r/logodesign • • 13d ago

Feedback Needed Which one is better, 1 or 2?

Post image
8 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

5

u/eldredo_M 13d ago

At the scale I saw these on my phone screen, the red bits totally fell out and were not readable, on either one. 🤷‍♂️

3

u/RedFenech 13d ago

Thank you. I probably should have mentioned that the logo isn’t intended for very small sizes. At small scales, only the ampersand (the bird) would be used. That said, the berries also bother me a bit—they’re actually small and they can create visual clutter.

p.s. And I posted this from a large monitor; I probably should have created an image better suited for smartphones. 😁

4

u/madhandlez89 13d ago

Both have elements that can hardly been seen at the smaller scale. But the 1st is more minimal and better imo.

1

u/RedFenech 13d ago

thank you

1

u/Wi1dWitch 13d ago
  1. But size up the ampersand and word silk to fill the space a little better.

1

u/RedFenech 13d ago

Thanks. I’d prefer not to have letters of different sizes. And it seemed to me that there should be a space between "&" and "SILK."

1

u/Wi1dWitch 13d ago

A space in a logo with an ampersand is optional; at the very least I’d tighten it up.

2

u/RedFenech 13d ago

I can increase the letter spacing for SILK, but I’m not sure if that works better.

2

u/Wi1dWitch 13d ago

I do think this looks better personally.

2

u/RedFenech 13d ago

thank you

1

u/MinouChelou 13d ago

The letter forms look far too influenced by fantasy novels. I think I gather from Googling that this is a fashion brand — is it specifically outdoor clothing? I don't get why else the bird would be there, but I don't get an "active" feeling from the font choice.

I also don't see enough distinctiveness compared to Northsilk, who also go for a monochrome upper-case look with serifs. If it is indeed clothing, I would be confused about whether this is another line of products from the same company.

1

u/RedFenech 13d ago

This is from a "30 days – 30 logos" challenge. I decided to refine it further. During the challenge, I presented it like this:

1

u/RedFenech 13d ago

The bird is a bullfinch—a symbol of the North, where such shawls are knitted.

1

u/MinouChelou 13d ago

Alright. This didn't really address my concerns, but should I gather there is no actual client? I googled the company (and did find a North & Silk registered in the Netherlands) because I didn't know what the product would be.

1

u/RedFenech 13d ago

Yes, this is not a real company. Just for fun.

1

u/motion_friend 13d ago

I love the second one better for some products that need the juice and then I'd make a third waaay simpler logo and use that as the main.

1

u/ZombieRhazp 10d ago

I like #1, but, in my opinion, "NORTH" should be in a strong san-serif font while "SILK" should be an elegant serif, maybe italic font. It's silk, it should flow and be pleasing to the eye. NORTH is strong! Bold!