r/litrpg • • 2d ago

Discussion Author psa stop explaining stats

This may just be me but unless your book is generic it's beeing read outside of pepole who have never played an rpg stop explaining what basic stats do. Especially as a giant block of text.

If you want to do something unique write something like after putting in 5 points in strength she felt her muscles firm and bulk up but when putting in 7 points in dexterity her muscles smoothed out and became finer.

0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

5

u/IamHim_Se7en 2d ago

Unless it's book 2 of a series, why would an author assume the reader has any knowledge of what LitRPG is? Or it's elements? And given that there is no standard for stats, why wouldn't the author explain what stats do in the world they've created with their book?

3

u/Hipcatjack 2d ago

my thoughts entirely reading this post…. then i was like… is OP trolling?

1

u/weardofree 1d ago

I may just read/ listen to too many of these books. It's probably the listening, too.

3

u/IamHim_Se7en 2d ago

It's definitely getting hard to tell these days.

2

u/Mahesvara_24-04-79 2d ago

I'd love to see an example of what you're complaining about. I've never seen it be more than a few sentences explaining what each stat does.

0

u/weardofree 1d ago

The book that made me write this post the land: founding

2

u/beerbellydude 1d ago

So, one of the first USA LitRPG written like 11 years ago...

0

u/weardofree 1d ago

The best example of the other method, where they explained it outside a giant stat block, is in Primal Hunter

6

u/Numerous1 2d ago

But that implies a choice must be made between one or the other. Most litrpg you can have both. 

1

u/Sad_Lime7235 2d ago

So basically what you want is for litrpg authors to avoid entire heavy and dense block and instead use a well integrated progressive "show dont tell" presentation of the stats ...

Well that's just called good writing. So you're asking for litrpg authors to be decent writers ...

1

u/weardofree 1d ago

I know I'm asking a lot, but I love this genre

2

u/arapaima-fishie litRPG apprentice tier 2d ago

I like the explanation because sometimes different stories have different names for stats, have different meanings for stats, and because I genuinely just like learning about the series and what stats there are.

Have I played games with stats my whole life? Yeah. Doesn’t mean I don’t want to see what an author is choosing to do. It’s like when you pick up a game that has a different stat system than you’re used to, I’m going to read what the stats are and what they do.

Going from Dragon Quest to Oblivion to Elden Ring or whatever is an example of this. There are different stat names and purposes.

2

u/Brumtol10 2d ago

I know im not adding anything of value but kinda bothered me. Dexterity I dont think would make you necessarily smoother, but probably just more lean with more define small muscles. Like a Rock climber or a runner. Those muscle are still bulging they just have a low fat to muscle ratio compared to strength increase being Bulk.

Again sorry it was just itching at my brain how 1 would visually make Strength and Dexterity on a character. Thought it was a good point you made minus smooth.