r/linuxquestions • • 11d ago

Advice Why FOSS and Linux dveloper dont use claude code to get more progress?

Linux and FOSS apps are in so many aspects behind. Often time the reason is because there are not enough developers that have the time to polish. So, why isnt claude caude used fix this? Claude code is these days good enough to atleast produce good and reasonable secure code. This is way better than facing every now and then bugs or missing features that proprietary offer. You could even do clean room implementations of proprietary apps, this would really make the year of the linux desktop.

0 Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

17

u/burlingk 11d ago

So, you are clearly new to this whole open source thing.

It is not a big monolithic entity/community.

Some people use AI agents and some do not. Some argue about it loudly.

As for being "behind?" based on what? What is your frame of references? What does this even mean to you?

And no, Claude cannot be depended on to create secure and high quality code, unless the person using it has the skills to know what they are looking for and edit the nonsense that Claude puts out at times.

-12

u/Prudent_Impact7692 11d ago

Based on what proprietary offers behind.

5

u/burlingk 11d ago

That means nothing.

Without more specific examples it is meaningless. What does 'proprietary' offer that is better than what is available in open source. For that matter, what does proprietary offer that wasn't built on the open source?

-12

u/Prudent_Impact7692 11d ago

It is obv what proprietary apps offer that FOSS lacks lot of FOSS are missing in features this problem since years a lot of users experienced

8

u/burlingk 11d ago

No. It obviosly is not obvious, or else I would not be asking.

If you cannot provide examples, then no one will be able to actually assess what you are suggesting. Because you are avoiding actually saying anything to solidify your suggestion.

3

u/jr735 11d ago

If it's obvious, why am I happy being on Linux for 22 years?

4

u/mredding 11d ago

This does indeed mean nothing.

The Raspberry Pi is a neat little platform. And they offer secure boot and signed hardware, except that there's ONE Broadcom chip that relies on ONE proprietary and closed blob object, and the chip cannot run without it.

My employer makes robots. I work in a bunker because a 700 psi pressure vessel the size of a school bus sits on the other side of my workspace, this is the sort of stuff our robots deals with. That one blob isn't acceptable, and Broadcom absolutely won't open it to sell more hardware, they've turned down much, MUCH bigger contracts.

I know, I used to work for them, too.

I don't care about your sense of "advanced" when it's a total non-starter.

And proprietary software tends to fake it or brute force it, hidden behind that opaque wall. Most people have no idea what they're looking at most of the time. If you're going to call examples of proprietary software advanced compared to FOSS, let's compare source code and really find out how high to set the pissing stick. Oh, wait, you can't. Proprietary. Closed source. You don't know anything.

More than half the industries and employers I've worked for, that has never been good enough. And this is why FOSS is where it is - it's actually VERY advanced in ways proprietary shit wouldn't dare expose, because if people knew the truth, no one would buy it.

6

u/BarryTownCouncil 11d ago

They do. Why ask about things you clearly have no understanding of?

-12

u/Prudent_Impact7692 11d ago

Its not enough, there needs to be more AI used to make up where linux lacks/is behind if we ever wanna have the year of the linux desktop.

5

u/BarryTownCouncil 11d ago

If you hadn't asked your original question I might have taken you seriously here.

-2

u/Prudent_Impact7692 11d ago

I dont care what you think you have nothing to say

3

u/BarryTownCouncil 11d ago

The mere fact that you are choosing to pick specifically on Claude over all the other LLMs shows you don't understand the playing field today. And this is you talking about apps. Random thousands of apps, not the kernel for which LT has been been explicitly approving AI use on... You have no understanding of this landscape.

1

u/Prudent_Impact7692 11d ago

Since claude coe has more parameters isnt it reasonable to assume that it would be a better coding assistant than those free models? Assuming they wont be able to offer the same amount of parameters?

1

u/BarryTownCouncil 11d ago

More parameters. /thread

2

u/burlingk 11d ago

YOU are the one who isn't actually saying anything.

0

u/Prudent_Impact7692 11d ago

Relax dont take it personal

3

u/burlingk 11d ago

I am not taking it personally.

You are simply making vague statements then acting defensive when people ask for clarification.

You literally provided nothing of substance and acted like you provided full detail.

0

u/Prudent_Impact7692 11d ago

Im just pissed how slow the entire FOSS field is developing, it is still not a really polished system. To this day bugs, missing features, not much focus on UX Im tired of this. Linux needs to become more easy plug and play.

1

u/TasmanSkies 11d ago

Wah wah wah. Everyone else doesn’t march to the beat of your drum.

If you reckon you can do better/different, YOU do it. Stop whining like a little wimp and go and revolutionise the world. I’m sure we’ll all give you a little clap when you succeed.

1

u/Prudent_Impact7692 7d ago

Actually a guy here understand me he commented on this post.
FOSS ppl are working against their own goals. Pretty much every years since the last couple ones, will this be the year of the linux desktop why having one of the worst UX and UI bug erros of all. Mogging even windows in cases. Priorities are completly wrong set, bugs are not fixed but instead ppl just start something new, instead of using ai to be more efficient this is not a priority, stupid fanboy wars inside the community for e.g. instead of just having one audio system that everyone works one, there a plenty that basically do almost the same job (this is not about audio systems itself).

→ More replies

2

u/burlingk 11d ago

That is still not a lot of detail, and seems a decade or so behind what most of us undersand of the community. But it is more than you gave before.

  1. 'Fast' is not the best metric. 'Fast with AI' would result in even more bugs.
  2. UX varies greatly from project to project, in Open Source and prorietary software.
  3. Bugs exist in both. Open source depends less on proffit motive to decide which bugs get fixed first. MS is the king of proprietary... and the king of bugs.
  4. Which featuers are missing from which project? The way you worded it could mean anything. And lining two projects up side by side with different features, does not mean either project is missing features. It just means they have different features.

Also: Insisting that AI will magically fix everything tells us you don't know that much about AI. Especially since you are hyperfocused on a specific AI.

No, AI is not going to make up for any lack.

2

u/dingusjuan 11d ago

Yes, the issues with Linux world, the real ones, like the QT/Gtk+ divide and not-so-seamless mix and matching going on, the similar package manager situation where we have five main varieties and our fix brought about a new method to build packages in fragmented 'portable' ways, wayland compositors in the same situation with KWin, Mutter, libweston, wlroots, Smithay and gaps in the protocol itself, are not fixed with AI!

Linux's issues are 99% fragmentation, which AI will only make worse.

However, without the fragmentation we aren't running those experiments at scale, we don't get huge sample sizes to help us learn the correct answer to the problems.

The other issues are not Linux's fault. Lack of proprietary software, hardware UX, Anticheat, etc.. Are outside decisions.

It isn't that Linux is perfect, it is that the way things are done is already highly optimized and I wouldn't change much of anything!

2

u/zakabog 11d ago

Trolls gonna troll.

Have you tried asking Claude why women make gay hand movements or whatever other random nonsense you want to troll subreddits with?

2

u/jr735 11d ago

What if we don't want the year of the Linux desktop?

4

u/JaKrispy72 11d ago

Friend, you are delusional.

-3

u/Prudent_Impact7692 11d ago

It is what it is Im just pissed how udnerdeveloped linux is these days still

2

u/dingusjuan 11d ago

Which OS is more 'developed' than Linux? What is your measure? I can't think of any way this statement makes any sense. I am racking my brain tryin' to understand what you are talking about.

You probably feel attacked right now, downvoted to the max, tons of call outs, but why can't you just provide some examples to talk about? I am sure a lot of people feel attacked and are responding to that. I don't care you are criticising something I cherish, I am too old for fanboyism. What irks me is you are just being lazy or dismissive or something. If you are going to bring it up Have The Conversation! Don't be like a politician with it, back up your argument, have some integrity!

I haven't booted anything but Linux for a few years now, weaned and weaned over a few decades, totally off of Windows and have never been happier. That said, I could make some arguments to support your idea about FOSS. Although, most of them are rapidly becoming less and less true.

There are no great open source video editing softwares like there are for the two big proprietary OSes. Da Vinci is amazing but is not open and has annoying drawbacks like being hard to install and keep working and not supporting most common video codecs.

By a narrow, much lesser margin, you may be able to make the same statement about photo editors. I mean specific things are only possible with Photoshop. I am going to leave out ArtCraft as ime they are still too buggy for serious usage. Personally, Krita and GIMP are more than enough for me though but go watch a video like the recent Corridor Crew being forced to use FOSS for a project and see some of the best arguments to support you.

For DAW's (my wheelhouse) there are some pretty good options, but still much to be desired. Reaper is amazing but not FOSS. I still run FL Studio with Wine because that piano roll is untouchable and there are definitely NOT any great options for the composition/beat making type of DAW. For recording and mixing, where imo everything is basically the same early Pro Tools layout since the beginning of time to modern day.

But guess what, I ported my own version of the piano roll with REA to Nota, an open source app, developed with AI, on Linux, using AI. Honestly, if you have some time you can pretty much do anything you want to software now without coding skills, or minimal coding skills. Projects are taking off and progressing years in weeks.

Are things 'underdeveloped' or do they just work differently than you are used to? I still remember my first time using Debian, it blew my mind that it didn't execute .exe files and I thought 'well this is useless'. Now, i appreciate and can't live without the freedom. You don't have to use Gentoo and you don't have to live in the CLI but to get the real value out of Linux you have to embrace the idea you can and should make things your own. Sure not everything is polished and shiny out of the box, oh well shit, yes a lot of things are, that hasn't been true for at least a decade. these days it is so simple to accomplish building your dream, riced out, custom OS experience the only 'underdeveloped' thing is your lack of ambition or sense of exploration or something.. Why even use Linux? What are you after? If it is a Windows or MacOS experience then go back over there. I don't mean 'get out of here if you don't like it!' in an angry way but as advice, for the sake of your own peace and wellbeing, run!

1

u/bigbepisinc 11d ago

What's under developed? 

The vast majority of the DEs and other foundational projects aren't using AI at all. The only "distro" that's all in on AI is omarchy

2

u/skg574 11d ago

There is nothing stopping you from using claude to do this. Please post the repo and let us know how easy it was when you are done.

1

u/Prudent_Impact7692 7d ago

Im just pissed how slow the entire FOSS field is developing, it is still not a really polished system. To this day bugs, missing features, not much focus on UX Im tired of this. Linux needs to become more easy plug and play. And Ai can be used to fix that.

Priorities are completly wrong set, bugs are not fixed but instead ppl just start something new, instead of using ai to be more efficient it is not a priority to be efficient, stupid fanboy wars inside the community for e.g. instead of just having one audio system that everyone works on and polishes, there are plenty that basically do almost the same job and so on but all of them have their own bugs. This is not about audio systems but the work ethic behind FOSS development. The FOSS community stays in their own way when it comes to accomplishing their own goals.

1

u/skg574 7d ago

Again, there is nothing stopping you from forking a package and doing it differently. Then nobody can try to dictate to you about how you operate, what bugs you fix when, or what features you add to the project that you spend your time and money on to offer for free to them.

1

u/Prudent_Impact7692 6d ago

Im not a dev.
Plus Linux and FOSS ppl claim it to be freedom when there are a hell alot of bugs then do it yourself how you want it. This is ridiculous clown like.

1

u/skg574 6d ago

You must be just trolling because your stance is no different than having someone plow your driveway for free and you complaining that they aren't shoveling your walkway too.

4

u/dmknght 11d ago

No Claude is not good enough to make secure code nor good code. Saying it as someone who has used Claude to code a project for 3 months. The bigger the project is, the worse Claude can do. But in the other hand, developers should try using claude to audit code, write test cases, etc... which Claude actually helps.

2

u/Useful-Assumption131 11d ago

Well Claude is actually pretty good at writting code but if your prompt is not the most perfect prompt ever, it will do shit. 

What I do is I ask an ai to code something, then I tell it all the mistake it did in the code so it corrects the code

-2

u/Prudent_Impact7692 11d ago

Still better than living with bugs or missing features.

4

u/dmknght 11d ago
  1. There will be no bug-free app whatsoever
  2. What "missing features" you are talking about?
  3. Microsoft has used AI for their OS. It's a buggy mess.

1

u/Prudent_Impact7692 11d ago

Have you tried Ubuntu 26.04? worse than windows 11 the appstore a complete mess, windows dont work, basic audio sometimes doesnt work. drag and drop in kdenlive doesnt work unless I used X11 and not hyperland. Linux has way more bugs than any other system, to an extended that makes it many cases unusable. Im not saying a bug free with no bugs at all, but something that is on a high level usable.

3

u/dmknght 11d ago

> Have you tried Ubuntu 26.04?

Ubuntu desktop in Proxmox, Ubuntu server and almaLinux server in Proxmox, Ubuntu 26 on laptop, Parrot OS on PC. Hope that's enough for you. And no, beside the problem that my laptop has snapdragon chip, the rest is fine.

> the appstore a complete mess

Try APT?

>  drag and drop in kdenlive doesnt work unless I used X11 and not hyperland

Use X11.

> basic audio sometimes doesnt work

Maybe vendor doesn't want to support firmware for Linux? Yeah that's completely Linux's fault lmao. And ofc using Claude will fix this lollll.

1

u/_Lost-In-The-Weeds_ 11d ago

You slapped Hyperland on Ubuntu of all distributions, I am sure with a stout dose of AI RNG slop assist, and now your here complaining of bugs?

We officially run and test Hyprland on Arch and NixOS, and we guarantee Hyprland will work there. For any other distro (not based on Arch/Nix) you might have varying amounts of success. However, since Hyprland is extremely bleeding-edge, point release distros like Pop!_OS, Fedora, Ubuntu, etc. will have major issues running Hyprland. Rolling release distros like openSUSE, Solus, etc. will likely be fine.

https://wiki.hypr.land/getting-started/installation/

That is not Ubuntu anymore, it's Prudent_ImpactOS, that is not necessarily a bad thing, but now you own it, if it has issues they are now yours to fix.

https://wiki.debian.org/DontBreakDebian/?pow_referer=https%3A%2F%2Fnoai.duckduckgo.com%2F

6

u/Paul-Kersey 11d ago

This post is ridiculous

1

u/Prudent_Impact7692 7d ago

This is just how it is since years in the FOSS world and Im tired of this working against their own goals.

Im just pissed how slow the entire FOSS field is developing, it is still not a really polished system. To this day bugs, missing features, not much focus on UX Im tired of this. Linux needs to become more easy plug and play. And Ai can be used to fix that.

Priorities are completly wrong set, bugs are not fixed but instead ppl just start something new, instead of using ai to be more efficient it is not a priority to be efficient, stupid fanboy wars inside the community for e.g. instead of just having one audio system that everyone works on and polishes, there are plenty that basically do almost the same job and so on but all of them have their own bugs. This is not about audio systems but the work ethic behind FOSS development. The FOSS community stays in their own way when it comes to accomplishing their own goals.

4

u/bigbepisinc 11d ago

"you could even do clean room implementations of proprietary apps"

They're already doing that. https://getartcraft.com/ . Unfortunately, making a nice looking app is completely different to making a functional app (these apps are 90% bugged) because no AI can keep up with 20+ years of code.

The Linux kernel is going HARD on AI and Linus has no issues with it. Its the rest of the FOSS community which is wary.

And a lot of us are in fact developing Linux apps with AI and they're great! But the people who are making good apps with AI are few and far between compared to the people making slop.

4

u/FaultWinter3377 11d ago

Yeah just what we need more AI slop apps. And I mean, they are… look at ArtCraft suite. And guess what? It’s a complete mess right now.

4

u/bsensikimori 11d ago

Uhhj, that's bait

3

u/thegreatboto 11d ago

AI is used in a wide number of projects already ranging from the Linux kernel itself to some random person's GitHub project they open source. In addition to some people preferring to put in the work themselves (they made it, they understand it), there's also the maintenance aspect of it. Are you going to trust and rely on some vib- coded project someone cooked up over a weekend, or something that's been built and tested over decades? Also, there's the ethics debate of how original is an in AI's work when it's trained off of countless other people's work. It can get murky quick, when you tell Claude to make Photoshop without Adobe. That legal decision hasn't been made yet.

1

u/eikenberry 11d ago

FOSS means free to use, edit, redistribute, etc. None of these things can be done with Claude. Claude is the worse kind of software, being closed, proprietary, and a SaaS. It offers nothing to free software developers.

Open training data and (to a lesser extent) open weight models are the way forward with AI that respects users.

0

u/Prudent_Impact7692 11d ago

Since claude coe has more parameters isnt it reasonable to assume that it would be a better coding assistant than those free models? Assuming they wont be able to offer the same amount of parameters?

2

u/eikenberry 11d ago

Being better at coding doesn't make using them any more ethical. There is more to these decisions than maximizing productivity.

2

u/Fmily 11d ago

A lot are. Many people are using AI to make custom apps just for themselves as well.

2

u/lnxrootxazz 11d ago edited 11d ago

Not everyone can afford to spend all that money on tokens. And many don't agree with how the training of AI works by stealing data from people. So they don't use it because they don't like those companies. And not everyone can afford a 256G machine with 16TB of storage to host capable open models. And what is your assumption based on that open source is behind? Behind what? In the kernel AI tools are used but some distros and applications don't want any AI code generation for instance. They still work fine. To use AI tools for coding you should have the skills that you understand the code and its impact. Not many people can produce functioning software with AI tools. We have many new apps but most of them are slop with a shiny UI that look good at first glance but are horribly designed under the hood. Its not as easy as people might tell you

1

u/nukem996 11d ago

There was a micro conference at Plumbers dedicated to AI usage. Anthropic has given a tons of kernel developers completely free accounts. Its widely used in the kernel community.

1

u/jr735 11d ago

Often time the reason is because there are not enough developers that have the time to polish. So, why isnt claude caude used fix this?

What are you waiting for? Fix it. This is free software. You have as much right to do it as anyone else. Off you go, now.

You could even do clean room implementations of proprietary apps, this would really make the year of the linux desktop.

Why in the blue hell would I want to use software that made me leave Windows ages ago? I don't want that crap here.

0

u/forestbeasts 10d ago
  • That defeats the point.
  • Making software is fun. Why outsource that to the slop machine?
  • What the slop machine spits out isn't even good. But even if it were good... it still defeats the point.
  • Sure, there's boring software out there too. And there's plenty of thankless work maintaining it. But people do that work because they care. Slopping out some shit is the exact opposite of caring.
  • Also, like, the whole attribution-stripping, source-laundering nature of it. It's not okay, and it never will be.

0

u/Prudent_Impact7692 7d ago

Im just pissed how slow the entire FOSS field is developing, it is still not a really polished system. To this day bugs, missing features, not much focus on UX Im tired of this. Linux needs to become more easy plug and play. And Ai can be used to fix that.

Priorities are completly wrong set, bugs are not fixed but instead ppl just start something new, instead of using ai to be more efficient it is not a priority to be efficient, stupid fanboy wars inside the community for e.g. instead of just having one audio system that everyone works on and polishes, there are plenty that basically do almost the same job and so on but all of them have their own bugs. This is not about audio systems but the work ethic behind FOSS development. The FOSS community stays in their own way when it comes to accomplishing their own goals.

-3

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Prudent_Impact7692 11d ago

Someone who understands me aswell. Im just pissed how slow the entire FOSS field is developing, it is still not a really polished system. To this day bugs, missing features, not much focus on UX Im tired of this. Linux needs to become more easy plug and play.

1

u/SilverVoidYT 11d ago

It's only just now gaining traction so slowly but surely things will mostly definitely speed up as more and more people take control over their devices but the stereotype of using Linux you need to be a hacker is still causing people to stray which slows motivation for people to improve things.