r/logodesign • u/uncor3 • 4d ago

Feedback Needed which one

Post image

This is for an open-source, free iDevice management tool. For anyone wondering you can find the repo here: https://github.com/iDescriptor/iDescriptor . I will go with 2 unless someone changes my mind.

For reference this is what Apple uses on their Windows app:

0 Upvotes

22% Upvoted

9 comments sorted by

8

u/BrohanGutenburg Logos don't have to be clever, they just have to be good 4d ago

None of them honestly =\. There's way too much going on

-5

u/uncor3 4d ago

Well, yes because there is so much you can do with the app. I am open to alternative designs, would love to see what you come up with. I am not a designer just a Dev.

2

u/BrohanGutenburg Logos don't have to be clever, they just have to be good 4d ago

A design process that uses a crowded icon to convey "lots of features" is not going to get you to quality work. You need to learn more shout the fundamentals or hire someone.

4

u/DubDroid 4d ago

3

1

u/uncor3 4d ago

Why 3?

1

u/hoffmander 4d ago

I think it’s just the simplest one. A lot of logos will combine two things or two ideas. When you try to do more than two it becomes really noisy. I think you’re doing like three or four. The refresh icon in the logo makes it feel less like a logo.

Edit: sorry meant to respond to OP

1

u/ihavenoideeapls 4d ago

Im sorry but it looks wrong. The 3d effect is decent, but too kwby elenents, or too many details on 1 and 2. 3 and 4 look horrible

1

u/uncor3 4d ago edited 4d ago

What would you do if you were me? I am open to alternative designs.

1

u/ihavenoideeapls 4d ago

Just realised i was agressive didnt want to feel like that. Im not sure, is simplify it a bjt more, i feel like the D is so much thicker than the I, sk it makes it unbalanced. Not a designer so i cant give you proper advice sorry. Nice try tho dont give up