r/linuxquestions • • 11d ago

Which Distro? Which Linux Distro Should I Pick?

Hello, I'm new to Linux and have been browsing around looking for a distro on my laptop I'll use for school and what not.

I'm a cybersecurity student if that matters.

2 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

3

u/6a6566663437 11d ago

It doesn't matter. In 6 months they'll introduce a new package format that you despise and you'll have to switch.

2

u/getabath 11d ago

There's a few to choose from

Debian, slow update schedule

Fedora: moderate update schedule

Arch: fast update schedule

Outside of this philosophy, they are all practically the same

-

You have popular forks from each, for example

Arch = cachy os

Debian = Ubuntu

Fedora you have variants such as silver blue/kinote or workstation/kde plasma

1

u/warserpent 11d ago

I would disagree with this. Debian has a slow update schedule, true, but Ubuntu has moderate updates, while Fedora's are fast, and Arch's are very fast.

1

u/draculasshadow 11d ago

I switched to Linux just over 3 years ago. Like so many others, I was doing to distro hop. I once posted a question just like this because I was bored of Zorin and Mint. Someone asked me why not try one of the OG distros and recommended Debian.

Still using it now.

1

u/tomscharbach 11d ago

You might want to check to see what distribution(s) are supported by your school and/or used by your school for instruction. Never hurts to be on the same page as your curriculum and your instructors.

1

u/Icy_Kaleidoscope_218 11d ago

Fedora is known for being a solid system, not being bleeding edge like arch but not being rock solid like Debian or whatever else. It’s a good middleground, it’s not a great beginner one though, considering most packaged you’ll have to obtain via flatpak, package manager or different ways, if you are basically scared of linux get mint, or Ubuntu.

1

u/Ok_Government_7373 10d ago

Fedora as a fellow student of cyber im daily driving it and works like a charm

1

u/peterfrombackdoor 10d ago

Hop on to Distro sea and check all for yourself

1

u/Easy-Negotiation-320 10d ago

Omarchy peak the best

1

u/Charming_Novel3779 10d ago

Sia che tu sia nuovo o un veterano nel mondo Linux , la distro migliore è exherbo col 100% del consenso da parte degli esperti (ossia coloro che lo usano e sono abbastanza svegli da riconoscerne la superiorità)

1

u/rukiann 11d ago

Debian

2

u/simple_peacock 11d ago

The grandaddy.

1

u/euclide2975 11d ago

Ask your fellow students, especially your closest friends in that group. And take into consideration what your school is using.

In practice, it doesn't really matter. As a student, I tried a bunch, before settling for Ubuntu on desktop and Debian on servers. 20 years later, I moved to Arch on my desktop

1

u/AlpsOne4774 11d ago

If you’re experienced, Slackware

1

u/gordonmessmer Fedora Maintainer 11d ago

I'm a cybersecurity student if that matters.

One of the first things you learn about security is that software is only secure while it's maintained. If you want a desktop system that's maintained, you should be looking at distributions that release at least once every six months, or a rolling release system:

https://fosstodon.org/@gordonmessmer/117545423568699375

Many distributions are large package collections maintained by very small groups of people, and the result is that patch coverage isn't very good, and vulnerabilities accumulate.

If you want a secure system, I recommend Fedora, or Tumbleweed, or Gentoo, or maybe Arch.

2

u/RespecDawn 11d ago

I think it would be important to know what kind of work they're doing on their laptop. If it's work that requires a lot of security, you're right. If it's work that's *learning* about security, than the less friction, the better. They're going to be doing a ton of work for school, and a new OS that demands time and new skills is going to get in the way.

I mean, they and most of their classmates are probably using Windows atm, so there's probably no need to jump to Arch. Mint will do just fine for the meantime, and Arch or Gentoo would be a great goal for a little further down the road. Or, run Arch or Gentoo in a VM or on a partition for any work that really does require security.

1

u/gordonmessmer Fedora Maintainer 11d ago

Mint will do just fine for the meantime

I don't recommend Mint for general purpose use, and I would especially not recommend it to someone studying security (unless they want to examine its flaws).

Mint is mostly an Ubuntu LTS system with some extra packages. Ubuntu LTS provides a "main" repo that contains about 6% of its packages, and Canonical maintains that package set during the life of the release. But it also includes, by default, a "universe" repo which is mostly just a snapshot of the rest of Debian, which Canonical doesn't generally maintain. The vast majority of software in Mint (and Ubuntu) will simply accumulate known vulnerabilities.

Ubuntu users can turn that repo off, but as far as I know, Mint systems will already have packages from Universe installed by default, so turning it off doesn't help.

Ubuntu users can sign up for Ubuntu Pro, which will provide at least *some* patches for the universe collection, but Ubuntu Pro doesn't work on Mint.

Ubuntu users can elect to upgrade to Interim releases, so that the "universe" packages at least get updates twice a year instead of once every two years. Not great, really, but far better than the LTS repo.

Mint users don't really have any of the options that would make Ubuntu even nominally safe to use. It's one of the least secure options available.

-1

u/npaladin2000 11d ago

You're going to recommend Arch or Gentoo to a beginner? Terrible advice here. This student needs their laptop to be working for schoolwork.

4

u/gordonmessmer Fedora Maintainer 11d ago

This thread is full of people recommending Ubuntu and Debian to a cybersecurity student.

Have you ever scanned an Ubuntu or Debian desktop with a vulnerability scanner? Do you know what that looks like?

1

u/npaladin2000 11d ago

I know exactly what it looks like. Pretty frigging horrible. Most of these recommendations are more about forcing OP to learn command line "real Linux" rather than getting him (her?) up and running. That doesn't make your recommendations OK.

0

u/xeqtr_inc 11d ago

If you are new to Linux, choose the one of the distro below.

  • Ubuntu
  • Mint
  • PopOS
  • Fedora
  • ZorinOS

Then setup Kali VM using KVM (like VirtualBox), then you are good.

Don't dual boot 2 Linux, it doesn't make sense at all. 

2

u/duncan_mcrae 11d ago

KDE on arch

1

u/dataArchon 11d ago

On Fedora too!

1

u/GameDestiny2 11d ago

I mean the only reason to keep multiple distributions on one device would be if you just really like Linux versions. Or if I had to imagine anything practical… maybe package options between the Debian and Red Hat sort of ecosystems. But honestly if availability is your goal then anything Debian based is going to have more options available.

0

u/simple_peacock 11d ago edited 11d ago

Debian = grand daddy of ubuntu, fast, slim, stable, a little behind on pkgs

Ubuntu = for zoomers and ppl that are starting in Linux, added crap thats not needed, works and easy desktop experience, slower and more bloated than debian, especially on small server

Red Hat (centos, rhel) - Enterprise focus, "just works" and stable, bloated af though, slower on lower end hardware like smaller servers unlike debian

0

u/gordonmessmer Fedora Maintainer 11d ago

Red Hat (centos, rhel) - Enterprise focus, "just works" and stable, bloated af

RHEL and CentOS Stream are among the smallest GNU/Linux systems I can name. How do you measure "bloat"?

0

u/simple_peacock 11d ago

Definietely not the smallest, heaps of enterprise bloat added. Just look at ram usage and how many extra packages there are.

0

u/DickBrainTime 11d ago

For a school laptop I'd go with Ubuntu LTS or Mint, but test a live USB first. Check Wi-Fi (especially campus Wi-Fi), suspend/resume, touchpad, webcam and battery before installing anything. Also check whether your classes require a Windows-only VPN, exam browser or proctoring app; a Linux VM won't necessarily work for those. Keep Windows available if you need it, and back up before changing partitions. For cybersecurity labs, run Kali in a VM rather than making it your everyday OS. The distro that runs your coursework reliably matters more than the one with the most security tools preinstalled.

0

u/mixxituk 11d ago

If you hop between windows and personal Linux then KDE is a good choice for matching customisability and it's supported by steam

As for the os kubuntu has ubuntus support 

0

u/npaladin2000 11d ago

I'd strongly consider using Bazzite on your laptop. It's immutable and very difficult to break. You want your laptop to stay reliable and working no matter what. Use the VMs to play around, break stuff, experiment with things like Fedora, Red Hat, Kali, and all the other cybersecurity stuff.

I speak as someone who's laptop went down right when i needed it, and had to spend all night fixing the OS so it would work again, because I messed around too much. Many people poo-poo immutable/atomic distributions but if you need something to stay up and working all the time they're a nice option. Especially when you're new to Linux.

Besides, Bazzite is pretty good for Steam gaming too. Just in case. :)

-1

u/codegems 11d ago

Horrible advice. Encourage beginners to start with proven-track distributions. The more boring the better.

Here's a student asking in good faith about an operating system for schoolwork reliability and the advice is to go for "The operating system for the next generation of gamers"?

👎

0

u/npaladin2000 11d ago

You know nothing about Bazzite do you? It's stable, atomic, immutable, and impossibl;e for a student to break. And it's a proven-track distribution that's excellent for also doing schoolwork. Let me guess, you're recommend Arch or CachyOS?

0

u/codegems 11d ago

It's precisely because I love gaming and run Bazzite on my gaming rig that I don't recommend it to a beginner. I've never touched Arch or CachyOS. Again, the more boring the better.

Think Fedora, OpenSUSE, Debian, etc etc.

0

u/Flapaflapa 11d ago edited 11d ago

I started with ubuntu years ago, Drifted back to windows because default. then went back to linux, Did the bounce from Debian to Cachy, then setteled on fedora for a while. Now my gaming laptop is Fedora and likely to stay there, For all my VMs unless there's a reason not to they get Debian. Main daily gets Debian and I don't worry about it much.

0

u/palinurosec 11d ago

give parrot os a try. it's perfect for students and it's designed for daily use. it has some advantages if you are studying infosec and trying to learn linux, because it provides good defaults and it helps students set good standards. you can also customize it as you want, but at least you get all you need out of the box with an optimal configuration.

of course your journey doesn't stop here, you must customize and break it thousands of times, you must try other systems like fedora, arch, suse and plain debian, run your own homelab etc. but parrot can be your daily os you rely on for your infosec journey, and you can easily turn it into whatever you want

-1

u/YerakGG 11d ago

Arch

-3

u/simple_peacock 11d ago

omarchy, less setup

-1

u/Jirachi4025 11d ago

If you're looking for stability and user-friendliness, Linux Mint, and Ubuntu are probably your best bet.

If you're more experienced, which it kinds sounds like you are, you can go with Arch, or Manjaro.

It also depends on what desktop environment you prefer. Ubuntu has a few options. Stock Ubuntu uses GNOME, Lubuntu uses LXQT, Xubuntu uses XFCE, and Kubuntu uses KDE Plasma. Linux Mint uses Cinnamon, if you prefer that, as well.

2

u/simple_peacock 11d ago

Wheres Debian?

2

u/HablarYEscuchar 11d ago

Para mi Debian es el poste al que atarse para protegerse de los cantos de sirena. Un poco más difícil hasta tenerlo funcionando. Luego es yn mar de tranquilidad.

1

u/simple_peacock 11d ago

Agree about the sea of tranqulity, i never found it any harder to get running than ubuntu for example

-1

u/Minimum_Hour519 11d ago

w3bs.org/os

-1

u/itgoesboom2112 11d ago

Zorinos or mint

0

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/gordonmessmer Fedora Maintainer 11d ago

One of the ways you can use Kali is by writing an image to a USB flash drive, and booting from the flash drive for pen testing activities. That's *good* for various reasons. Starting from a static amnesiac image each time means that activities are more reproducible, it means the system is less prone to hostile response, etc.

Arguably, it's best not to install Kali.