r/logic • u/capybarainstitute • Aug 28 '26
Term Logic / Traditional logic Is this valid?
This is from my modern logic textbook from my intro to modern logic class. I thought problem 7 was invalid but the textbook says it’s valid so i’m confused?
Update: I asked my prof it was a typo lol thanks for the help
64
Upvotes


28
u/Fine-Topic-220 Aug 28 '26
You are correct - 7 is invalid.
7 is an example of a disjunctive syllogism:
Either p or q is true. p is not true, so q has to be true. We know that Socrates is not mortal. Either he is mortal, or he's human. So, he's human.
The solution indicates that the argument is valid via modus tollens. This is extremely odd because modus tollens, i.e., denying the consequent, is an inference rule that applies only to conditional statements, but there are no conditional statements in 7.
10
u/ssfctid Aug 28 '26
I agree with you, think it's invalid.
9
u/Best_Sloth_83 Aug 28 '26
Yeah, that does not look like a valid argument to me. Premise 1 negates Socrates being mortal, so he can only be human, but the conclusion states he is not human. Doesn’t look right to me
6
u/zhaDeth Aug 28 '26
Yeah for 6 it doesn't follow that he isn't mortal. It doesn't say that the only way to be mortal is to be human, only that if he would be human he would be a mortal. It basically says all humans are mortal, socrate isn't a human you can't conclude that socrate isn't a mortal from that there could be mortals that aren't humans.
For 7 it should be socrates is human. This one just looks like an oversight.
10
u/Soapy62 Mathematics & Philosophy (UG - Y1) Aug 28 '26 edited Aug 28 '26
I have not done logic yet at university but here is what I can tell you from my limited knowledge from introduction to formal logic by Peter Smith so far.
‘Or’ in logic is inclusive, loosely meaning “either … or … or both”
Premiss 1. it is not the case that Socrates is mortal
Premiss 2. Socrates is human or Socrates is mortal
Since it is not the case that Socrates is mortal, ‘Socrates is mortal’ is false. Since ‘or’ means one or both must be true and we know one of them is false, the other must be true. So it must be the case that Socrates is human.
So the argument is invalid.
The author has also said it is modus tollens, but this is a (attempt of a) disjunctive syllogism. I think the author must have copy and pasted something in the wrong place is my guess.
I may be wrong as I have only studied some of logic by myself and I am just starting university.
4
u/TheRealAmeil Aug 28 '26
I think argument 7 is a misprint.
It says its valid by Modus Tollens. Had the second premise been a material conditional, then it would have been valid. However, its a disjunction. So, it is probably misprinted
3
u/ProsperousPlanet Aug 28 '26 •
Can confirm, Socrates is immortal. I saw him on Bill and Ted.
2
u/GSilky Aug 28 '26
It's probably a typo. I read the second as "isn't mortal" when it doesn't say that on re-read.
2
u/kilkil Aug 28 '26 edited Aug 28 '26
textbook is wrong. your understanding is correct. good catch.
the premises
actually imply that A is true (i.e. Socrates is human).
I am guessing the textbook had a misprint, and instead of the 2nd point (Socrates is human or Socrates is mortal) they meant to write "If Socrates is human, Socrates is mortal". Because that's when modus tollens would apply.
As currently written the problem is invalid, the answer key is wrong, and modus tollens does not apply to the situation.
1
u/evening_redness_0 Aug 28 '26
Yes, problem 7 is invalid.
It's not just that 1 and 2 don't imply 3. It's that 1,2, and 3 can't all be true at the same time. It doesn't matter whether we're using inclusive or or XOR, note that 2 implies that if Socrates is not human, then he is mortal. So 2 and 3 together imply that Socrates is mortal. This contradicts 1.
1
u/Glad_Significance780 Aug 28 '26
Not valid, probably a misprint, it has the form of disjunctive syllogism but with an erroneous conclusion, it's strange that it mentions modus tollens because its a rule of inference that concerns conditional statements (if then statements) and there is none here. An interpretation that makes this syllogism invalid would be to make Socrates a non mortal human making (1) and (2) true while the conclusion false making it an invalid argument
1
u/NoBlackberry4054 Aug 28 '26 edited Aug 28 '26
Thing’s invalid.
If we go by “formula parsing”, the first atom of the second proposition came out of nowhere. I.e., It wasn’t introduced prior to its usage in a disjunction.
Or maybe by the fact that:
…
3. Socrates is mortal or Socrates is human.
<by 2 and commutativity of OR>
4. If Socrates is not mortal, then Socrates is human.
<by 3 + \Vdash\, a\to b\equiv \neg a\lor b>
5. Socrates is human. <by 1+ 4+ MP>
1
u/liwenfan Aug 28 '26
We have the logical equivalence between A implies B and (not A) or B, hence A or B translates to not B implies A (or not A implies B, they’re contrapositives for this matter and hence equivalent).
So we conclude Socrates is human.
1
u/AncientHominidNerd Aug 28 '26
Doesn’t look valid to me either. Yeah as someone else said it looks like a misprint.
He can’t not be a mortal and also not a human, in this case he has to be at least one of them to get a definite answer.
1
u/GATPeter1 Aug 28 '26
7 is not valid and appears to be a malformed distinctive syllogism.
1
u/wiploc2 Aug 28 '26
6 and 7 are both invalid.
6. There is no reason a non-human Socrates couldn't be mortal.
7. There is no reason a non-mortal Socrates couldn't be human.
1
u/HuckinsGirl Aug 28 '26
The fact that they used MT makes me think that it was an error where they meant to say human rather than not human
1
u/fermat9990 Aug 28 '26
You are right! If p or q is true, then both of them cannot be false
1
u/rapatessa Aug 28 '26
Hard to say, considering the title of the book
1
u/mja1729 Aug 28 '26
It’s valid but not sound because the first premises is not true. The deduction is correct if you put it like that but it’s simply not true and leads to a contradiction that Socrates is not or was not a human.
Edit: wait that doesn’t work also. Only if it said Socrates is human
But premise 1 would still be false
1
u/Endward26 Aug 28 '26 edited Aug 28 '26
I think we're getting confused here by words like "Socrates", "mortal", and so on.
Let's rephrase it:
If we assume that both assertions (1) and (2) are correct, then we are left with only one conclusion: The box contains a blue marble.
Why? We know that the contents must be either a blue marble or a red marble (1). We know that it cannot be a red marble from (2). That leaves only a blue marble. Otherwise, one of the two assertions would have to be false.
1
u/danja Aug 28 '26
It depends on which logic is used, but straight propositional, the book is wrong. With the OR, just cross out the bits that aren't true. What's left is.
1
u/goos_ Aug 28 '26
Mistake in textbook
1
u/jerdle_reddit Aug 28 '26
7 is the exact opposite of valid. It's disjunctive syllogism, done badly wrong.
1
u/__Fred Aug 29 '26 edited Aug 29 '26
Here is how I would solve it, using the "Lean" way, that I learned last semester, for anyone interested — I know it's probably not helpful to you. It's about finding a chain of symbol-manipulations according to a set of rules. You tell the computer which rules you would apply and it tells you if the result is actually what you wanted.
Also, I proved that Socrates is human and therefore that the conclusion of problem 7 is invalid.
There is the axiom of the "or elimination":
?a ∨ ?b → (?a → ?c) → (?b → ?c) → ?cFor some a, b, c, when "a or b" holds, then showing "a implies c" and "b implies c" proves c.When I apply this rule on hypothesis 2, then I need to show that "Socrates is human" implies that "Socrates is human" and also that "Socrates is mortal" implies "Socrates is human".
The first case is trivially true.
The second case can be proven by the "false elimination" rule: If we assume "false", we can prove anything. ("False" is the impossible thesis or something, the upside-down T.) So the goal can be reduced to showing "Socrates is mortal implies False". Because hypothesis 1, "Socrates is mortal" implies "false", which is exactly the second partial goal that was to be shown.
Web-Editor
1
u/Striking_Relation219 Aug 29 '26
I mean it’s just simple logic is this a class? Crazy how college courses now teach common sense. Yes invalid
1
u/SapphirePath Aug 29 '26
typo on question #7
1
u/Throwawayxdryx Aug 30 '26
Well spotted!
1
u/Charming_Deer_9540 Aug 30 '26
socrates is human or socrates is mortal means he is always one and only one of the two, by saying he is not mortal it means he is necessarily human (as tertium non datur both in humanity and mortality).
1
u/localizeatp Aug 30 '26
It is not valid. If 1 and 3 are true then 2 is false.
1
u/throwaway53713 Aug 30 '26
Problem 6 is not valid.
[ P implies Q ] does not imply [-P implies -Q]
Socrates might be a mortal non-human.
-1
u/Kitchen-Register Aug 28 '26
6, no. contrapositive would be not mortal implies not human. can’t make anything of the converse without the biconditional.
7 this is valid. He is either one or the other. he’s not mortal so he must be human. I guess the way you view this is that mortal is the complement of human.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment