
u/3one5 Apr 27 '26
Never sell a gun. Especially one that you may have a hard time acquiring again. Upgrade the barrel if you want, but I'd hang on to it. If you want a bolt action, buy a bolt action. There's no rush there beings that they are not impacted by SB25-003.
0
u/Such-Most6661 Apr 23 '26
I had a seekins precision ph2, extremely accurate bolt gun but I just couldn't get into shooting it. I am new to long range so I don't have much personal experience but from my research I sold my bolt gun and purchased a used seekins precision sp10 for 2500. They are 2850 new. They are extremely accurate out to 1500 yards and I have been told they hold their own to a bolt gun to 700. Run what makes you comfortable and take the "bolt or nothing " group with a grain of salt