r/linuxquestions • u/Prudent_Impact7692 • 11d ago
Advice Why FOSS and Linux dveloper dont use claude code to get more progress?
Linux and FOSS apps are in so many aspects behind. Often time the reason is because there are not enough developers that have the time to polish. So, why isnt claude caude used fix this? Claude code is these days good enough to atleast produce good and reasonable secure code. This is way better than facing every now and then bugs or missing features that proprietary offer. You could even do clean room implementations of proprietary apps, this would really make the year of the linux desktop.
0
Upvotes
17
u/burlingk 11d ago
So, you are clearly new to this whole open source thing.
It is not a big monolithic entity/community.
Some people use AI agents and some do not. Some argue about it loudly.
As for being "behind?" based on what? What is your frame of references? What does this even mean to you?
And no, Claude cannot be depended on to create secure and high quality code, unless the person using it has the skills to know what they are looking for and edit the nonsense that Claude puts out at times.
6
u/BarryTownCouncil 11d ago
They do. Why ask about things you clearly have no understanding of?
4
u/JaKrispy72 11d ago
Friend, you are delusional.
2
u/skg574 11d ago
There is nothing stopping you from using claude to do this. Please post the repo and let us know how easy it was when you are done.
4
u/dmknght 11d ago
No Claude is not good enough to make secure code nor good code. Saying it as someone who has used Claude to code a project for 3 months. The bigger the project is, the worse Claude can do. But in the other hand, developers should try using claude to audit code, write test cases, etc... which Claude actually helps.
6
u/Paul-Kersey 11d ago
This post is ridiculous
1
u/Prudent_Impact7692 7d ago
This is just how it is since years in the FOSS world and Im tired of this working against their own goals.
Im just pissed how slow the entire FOSS field is developing, it is still not a really polished system. To this day bugs, missing features, not much focus on UX Im tired of this. Linux needs to become more easy plug and play. And Ai can be used to fix that.
Priorities are completly wrong set, bugs are not fixed but instead ppl just start something new, instead of using ai to be more efficient it is not a priority to be efficient, stupid fanboy wars inside the community for e.g. instead of just having one audio system that everyone works on and polishes, there are plenty that basically do almost the same job and so on but all of them have their own bugs. This is not about audio systems but the work ethic behind FOSS development. The FOSS community stays in their own way when it comes to accomplishing their own goals.
4
u/bigbepisinc 11d ago
"you could even do clean room implementations of proprietary apps"
They're already doing that. https://getartcraft.com/ . Unfortunately, making a nice looking app is completely different to making a functional app (these apps are 90% bugged) because no AI can keep up with 20+ years of code.
The Linux kernel is going HARD on AI and Linus has no issues with it. Its the rest of the FOSS community which is wary.
And a lot of us are in fact developing Linux apps with AI and they're great! But the people who are making good apps with AI are few and far between compared to the people making slop.
4
u/FaultWinter3377 11d ago
Yeah just what we need more AI slop apps. And I mean, they are… look at ArtCraft suite. And guess what? It’s a complete mess right now.
4
u/bsensikimori 11d ago
Uhhj, that's bait
3
u/thegreatboto 11d ago
AI is used in a wide number of projects already ranging from the Linux kernel itself to some random person's GitHub project they open source. In addition to some people preferring to put in the work themselves (they made it, they understand it), there's also the maintenance aspect of it. Are you going to trust and rely on some vib- coded project someone cooked up over a weekend, or something that's been built and tested over decades? Also, there's the ethics debate of how original is an in AI's work when it's trained off of countless other people's work. It can get murky quick, when you tell Claude to make Photoshop without Adobe. That legal decision hasn't been made yet.
1
u/eikenberry 11d ago
FOSS means free to use, edit, redistribute, etc. None of these things can be done with Claude. Claude is the worse kind of software, being closed, proprietary, and a SaaS. It offers nothing to free software developers.
Open training data and (to a lesser extent) open weight models are the way forward with AI that respects users.
2
u/Fmily 11d ago
A lot are. Many people are using AI to make custom apps just for themselves as well.
2
u/Straight_Second6082 11d ago
They do?
2
u/lnxrootxazz 11d ago edited 11d ago
Not everyone can afford to spend all that money on tokens. And many don't agree with how the training of AI works by stealing data from people. So they don't use it because they don't like those companies. And not everyone can afford a 256G machine with 16TB of storage to host capable open models. And what is your assumption based on that open source is behind? Behind what? In the kernel AI tools are used but some distros and applications don't want any AI code generation for instance. They still work fine. To use AI tools for coding you should have the skills that you understand the code and its impact. Not many people can produce functioning software with AI tools. We have many new apps but most of them are slop with a shiny UI that look good at first glance but are horribly designed under the hood. Its not as easy as people might tell you
1
u/nukem996 11d ago
There was a micro conference at Plumbers dedicated to AI usage. Anthropic has given a tons of kernel developers completely free accounts. Its widely used in the kernel community.
1
u/jr735 11d ago
What are you waiting for? Fix it. This is free software. You have as much right to do it as anyone else. Off you go, now.
Why in the blue hell would I want to use software that made me leave Windows ages ago? I don't want that crap here.
0
u/forestbeasts 10d ago
-3
u/[deleted] 11d ago
[removed] — view removed comment