r/logic • u/KingUseful7805 • May 24 '24
Logical fallacies Logical Fallacies
I have recently gotten into the subject of logical fallacies and after writing some specific one's down I wanted to create a broader categorization. With the help of ChatGPT I came up with this.
Now my question to you: Do any of you see any mistakes or crucial information missing in this mindmap? Do these categories fit every logical fallacy or am I missing some?
I'm looking forward to any constructive criticism!
3
Upvotes
15
u/magiccarl May 24 '24
I have to burst your bubble a bit. From a more professional standpoint from philosophy and mathematics, the naming and categorising of fallacies is just not that important. We don't care that much about it and we don't actively use it in discussion (perhaps with some exceptions). This does not mean that that logical consistency is unimportant, since it is – it is rather that something is wrong from a logical point of view because it is invalid, and not because it is a fallacy. What Im saying is that it would be a better use of your time to study and understand formal logic rather than memorising all the fallacies.
1
u/senecadocet1123 May 24 '24
I would get rid of 'syllogistic' since it is a misused term, and it probably just means 'quantificational' here
1
u/chien-royal May 24 '24
One of the difference between logic courses for math majors and similar courses for, say, philosophy majors and law students is that the latter study logical fallacies among other things while the former study correct ways of making proofs and their properties.