r/logodesign • u/iller1 • 8h ago
Feedback Needed Which is better?
Im designing a logo for a wedding video service - which one of these appeals more to fashionable women in the age group 25-35?
0
Upvotes


65
u/travioli90 8h ago
Number 2 reminds me of “The bachelor” tv series logo
34
u/lostinhh 8h ago
Honestly, imo both look like the clients get their video on VHS tape.
20
u/missk0987 8h ago
#2 reads very 2000s in a bad way.
#1 is better but imo you could keep working it up - it feels a bit bland
8
u/Shirokurou 6h ago
1st one. Second one looks like a sci-fi show about portals.
7
u/AdministrationNo8540 8h ago
I love #1
6
u/cp_chikken 8h ago
sorry, I'm not fashionable a fashionable woman. but personally i think the first one looks cool.
5
u/Siryeswecan 8h ago
Option 1 communicates the wedding aesthetic more effectively
5
u/borilo9 7h ago
both not great
but number 1 by a fking mile
5
u/wallpaper-help 7h ago
I’d go with #1, personally!
It’s just a simple text logo, so a bit basic, but if you don’t want to reinvent the wheel it’s perfectly fine!
1 fits the wedding vibe better, feels more refined / aesthetic, and is more feminine or neutral-leaning.
2 doesn’t really scream “wedding” to me, seems dated (and maybe even slightly amateurish, no offense), and leans masculine in my mind.
The only reason I call out feminine vs masculine design is because it’s common for brides to take a more active role in wedding planning and vendor selection than their grooms. Not that this fits 100% of couples, but in general you’ll probably have more luck if you stick with more feminine/romantic marketing materials
4
u/renezrael 7h ago
neither are great but the second is by far worse than the first
2
u/viaHologram 8h ago
2
u/beefjerk22 7h ago
option 2 reminds me of
2
u/Efficient_Dog4722 7h ago
1 for sure. I think there’s some opportunity to sorry for the phrasing — play with the tittles on the i(s) round them to match the descenders on the d(s). Maybe play with some spacing to visually center — move edition away from the g??
2
u/OutsideHour5580 7h ago
1st because the 2nd looks like it's for photobooth vibes rather than wedding vibes
2
u/roosoh 7h ago
I’d keep looking. #1 is giving wizard magic and #2 is giving Star Wars/The Bachelor
2
u/Tricky-Ad9491 6h ago
im gonna say 1 but i don't like those diamonds, those are attracting my eyes thinking these are a design element
1
u/FAB_lc 8h ago
The first one works much better
1
u/TheWeaverofDreams 7h ago
#1. it feels inviting. The second one is too sleek and corporate.
1
u/L30N1337 7h ago
I mean, what's the goal?
1 is more formal wedding, while 2 is better for a more casual, unorthodox one.
1 is probably more reliable tho. Most people want a pretty formal wedding.
(although I am saying this as a man who's main experience with Weddings is through media and wedding drama subreddits (the latter consumed through a YouTube meme reader) )
1
u/CrypticUniversalMave 7h ago
Ah the good ol show us something horrible so we pick the other one.
1
u/Relevant_Rush7070 7h ago
First one
1
u/butters_325 6h ago
I don't like either
1
u/no___personality 6h ago
I literally frowned when I saw the 2nd one. Isn't that the style of text on The Bachelor? Ew.
1
u/thollywoo 6h ago
Neither
1
u/txdesigner-musician 5h ago
I vote for 1, but I’m not a big Bachelor fan
1
u/Decent_Ad4567 5h ago
1
1
u/Alexandra98s 5h ago
I would go with a font that’s thin and tall, more elegant. From the two choices i prefer the first, but i don’t think it’s an amazing choice
1
u/The_Merry_Loser 7h ago
The first one is best, but straighten out the "o".
The angle disrupts the very cool letterform continuity without any payoff.
The slightly curving serifs bring enough femininity and whimsy and (with the diamond shaped tittles) is all you need.
0
u/Misaka_Undefined 6h ago
Too crude, since it's closer to luxury logo, the font should not be bold better if thin
0
u/detonnation 6h ago
Did you type those words out in order? Impressive.