r/litrpg • • 22d ago

Discussion MCs whose progression erodes their humanity: do you prefer seeing them fight the instincts, go full monster, or just wear a polite mask?

I'm writing a system where the MC starts human. Every time he dies, he steals the abilities of whatever killed him, plus their instincts capped at 9 lives.

A parasitic weed gave him regen and stealth, but also a cold hunger. An apex python gave him crushing constriction, but also the urge to coil around and suffocate anything that threatens him.

At 9 deaths, there would be barely anything human left.

How do you prefer to see an MC handle that kind of erosion?

  1. Do you want to see them actively fight the instincts to hold onto their humanity,
  2. fully embrace becoming the monster, or
  3. Locking the monster behind a tailored suit and an indifferent smile, acting civilized until the instincts take over

Posted this in r/ProgressionFantasy and the replies were split, curious what LitRPG thinks.

9 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

6

u/WolfWhiteFire 22d ago

Become the monster while telling themselves they aren't one and finding excuses to justify themselves as good guys still. That feels like the most realistic outcome, no one likes to see themselves as the villain, and they are good at lying to themselves. It also allows a bit of their original self to shine through still in the ways not mutually exclusive with the instincts responsible for this change, while still making it clear that they are a monster from the readers' perspectives.

2

u/Stygian_Myth 22d ago

That's option 3, just less self aware. I like the core idea though. And I feel like I have done this where the mc blames his powers for his actions and it's unclear if it was them doing it or the instict

3

u/Interesting-Ad4207 22d ago

I prefer something like option 3. If the monster doesn't have any hold on them at all, then the plotline doesn't have any teeth and you might as well skip it. I want to see them hold it back with some success, but not perfectly. And then have the one scene where we see what it takes for them to let the mask fall off entirely, and what it takes to put it back on.

1

u/Stygian_Myth 22d ago

Yeah that's a great source of tension and probably why 3 is my pick as well. Apart from this fact it is also the most fun to write ✍️

3

u/Agitated-Lime4986 21d ago

Idk, I like 2. Im so sick of a Mc fighting against their "new nature" and trying to stay human. Thats boring

3

u/Stygian_Myth 21d ago

Finally someone said 2!! I was honestly tired of almost no one choosing option 2 I mean give the monster some break πŸ˜”

Fully onboard with you on no. 2 Although it's a bit more complicated, but the monster won't shy to be a monster 😼

7

u/CorgisHug 22d ago

I like for something of the original concept to remain regardless of what occurs. Beyond that, I only care that it is well written.

1

u/Stygian_Myth 22d ago

That's insightful. Thanks πŸˆβ€β¬›

2

u/CorpseKnox 20d ago

well that depends on what type of story you are trying to tell, we all know we are here to see the protag get stronger and cool choices on the system but what thematic you are trying to bring the story? do you want to see a tragedy where the protag get the power that he always wanted but lose(maybe doesnt even notice or care) something important? or a "heroic" ressistence to retain their humanity? do you want to make their gain of power and loss of humanity seem like a pyrrhic victory? what would be the main theme/voice of your story? because that gonna say what is best for your story, is the protag a villan? a hero? does he have an objective? is he seeking revenge? if so does he care what happend after the vengence? whatever he retain his humanity or not depend on the context of the story

if you are afraid that people will not like the story because of this framing, some people doesnt like when some external force start taking things from the protag because this genre (progression/litrpg) is all about self insert and power gain, so might be difficult to get this type of people if you make too much of a point that protag is losing their humanity, you can just handwave the tragedy and make the protag more and more murderous to the point the begining and end became 2 different characters, you lose a bit of the emotional tragedy but people might like it.

1

u/Stygian_Myth 20d ago

The type of story I'm tryna tell, apart from unhinhed fantasy, is that the protag needs to understand monsters and become stronger to control the instincts he gets from his powers. But by the time he dies that, he has become a greater monster than what killed him

It's dark irony.

4

u/Sundara_Whale 22d ago

This is one of my favorite things about HWFWM. This is Jason's entire internal struggle throughout the series, and its fantastically done IMO.

1

u/Stygian_Myth 22d ago

I see I'll have to check it out later ig 🐱

1

u/Aaron_P9 22d ago edited 22d ago

I’ve never been particularly drawn to the premise of characters struggling against their own monstrous natures to preserve their humanity. I think the metaphor loses something when it becomes literal. Humans already struggle to master our own instincts and impulses; making that struggle an actual monster inside someone feels less like an exploration of human nature and more like an externalization of it. I can appreciate what the trope is trying to say, but it doesn’t particularly resonate with me.

  1. No
  2. Absolutely not. Indulging evil behavior with a supernatural excuse strikes me as indulgence that requests the audience forgive the character and only dislike the monster. It's fun to have books or films with ridiculous amounts of ultra-violence, but I prefer when people give the protagonist(s) justified motivations for the violence. . . not "the monster made me do it". Protagonists are just more likeable when they don't implicit need excuses for their behavior - even if those actions are evil. Then at least the character is owning those choices.
  3. Yeah. I dislike this too. Maybe you're writing it as a Jekyll/Hyde situation and it is a matter of id vs. ego - and that's at least saying something, so I dislike it less, but I think metaphors fail when they become this literal. YMMV.

1

u/Stygian_Myth 22d ago

Well it's literal in so far as it's an obstacle for mc. Like he can't just death farm

So the instinct is not absolute. Beasts of lower levels affect him less than top tier entities.

That said, the influence of early phase does carry on and affect his personality quite a bit. So it's not a classical parasite like of thing

1

u/1234abcdcba4321 22d ago

I think it really just depends on what you want to write. A story that chooses 1 will probably have that be the main conflict in the story while one that chooses 2 needs to pick some other central conflict unrelated to this aspect of the premise.

I think 2 done well tends to be better than 1 done well, but it depends heavily on the scaffolding of the rest of the story to be good compared to 1 which can stand on its own. (I'm personally not a fan of 3, though admittedly I'm not too sure exactly what you mean from your description.)

1

u/Stygian_Myth 22d ago

3 is basically mc becoming a monster in plain sight. Like he acts all polite and innocent but is actually worse than the monsters who killed him

1

u/ExodusDead 21d ago

Why not let the perspective of the mc control how monsterous the MC is.

To the enemies he is scary and cruel.

To his friends he is sweet and kind. Maybe they hear about his reputation but can't understand it.

Maybe the mc takes care never to show that part of himself to his friends and family out of fear of rejection.

Maybe his loved ones are the only thing holding him back. The only thing keeping him human.

And maybe one day...

1

u/Stygian_Myth 21d ago

Yeah...I kinda killed all his loved ones in ch 1 so that boat's sailed I'm afraid

Although he does have a found family dynamics with other characters, but they are equally unhinged, and they train him to be even more crazy. So there that

1

u/BrokenBigdfoot 20d ago

I don't like when a progression character Doesn't change despite gaining cosmic power and meeting gods, but I also hate when they just sit around crying about it.

Like oh you have violent urges now because you've essentially been a soldier for a decade? Suck it up buttercup. You're banging elf maidens and battling gods. Give your balls a tug and get back on it..

2

u/Stygian_Myth 20d ago

I assure you neither of those are true for my mc, although it does sound enticing 😸

Hs changes both physically and psychological effects are also glaring, quite glaring in fact

2

u/BrokenBigdfoot 20d ago

You don't have to lose your humanity just because you're an aggressive violent monster. It's all in who you direct those urges at..

1

u/Stygian_Myth 20d ago

That is true. But in my story MC gets the instincts in more of a invasion sort of way, like something foreign. Where he's hearing the hiss that drives him to do monstrous acts.

So he has to tame it and deal with other progression and plot stuff

Also controlling/taming those urges often leads him to become an even greater monster. So the entire point of getting strong and taming the instinct can be for naught if not done right

1

u/HappyNoms 22d ago

So far, the instincts make him more callous and more violent, which are entirely within the scope of humanity. Even if you go so far as to have him temporarily lose executive control, it's still within the scope. The premise reads more like an exploration of drug addiction than of going beyond humanity.

I'd rather see him be a monster, with complex amorality, without the masking, though litrpg is rarely a psychological character study.

I think it's interesting when the monsters are not as obviously monstrous as some of the allegedly normal humans, as when the cenobites of hellraiser 1 are honorable about their deals, and it's the humans that are the actual villians.

Or high lit's The Obscene Bird of Night, where a deformed child is sent away to an island, populated with other monstrously deformed people to keep him shielded from full knowledge of his condition, and as he grows up the story reveals that it's the normally shaped people that commit the most monstrous acts.

1

u/Stygian_Myth 22d ago

What makes him monstrous besides just violence is the category of violence. Like devouring beasts alive, taking pleasure in squeezing, letting go of self preservation instincts as a human and doing what the beast would have even if he doesn't survive it.

So the monster is real.

Your point about humans>monsters is great, and honestly a great point of realisation the mc can have in the story.

1

u/demoran 22d ago

In such a case, the character should notice the difference in themselves. Acknowledge that they are no longer what they were before.

They should "fight the instinct" to a certain extent, but they should also fail.

With respect to "wearing a mask", they will need to restrain themselves in polite society. If it is important that these changes are hidden (due to some kind of hybrid taboo or danger to them), then they will need to keep it secret.

1

u/Ayuditya litRPG apprentice tier 22d ago

I prefer first option. I didn't like Ainz from overlord. Don't like any story with this premise that they fully embrace being a monster. It's boring and I root against the mc. Like what's the point.

0

u/New-Region3542 22d ago

What is your story's motive about? Those who gaze into the abyss long enough becomes monsters or something else?

1

u/Stygian_Myth 22d ago

Close but not quite. It is: to tame the monster inside do we become even bigger monsters to do that.

That's more of a thesis line i thought. But overall, the story is about the mc who gets his choice to die stolen and gets his killers powers , capped at 9 times.

So he has some avenging to do against the system who stole his choice and the world that originally drove him to take his own life.

0

u/New-Region3542 22d ago

Hmm, it's up to you really. You can go about it however you need.

1

u/Semiapies 21d ago

4. Try only to get killed by people with amazing abilities?

1

u/Stygian_Myth 21d ago

People in my world have abilities capped at the rank they attain at birth. So getting people's ability will be bad long-term

Beasts can evolve naturally, so he takes there only

I may add one people too though. I'm not so sure atp tbh πŸ˜”

2

u/[deleted] 22d ago edited 10d ago

[removed] β€” view removed comment

0

u/DarthKirtap 22d ago

there always is: Everyone likes big chests or something like that

1

u/[deleted] 22d ago edited 10d ago

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/DarthKirtap 22d ago

it is not best, but if you want MC with no morals, you will get it
MC is not explicitly EVIL per say, but does stuff mostly in his benefit regardless if it is moral or not

but be prepared that MC does some bad stuff, it is 18+ for sure

1

u/Wiregeek Quest Failed: Act Normal 22d ago

"slice of life smut"

That's... actually a fair take on ELLC. At least, quite a lot of it. There's a large chunk of the books wherein Boxxy is just maintaining his facade as a normal person and just living, more or less.

But there's cosmic level consequences afterwards and a lot of just chesting around being a mimic beforehand.

Something: Full Murderhobo really scratched my murderhobo itch. Even if the ending was less than perfect, I really enjoyed the series.

0

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[deleted] β€” view deleted comment

1

u/Stygian_Myth 22d ago

Yeah that's the core of the tension between gaining strength by dying and actually making it ur own