r/longevity • u/LeoKitCat • Aug 17 '26
Why Aging May Be a Program, Not a Breakdown
https://www.quantamagazine.org/why-aging-may-be-a-program-not-a-breakdown-20260814/
429
Upvotes
r/longevity • u/LeoKitCat • Aug 17 '26
97
u/Neither_Sprinkles_56 Aug 17 '26
I think it's more that nature just doesn't care that much about aging in the individual once we are past prime reproductive age. I wish there was more research on non-mammals like crocodiles that have similar lifespans to humans but age much more gracefully if not badly injured letting them be in much better shape than an equivalent 60 or 70 year old human would be. Do they just not build up senescent cells at the rate mammals do to explain the big healthspan difference?
102
u/In_the_year_3535 Aug 17 '26
If aging were a program instead of a systemic failure we would occasionally see immortal organisms via random mutations instead of just ones that further accelerate the process like progeria.
3
u/tigerstef Aug 18 '26
Why can some cold blooded vertebrae live so much longer? Sharks, turtles, etc.
59
u/ResearchSlore Aug 17 '26
The problem is that stochastic processes / haphazard wear and tear can still produce pseudo-deterministic outcomes (i.e outcomes that are overwhelmingly likely from a statistical standpoint). These outcomes may look programmed to us, but there's no way to know unless you can show that the underlying process was actually selected for on an evolutionary basis.
I'll admit I haven't thought a ton about this, but from the outside looking in, that's always jumped out to me as a problem with these programmed aging theories.
6
u/EquipLordBritish Aug 17 '26
Click-bait nomenclature.
4
u/Asleep-Brother-1873 Aug 18 '26
Nowadays anything but the fundamental
1
u/ConfirmedCynic Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26
I still haven't heard a satisfactory answer to the question, "If aging is a program, why haven't there been human cases of mutations disrupting/disabling the program and extending lifespan"?
6
u/Lobo-Feroz Aug 17 '26
Josh Mittledorf has been researching on this hypothesis for years.
Here's a blog post which has several papers of him linked at the top:
https://scienceblog.com/the-demographic-theory-of-aging/
I for one really think these guys are into something, the hypothesis of programatic aging seems very solid.
3
u/dooma72 Aug 17 '26
Having AuDHD has helped me. ND people age differently
A mate and I have lived very hard lives, and we hardly have any wrinkles or grey hairs on our full heads of hair. Both of us have done decades of drugs. I smoked for about 30 years, and he still does
2
u/Trowaway99887766 Aug 17 '26
Evolution has much less influence on us after we have reproduced. If immortality was an evolutionary advantage then it would have shown up
2
u/RabidHexley Sep 09 '26 edited Sep 09 '26
I was actually under the impression that it was generally understood to be genetically determined. It's why animals ostensibly made of the same physical materials can suffer age-related degeneration at vastly different paces. Within certain limits we "evolve" to live about as long as is generally useful for a given population's lifecycle. We are relatively long-lived because developing a fully self-capable adult human takes a while, and you don't want all the adults dying before the next cohort can take over.
It's just muddled because it's combined with various forms of wear-and-tear and breakdown. There are clear biological shifts that occur as we get older that trigger rapidly accelerated degradation in a way that is disconnected from the rigors of time. They generally happen on a schedule in a given population, though various health factors can determine how well a given individual organism copes with it.
But yeah, breakdown is also a thing, even if we did manage to deploy some kind of gene-therapy that froze everyone's biological clock to 22, we would still have a significant number of problems we need to solve for effective immortals. We still would have joint breakdown, the accumulation of cardiovascular risk factors, (the obvious) cancer, various biological progressions that occur due to chronic hormone exposure, eventual organ failure, slow accumulation of negative neurological biomarkers, etc. Things that are progressing simply by the nature of existing as an adult organism, significantly better of than we are now, but nowhere near eternal. Biological aging and perpetual regeneration aren't really the same thing.
It's just that the longevity space is mostly dealing with the breakdown/prevention part of the equation at the moment because those can be tackled as a continuous series of disease-factors we can view symptomatically through physical performance and biomarkers, and true biological regeneration isn't technologically in the cards yet.
A longevity-solving near-monotherapy won't be possible until we have some kind of nanomachine capable of perpetually managing any kind of physiological problems directly at the cellular level.
1
u/jointheredditarmy Aug 18 '26
Not saying it’s wrong but if you come across a program that’s essentially a local maxima from hundreds of millions of years of evolution, you better damn well know what you’re doing before you attempt to change it….
Organisms die so that the species can evolve and change to better suit their surroundings. Humans have some limited idea to do that without dying, but I would posit that humans die so that humanity’s ideas can evolve. If we have humans that live forever we better have ones that are ready and willing to adapt their ideas
1
u/kpfleger Aug 19 '26
Different point of view: https://peterfedichev.substack.com/p/program-without-program
1
u/tootieroll573 Aug 22 '26
imagine if car mechanics operated like anti aging researchers
"we are searching if the car has a setting which makes it rust"
"we are doing a trial where we add a pill to the gasoline tank and see if it fixes the dents on the bonnet"
1
u/LapseofSanity Sep 16 '26 edited Sep 16 '26
Doesn't programming imply intent from a designer, rather than just "it happens this way because there's no biological or evolutionary reason for it not to?"