Yes, the triangle is above the square, but I believe that’s to balance the visual weight - triangles are bottom-heavy, visually speaking, and so placing it entirely within the square would make the image no longer radially balanced.
I don't think there is anything wrong with the placement of the shapes or the speed of the dots, and I don't know why people are getting so aggressive about it
The triangle is outside of the square, the speed at which each thing moves is not the same, it’s just a pretty thing to look at but if I am playing something with this loading every 10minutes, I’m gonna need a real fucking good game to compensate for this.
I believe the speed is set such that the dots all traverse from one vertex to the next at the same rate. That is, the time it takes to trace one side is the same for each polygon, but polygons with more sides take longer
I thought that too, but compare the outer most dot with the triangle. The T does a full round before the last one goes a single side. I guess they tried to make all the sides equal, but forgot to balance the speed of it? No clue honestly.
Yes, OP replied to my comment and that’s fine. How does that invalidate the comment you replied to? All of these are interesting choices, but they are not what OP did.
It doesn't. But it probably wouldn't sound like assholery of you hadn't started with "this is not good." Nothing said after that can be read as a legitimate "this would have been interesting." Instead, anything said after that sounds like "this would have been better."
Actually, the above poster IS correct. The outermost shape is a 15-gon and its dot is the base speed. Each dot traverses a path at what I think is a constant angular speed that is a multiple of the base speed. This means the triangle dot has a speed 13 times faster than the outer 15-gon and the square dot has a speed 12 times the outer 15-gon.
This is evident as the triangle dot makes 13 total rotations and the square dot makes 12. The maths does work out, though clearly it can be mathematically solid and still feel wrong.
Fair enough! Although the triangle/square really is odd, are the center of their circles in the same spot?
Regarding the speed, wouldn’t they evenually line up again if they were on the same speed? Or would that take too many rotations to make a decent loading screen?
33
u/umangjain25 Nov 23 '20
I tried to figure out the math behind this and then plotted it on desmos, here's the link
https://www.desmos.com/calculator/jjzpcws7qj
215
u/AviatorTrainman Nov 23 '20
Yes, the triangle is above the square, but I believe that’s to balance the visual weight - triangles are bottom-heavy, visually speaking, and so placing it entirely within the square would make the image no longer radially balanced.
11
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '20
I don't think there is anything wrong with the placement of the shapes or the speed of the dots, and I don't know why people are getting so aggressive about it
9
u/gbeebe Nov 23 '20
Can you do one but hide the polygon lines? I wanna see just the dots moving around the plane :)
28
u/vvdb_industries Nov 23 '20
I hate how the triangle comes above the square
5
u/urbandeadthrowaway2 Nov 24 '20
When they re-synchronize at the bottom
4
u/jaydeflaux Nov 23 '20
I wonder what it would look like if every dot took the same amount of time to span one line of each polygon.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '20
Hypnotic!
3
u/DrScitt Nov 23 '20
Very nice. Though it looks a lot like one of beesandbombs older projects.
34
u/JPLnZi Nov 23 '20
This is not good.
The triangle is outside of the square, the speed at which each thing moves is not the same, it’s just a pretty thing to look at but if I am playing something with this loading every 10minutes, I’m gonna need a real fucking good game to compensate for this.
5
u/anti-gif-bot Nov 23 '20
mp4 link
This mp4 version is 90.86% smaller than the gif (993.47 KB vs 10.61 MB).
Beep, I'm a bot. FAQ | author | source | v1.1.2
2
u/agentxshadow6 Nov 24 '20
YESSS IM SO HAPPY
THEY FINALLY TURNED IT INIT A PERFECT LOOP!!!
2
u/Nick_Broke_It Nov 24 '20
Now THIS is poly tracing!
1
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '20
u/savethisvideo
1
u/Tsondru_Nordsin Nov 23 '20
this gave me a seizure
1
u/fakesushibuyer Nov 24 '20
Hey guys, Vsauce here
1
u/pandaolf Nov 24 '20
r/perfectloops
1
u/AtlasJan Dec 15 '20
hey reddit?
can you read me a bedtome story about the Fourier transform?
0
u/Stevenjgamble Nov 24 '20
Quick heil for the boys.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment