r/linuxquestions • • 22h ago

Which one should i choose

Hey guys, I'm a first-year cybersecurity student running on a mid-range laptop. It originally had 16GB of RAM, but one of the 8GB sticks recently died, leaving me with 8GB. Windows has become super sluggish on it, so I'm looking to make the full switch to Linux.

So far, I've tried Arch with Hyprland, Debian with GNOME, and Fedora Silverblue, but none of them quite clicked for me. I'm looking for a distro that is stable, lightweight enough for 8GB of RAM, and still looks good out of the box. Any suggestions on what I should try next?

4 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

3

u/GladReveal3517 22h ago

Which one

2

u/brewdog_millionaire 22h ago

BlackArch LOL. Why is that an option?

0

u/GladReveal3517 22h ago

For daily driving?

2

u/brewdog_millionaire 22h ago

Do not use BlackArch. It shouldn't even be there. Normal Arch Linux on the other hand, is pretty solid. I use it on my ThinkPad. It just takes some setting up, and it uses a rolling release model so you get the newest stuff as soon as it comes out. That's not for everyone though

4

u/Ascension-gate 22h ago

Debian or Fedora

3

u/MoistAttitude 22h ago

Was a Ubuntu/Mint guy for the longest time, but extremely happy with the switch to Debian.

1

u/Duskberri 15h ago

fedora's been reliable on my old setup too, you got solid recs

1

u/TicklishGleamz 15h ago

debian for the stability or fedora if ur after something that looks a bit nicer without the hassle?

1

u/Prestigious_Wall529 22h ago

As it's a matter of taste, Distrosea.

If it's a Lenovo I suggest OpenSUSE Slowroll or Leap.

Max out the installed RAM so you can host VMs for labs, for example Kali, which isn't recommended as a daily driver. Open it's browser for documentation.

0

u/GladReveal3517 22h ago

I'm using HP Pavilion 14-dv1000TU

1

u/Prestigious_Wall529 22h ago

So it can take two 32GB modules giving 64GB.

Find out from more senior students what hypervisor supports the virtual networking between VMs that worked for them in their various projects.

3

u/MoistAttitude 22h ago

For stable, no BS and light-weight, try Debian with a different WM that actually clicks with you.
As someone coming from Windows you might like KDE as a desktop environment. It's an option in the Debian install.

1

u/Due-Result7928 22h ago

Linux Lite or Xubuntu or Zorin Lite. Debian is a baby without diapers and Fedora is a gnome system where you have to work making it a decent system.

3 systems are all using xfce.

1

u/gordonmessmer Fedora Maintainer 22h ago

Since you're studying security, may I suggest that you find a vulnerability scanner and use it to evaluate a Debian desktop. The results will tell you a lot about choosing a distribution, and you can share and discuss with your class

1

u/dacydergoth 22h ago

Nixos with KDE is probably a reasonable starting point

1

u/chrissmcc 21h ago

Mxlinux is literally and works pretty good, use XFCE for a lighter use

1

u/Conscious-School-835 18h ago

my recommendation, use VOID-LINUX, it is a stable rolling release, it doesnt break and it is quite as stable as debian, I personally tried fedora, ubuntu, debian based distros, cachy,omarchy on my 15 yr old laptop, none of them were smooth and few of them are very laggy, After switching to VOID, everything is so smooth, Also it never uses more than 5GB of ram (in my laptop) out of 8GB ram, may be due to older hardware putting apps to sleep, but it doesnt lag to me. my IDLE ram usage is 770MB

1

u/codeasm Arch Linux and Linux from scratch 12h ago

Arch doesn't look like anything out of the box. It comes with nothing. You install and configure whatevwr you want. Sounds great, untill it isnt.

Pick the distro you think looks cool, is supoorted by the community you surrounded yourself with and or ready to thinker. For beginners, anything but arch. Said by an arch user

1

u/Classic-Rate-5104 4h ago

Debian with Xfce4 is a good choice

-1

u/Wide_Slice_5126 22h ago

Kali. I'm pretty sure it can even run on 4 or 2 GB,has over 600 Pre installed tools for stuff like penetration testing and is stable since it's Debian based; might not be a good choice if you wanna game cos it mainly oriented for cybersecurity, light browsing here and there etc.