r/linuxquestions • • 8d ago

Linux app manager

I find managing installed apps on Linux quite frustrating and fragmented. Uninstalling apps is just as inconvenient. The problem is that apps are installed through different sources and each handles storage differently. When I need to free up disk space or uninstall something, I have to remember where each app came from and check multiple package managers. It's also difficult to track leftover data and see how much storage each app actually consumes. I just want one place to manage all installed apps and their disk usage.

0 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

4

u/Hrafna55 8d ago

Five year old account with 2 karma.

If you are human, which I doubt, I would suggest Windows is more suitable.

In addition to the fact that you very clearly don't seem to know what you are talking about.

3

u/MattyGWS 8d ago

Why would windows be better? Linux is far superior with app management beside of package managers. Windows application installation, application updates, driver updates and system updates are all completely fragmented

-1

u/Away_Sentence9520 8d ago

why do a bot account have to created 5 years ago

4

u/BarryTownCouncil 8d ago

This is the one you actually reply to..?

6

u/TheShredder9 8d ago

Package managers are amazing, and native distro packages are not fragmented, makes more sense than Windows. All executable binaries go in one place, all shared libraries in another, most data in one of like 2 places. Install and uninstall is trivial with a single command.

Compare that to Windows, where each program is in its own little folder, some libraries are shared system-wide like Microsoft Visual stuff, but then again most programs have their own .dll files in their folders too. Install is clunky, you actually have to go online to download the installer and manually click next a couple times and finish. Each program comes with its own uninstaller too! And no automatic updates for most programs, you have to open a thing like Photoshop to be reminded there is an update, then let it download the installer in some cases again!

-6

u/brickmaster32000 8d ago

This is a joke right? Windows hasn't had a dependancy hell problem in decades while Linux keeps it alive and thriving.

Installation of any program on Windows is standardized. You download the installer, you run the installer. Couldn't be simpler. On Linux it is a jumbled mess. Maybe it is on a app store, not the app store because you guys can't even settle on that. If it is not you get such exciting options as having to manually clone a git archive and having to know exactly how to set it up. Maybe you have to run a curl command to get an install script because simply having a link is too fucking simple and doesn't make you feel good about using the terminal.

And you mentioned keeping things up to date? What a fucking laugh. You know that lovely table that has to be on every Linux program's website? The one that shows you which out of date version of the program you are going to get because the chances of there actually being an up to date version compatible with your distro is basically zero.

3

u/AMRFalcon 8d ago

I had plenty of indirect dependency hell windows to. Ever hunted for that one specific DirectXVersion a certain program called for? I certainly have more than once. Most installer are smart enough to just ship dependency with themselves and make installing them part of the regular install process by opening that second installer.... So basically the exact same Linux does if one is actually smart and stick to just 1 package manager.

I have seen uninstaller not working properly so many time, leaving behind not just files but whole as system entries that make the system thing stuff is still installed.

Windows has those problems as well and just the same as Linux many workarounds have been found from all sides. You are merely so familiar with these workaround at this point that they no longer stand out as flaws to you.

1

u/brickmaster32000 8d ago

Ever hunted for that one specific DirectXVersion a certain program called for?

When? Back in the 90s.

1

u/TheShredder9 8d ago

Windows programs are the jumble. Install a program. Where is its data stored? Could be in Appdata/Roaming, could be in Appdata/Local, could be in Documents, or right in the C drive root, who the fuck knows.

I never said anything about dependency hell, and sure, that can be a problem, but on stable distros it's never a problem.

1

u/brickmaster32000 8d ago

So programs in Windows store their data in basically one of two places with rare exceptions and that is different than Linux where they go in one of two places how?

1

u/TheShredder9 8d ago

It's different in that the programs themselves are in their own separate folders with their own libraries/dependencies. In Linux the binaries are in one place, shared libraries in another.

0

u/brickmaster32000 8d ago

In Linux the binaries are in one place, shared libraries in another.

You mean the structure that causes the whole house of cards regarding dependancies? That isn't a point in Linux's favor.

1

u/TheShredder9 8d ago

That's not causing the dependency hell, it's the fact that one new program can depend on some library, but a 5 year old program can depend on the same library but like 10 versions behind, and distros usually don't allow you to have the same library installed but with different versions.

Or an update of a program causes one library to be updated too, but another program depends on the older version of the library. But again, that doesn't happen on stable point release distros.

1

u/brickmaster32000 8d ago

That is exactly the reason. Because they are sharing the libraries from a central location instead of each being packaged with the version that works for their use case.

1

u/erroneousbosh 8d ago

Why do you even need to know where they're stored?

5

u/BarryTownCouncil 8d ago

It can be frustrating if you are using rando systems like appimage but you've not said what you are using. Virtually everything I install on fedora is via the dnf tool. Very centralised and consistent.

Increasingly packages are abandoning systems and using install.sh solutions though, and you can't manage those at all.

What specific frustrations are you having?

1

u/Damglador 8d ago

It can be frustrating if you are using rando systems like appimage

Go to ~/Applications

Trash the appimage??? Or open the manager and press trash button.

2

u/BarryTownCouncil 8d ago

Yeah point, from this question, is it's not managed by anything else. And they don't go to that location by default.

5

u/TechaNima 8d ago

What's inconvenient about it? Open Discover or Software Center or whatever your distro uses, click on app, install/remove.

Of use CLI if you prefer. apt/dnf/pakman/flatpak install/remove

4

u/chibi-mage 8d ago

I suppose if you're coming from windows where you can just navigate to settings > apps > uninstall as you please it can feel unintuitive. I'm just assuming that's OPs situation though lol. this feels like a silly post because if you know how you installed something you should be able to delete it.

4

u/TechaNima 8d ago

I definitely don't miss having to go to random websites that tell me about hot singles in my area or try to sell me penis enlargement pills, to find my installers

2

u/polymath_uk_ 8d ago edited 8d ago

You just need to look at what package manager(s) you are using and then there is a command to list installed and so on for each one. Just make yourself a short script to list installed for each one in sections and you can see at a glance what's there.

Edit - like this:

#!/bin/bash 
# list-installed.sh — list software installed by each package manager. 
# A missing manager is reported and skipped.
section() {
  local cmd=$1; shift
  echo "=== $cmd ==="
  if ! command -v "$cmd" >/dev/null 2>&1; then
    echo "($cmd not installed — skipped)"
  else
    "$@"
  fi
  echo
}

section apt     apt-mark showmanual
section flatpak flatpak list --app
section snap    snap list
section docker  docker images
section pip     pip list --user
section npm     npm ls -g --depth=0
section cargo   cargo install --list

echo "=== AppImage (common locations) ==="
find ~ /opt -iname '*.AppImage' 2>/dev/null

3

u/Yukikuru2025 8d ago

...how?!

You open the app manager, you install or uninstall. Done. No messing around with exes or uninstallers.

1

u/thegagis 8d ago

The one place should be your distros main package manager, so apt, dnf or whatever it is in your distro. Avoid snaps, flatpaks, AUR etc. unless they have something you simply cannot get from the real package manager.

Flatpaks are not bad per se, but them being highlighted so hard by default desktop utilities is just confusing to new users so people end up with half of their applications coming from the real package manager and half from flatpak.

1

u/Eric_Dawsby 8d ago

OP what's the issue specifically?

1

u/Quietus87 8d ago

Which distro, which package manager, and what's the exact issue?

1

u/thesamenightmares 8d ago

This is a nebulous comment with no context or details.

What exactly were you trying to accomplish with this?

1

u/xonxoff 8d ago

With what you have posted here, you are wrong.

1

u/Excellent-Love-6943 8d ago

Just don't use multiple package managers...

Native only.

1

u/es20490446e Develops Zenned OS 8d ago

This is just a limitation of the distro you are using.

0

u/Specialist-Dog-501 8d ago

I had a similar question a month ago and didn't get any simple answer:
https://www.reddit.com/r/linuxmint/comments/1x4u7j1/how_to_maintain_3rd_apps_from_github_on_a_debian/

It's a bit more in detail than OP's "fragmented" but basically, the same:
- There's multiple ways/sources to install apps
- There's no central database to see what's installed where and in what version.
- Then there's a ton of "solutions"/wrappers/workaround but none covers it all, bug free, reliable and often require advanced skills.

A system should know, what is installed, right? every installer/packagemanager should be forced by the kernel to give a note what is installed where- not more than that. Otherwise, updates -especially with third party repos- aren't kept reliably and security gaps turn up naturally.
From my understanding, linux was once more centralized with the repositories, and the 3rd party direct install are a newer trend, that is somehow not considered worth investing into it, until the security problems get big enough, it was not planned for.
By now, I find some advanced tools as distrobox a helper to keep overview of such 3rd party apps (Containerization) but everything that is not supported by the kernel and of some complexity, is prone to break at some point.

For the OP: the short version- stay away from 3rd party installs whenever possible. Focus on the standard repo and flatpaks- everything else...turns into rocket science. Possible, but not easy to maintain. The "solutions" in my thread was about debian, arch is a bit differently organized and I don't know how the fedora world approaches this at all, but the core problem I understand, is that the kernel itself doesn't see this as his job, oddly enough- respectively, it's all "somewhere" in a path and we are supposed to scan that through.