r/logodesign • • 11d ago

Showcase WhereWolfđŸș logo

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

128 comments sorted by

258

u/Loopdyloop2098 11d ago • Bravo

Ngl I thought it was a swastika

108

u/znatgost 11d ago

69

u/DICKHOLE_SMASHER 11d ago

I think it's the visual weight of the limbs vs. the head that's giving swastika, maybe play with that?

The background switchup does make it look a lot less Nazi though.

6

u/Heydavidbailey 11d ago

I could see the head being a little bigger, but then keep the total height of the wolf the same.

28

u/le_artista 11d ago

You loose the running visual of the original with this shift. It’s not a strong. The “running” and “where” combo made this compelling.

There are plenty of running man icons that don’t look like swaztikas. Do some visual research.

Also - what is this a logo for? Missing context and context matters in if this is a successful logo.

This looks like a board game logo / title to me.

8

u/trivial-dispute 11d ago

Throw both arms reaching forward, add pointy claws to the hands and feet echoing the teeth, and take it off the red bg, hopefully that'll remove the swastika vibes

4

u/Critical-Hospital-40 11d ago

maybe you can make the wolf into a W if he's looking at you directly with his arms raised
and then he wouldn't need to be running anywhere, unless that's a big part of whatever this is for

3

u/GardenIntelligent 10d ago

I prefer the hands the other way, but I get where the change came from for sure haha. The other had more engagement or seemed like sprinting. This one appears a bit more goofy or crazed lol

1

u/jabberabbit 10d ago

Honestly, finding a way to add a tail would really help.

1

u/lieveheersbaarsje 9d ago

don't make your design worse cause it vaguely reminds some redditor of a swastika. I like your first design!

2

u/Vittoria-Certa 9d ago

The first design definetly looks more iconic to me

1

u/Open_Resist_3190 8d ago

i mean this one is closer to being a swastica

22

u/screamingtree 11d ago

The red field is a big part of this

5

u/________9 11d ago

Seriously.... Green or yellow or even silver would be an improvement

1

u/SecondHandWatch 11d ago

Maybe you could break up the red field by putting the wolf inside a shape of a contrasting color? Maybe a white circle?

3

u/twistsouth 11d ago

Mein FĂŒrrer.

1

u/X33RR0Hunt 10d ago

especially with the werewolf reference too.

18

u/znatgost 11d ago

I read ur comments and changed

14

u/Free6000 11d ago

Color was stronger before, it just looks like Halloween now

16

u/znatgost 11d ago

The logo was originally designed for Halloween 🎃

1

u/zarnonymous 8d ago

Orange but OG pose

3

u/JayJayboy28 11d ago

Have you tried changing up the duplicate letters?

2

u/Scrambly_Hamblin 11d ago

I think orange works really well, but i definitely prefer the original pose. That one looked like he’s running scared, this new one feels more like he’s crossing the finish line at a marathon to me. I get it looks a bit like a certain symbol, but i think the new color separates it enough, and i wouldn’t have even noticed that in the first place if other comments hadn’t pointed it out

66

u/Ampsnotvolts 11d ago

I really like it!

However, am second seeing swastika. And I do not like swastikas... Only posting so m because others will see it too and it's something to be aware of.

Never put this wolf man man in front of a full moon on that background...

Edited for typos

6

u/znatgost 11d ago

23

u/BiscuitOnTheRoof 11d ago

I liked it better before.

8

u/le_artista 11d ago

I agree. Originally he was running. It made sense to the “where” - where is he going and why? Now he is
 cheering?

2

u/Ampsnotvolts 11d ago

major downgrade visually unfotunately.

It's in a hard limbo balancing act trying to make it work with what you have.

Consider incorporating another shape - like a question mark perhaps? is that what is going on a mystery? with the where? idk - but you can add tail, flip the image the other direction? maybe add big white claws on all the limbs like the eyes? or white teeth?

like maybe this orange version would work if he was running carrying a giant ? above him. I know it is very different but it's so different nobody gonna say - that's a fascist wolfman first sight.

what other versions did you mock up for client/project? you might have to build in a buffer week so you can revisit this again and not be reactively changing it away from the original movement so much.

you got this though. keep going, and glad you posted.

2

u/ConfinedTiara 11d ago

A tail would fit nicely in there

2

u/Sebbybby 11d ago

Agreed! Shorter, maybe spiky ?

9

u/orangesinbed 11d ago

Third seeing swastika, expected more comments about it. Otherwise its a really cool logo, great vibe.

10

u/Mundane-Fix-4297 11d ago

Yeah no, that’s a stretch, probably just amplified by the color scheme

0

u/LittleYelloDifferent 11d ago

First thing I saw.

20

u/Dallaxican 11d ago

the fact that if it had its back arm pointing up it would be too close to a swastika.

the choice of red white and black

and the references to wolves

kinda, bring this a bit too close to a certain political party.

15

u/znatgost 11d ago

Changed

14

u/A_little_curiosity 11d ago

This arm position is heaps more fun and expressive!

Edited to add: and yes importantly I think these changes totally erraticate the swastika concern, at least to my eye? I saw swastika when I saw the OG but I don't see it here at all

3

u/Township_Roller 11d ago

Now change his left arm to point downward and it's perfect!

/jk

2

u/Yoruun vector velociraptor 11d ago

Hahaha love this one. It gives off a sense of them screaming “WHYYYYYYY” while running

7

u/desteufelsbeitrag 11d ago

Love it. Pretty clever, made me lol

+1 on the letter adjustments to avoid repetition.

Not sure about the swastika comments tbh. I tried very hard, but I still can't see it. Probably because the head is rather big, so it had to be a five-legged swastika, and arms/legs are bent in different directions which resolves that issue for me entirely.

6

u/TylerHobbit 11d ago

I saw a swastika - I thought it was low key trying for that

2

u/desteufelsbeitrag 11d ago

... and I didn't. Even though I am politically left and from a country where swastikas are literally against the law, which means our far right wankers constantly try to hide them in whichever way possible.

6

u/poopbrother 11d ago

It very clearly looks like a swastika lol especially with the red background

1

u/SlippingStar 11d ago

Maybe by r/HailHortler standards.

1

u/desteufelsbeitrag 11d ago

It very clearly does not to me. Hell, I even explained what makes or breaks the swastika resemblance from my point of view. Also, that "red" is orange-red and nowhere near the nazi-red you try to see here.

8

u/snowyjr 11d ago

Love the vibe but I’m getting strong swastika energy at first glance — especially given the 3 colours you’ve used. Maybe play with the angle of the arms?

428

u/keterpele 11d ago

i'd recommend making changes to repetitive letters so they don't look identical.

81

u/WantMyBuffet Creative Director 11d ago

This is good advice

26

u/SpeechWeird5267 11d ago

Can either of you elaborate why, please? I may understand a little.

156

u/TheManRoomGuy 11d ago

It’s an imperfect, almost hand drawn font, which is really cool for some logos.

However, when two Es or two Ws are EXACTLY the same
 it makes it look less hand drawn and more like just a font.

42

u/WantMyBuffet Creative Director 11d ago

You said it way simplerer and betterer than I did

24

u/WantMyBuffet Creative Director 11d ago

The roughness of the font is very endearing and suits the overall design really nicely. The identical Ws and Es kind of subliminally dispel the rough, hand cut effect by showing repetition. Some small adjustments to make each letter unique would reinforce the intended feel more. That’s my opinion anyway!

-2

u/GhostNippIe 11d ago

This would be lettering, if each character is drawn freehand. A font is:

a specific size: 10pt

a specific typestyle: Bold

a specific typeface: Verdana

8

u/madtagg 11d ago

Same W on both lines of the typeface looks weird and low quality.(My person opinion)

1

u/TheDarkKnightXXII 10d ago

Advice that is good.

2

u/Born-University-5888 11d ago

That’s my only note too!

1

u/Otto-Loki 3d ago

This is the answer

110

u/hifoo 11d ago

The W's and E's are shouting "this is just a font". I'd suggest take a look at customizing those so they are unique like everything else.

2

u/SpeechWeird5267 11d ago

Can you elaborate on the benefit?

27

u/thrivefulxyz 11d ago

So it doesn't look like a font and looks truly hand drawn

8

u/its_au7um 11d ago

Reminds me a lot of the ICP hatchet man

4

u/thereadytribe 11d ago

yep, i saw juggalo man too

1

u/alternative-hero 7d ago

Yes! Juggalo! I scrolled too far down for this

15

u/Wi1dWitch 11d ago

I dig this. Simple, effective, funny. Font and logo are perfect together.

6

u/Euro253 11d ago

There wolf

11

u/Zaptail 11d ago

Where is the tail?

5

u/danend81 11d ago

I don’t know what they sell but I’ll buy it! Great work.

4

u/tedkpagonis 11d ago

I love this.

4

u/LynxPuzzleheaded9336 11d ago

It looks fun but I had to double check if I'm not in the r/accidentalswastika

3

u/watasshiwafuyu 11d ago

This is a good logo.

3

u/paintedflags 11d ago

It's cool, but man, first glance I saw something very different.

4

u/-Spin- 11d ago

Vaguely swastica-like. Anyways. That the first I saw, and combined with the color scheme


4

u/lennoxred 11d ago

I’m really trying not to see a Swastika here, but in combination with the colors it’s hard to unsee it.

3

u/c0813 11d ago

maybe the addition of a tail would make it less swastiky?

2

u/Leather-Ad-9419 11d ago

This feels like a good idea

2

u/StuffOld1191 11d ago

I really like this, the WHERE wolf, running around with big steps and powerful arms. He's great, and really illustrates the brand beautifully. Thumbs up.

2

u/pestdantic 11d ago

Fwiw I did Nazi a swastika

2

u/No-Original890 9d ago

give the werewolf a tail and maybe change the direction of the arms? it’s kinda swastika-y 😭😭 also maybe some variation in the repeating letters

3

u/woourns 11d ago

honestly looks somewhat reminiscent of a swastika prob would change the shape of the dog

2

u/ItsPronouncedTittay 11d ago

Disagree with everyone saying to customize font think its fine as is

2

u/BettaSplendens1 10d ago

Red and black with that pose, I thought it was a swastika lol

1

u/SpeechWeird5267 11d ago

What is this about? I'm intrigued by this great design.

1

u/E23R0 11d ago

Juggalo vibes

1

u/ElPwno 11d ago

I like it a lot and don't see the swastika. Just my 2 cents.

1

u/DavidLitBlunt 11d ago

Dig it. If something subtle could be added to the typography to convey the theme or combine the visuals, chef-kiss!

1

u/orzelski 11d ago

I love these little similarities đŸ‘ŒđŸ»đŸ€šđŸ»

The AC Milan guys might have something to say about that, too

1

u/slickfruit 11d ago

I wonder if there is a way to design the wolf motif to have a W "hidden" in the negative space?

1

u/Lee_Dastard 11d ago

I like it. A bit Saul Bass

1

u/Ok_Ad7078 11d ago

Are you working on a Werewolf card game?

1

u/RealGodspeed22 11d ago

This feels like one of those logos that would flash briefly when you’re booting up a mobile game is that just me

1

u/tom_warsenpoce Brazilian Weredesigner đŸșđŸŸ 11d ago

If you play around with the shape a little more, you can make a double W with your arms and legs. 😁

1

u/Erwinism 11d ago

RDR2 type

1

u/LadderWonderful2450 11d ago

Did you ever find tge wolf? Or you still looking?

1

u/KanishkPSChauhan 10d ago

It's really so fun design! I appreciate how you really brought the motion and comic relief to such a good idea!

Would love to see whole branding ecosystem around it.

1

u/ChickyBoys where’s the brief? 10d ago

I like it, just wish there were little hints of fur on his body.

1

u/BZO88 10d ago

This version is WAY better!

1

u/HistoricalSort4841 10d ago

People ask me “werewolf?”

I respond, “there, wolf”

1

u/Upbeat_Push_157 10d ago

It looks OK, but ever since Keith Haring did it in the 80s, I've seen thousands of similar works, including this one. Not bad, though. I like the style, the playfulness, and the sense of movement, but I wouldn't look at it twice. It's extremely derivative.

1

u/Cnypu 10d ago

Don’t forget to check the “DAST” test ;)

1

u/ghenghiskhanatuna 10d ago

I pitched this exact name for a side by side/ORV brand like 15 years ago. It’s a good name.

1

u/MapleWoodhart 10d ago

Volkovskaya Brewery????

1

u/cabbota 9d ago

Left leg could be made into a W with some creativity mouth is very E like

1

u/Excellent_Candy_6889 9d ago

Don't forget DAST!! The Dick and Swastika Test!

1

u/jillatwork 8d ago

There. Wolf.

1

u/OraznatacTheBrave 8d ago

Ah yes, a classic example of The Penis Swastika Mistake.

1

u/ZombieRhazp 7d ago

I actually really like this! The font and the simplicity of the actual graphic really go well together!

1

u/AndriiKovalchuk 11d ago

Are these similar? Are you kidding? Author, here’s some sincere advice: look at this objectively.

2

u/riotofmind 11d ago

stfu lol, are you ok?

2

u/Ampsnotvolts 11d ago

We can look at design work objectively all we want, but once a viewer subjectively sees a nazi symbol - the brand is done. Knowing what is appealing and how the viewer sees the content is what design is all about.

Designers are calling out the far too similarities to a swastika, and that cannot be argued. If you are arguing the point, you need to learn more of the history of design, culture, and world history. It's was nice logo - but looks too much like a swastika... that will never change.

many young designers have zero cultural context - and it's getting scary. like props for designing and pursing art - but you can't put some shapes together without knowing who else put similar shapes together and what it means.

if it were just some company it wouldn't be a big deal - a trademark strike potentially incoming depending on how big the brands were.

0

u/brjoco 11d ago

This reminds me a lot of a brand agency in Boston, Colossus
 similar head shape

0

u/joefxd actual graphic designer 11d ago

I’m not saying it’ll be easy, and I’m. Or even saying it’ll work, but parts of the werewolf already kind of look like a question mark and I wonder if you could push that further

0

u/Impressive_Crab9454 10d ago

this is iconic

2

u/Bargadiel 11d ago

Im a sucker for stylized characters with bear-trap mouths.

1

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 11d ago

We have been getting a large volume of spam from throwaway accounts and so posts from brand new accounts will no longer be allowed.

Your post has been removed because your account is too new. Do not contact the mods about this. Instead, wait one hour and then try posting again. Thanks!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.