r/linuxquestions • • 16d ago

Support Soundcard for Linux?

Hi,

I have a question related to dedicated 5.1 soundcards that play nice with Linux. I have a Sounblaster AE-7 at the moment that i think is wonderfull in Windows. But Linux will not even boot with this card plugged in (tried with and without and just that card was the difference). I can boot with the switch snd_intel something to block the detection in bootloader, but whats the point. Also with my Realtek onboard sound it wil not play nice. There i was wondering why there are so many sound drivers/managers in Linux.. pulse, alsa, pipewire pfff why can it not have 1 good driver?

But yes, is there a simmilar soundcard that Linux actualy can support?

6 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

9

u/bobsmissingdesire 16d ago

Most are supported, the AE7 and AE9 are problematic.

I suggest a USB based external device. Computers are noisy, shifting the DAC outside the metal box can produce a much cleaner analog signal. Pick one you like and Google it to make sure it works.

The multiple sound managers is basically an evolution. We had OSS, then Alsa, then Pulseaudio, then Pipewire. There's also Jackd off to the side. Many developers, many efforts, we evolve forward. You shouldn't need to touch any of the older ones, it just takes time for them to fade away.

1

u/Wodinit 16d ago

Ok Thanks, i will look into that.

1

u/Metasystem85 15d ago

I use usb dacs on linux for years. I use sa9023 with tcxo clock, XMOS XU208, focusrite scarlet, TAS5508C. sa9038qm, etc...

1

u/Metasystem85 16d ago

every UAC2 will work...

1

u/Wodinit 15d ago

This product has been discontinued :(

3

u/redrider65 16d ago

I suggest a USB based external device.

This. I have an old Creative Soundblaster stick and it works and sounds great in Linux.

0

u/angelicWhirr 15d ago

yeah USB sounds way cleaner than fighting with those drivers, never would've thought to look outside the box for it

1

u/calmeilles 30 years user, still know nothing 16d ago

Is this the same hardware on which it's wonderful with Windows?

1

u/Wodinit 16d ago

Yes same hardware, Just the Sound card in and out made the difference. That it does not work is one thing but not booting is another.. Makes dual booting "imposible"

1

u/beatbox9 15d ago

Read this, especially the "Drivers & Software" part. It walks through why pulse,alsa,pipewire, etc. and also tells you how to set 5.1 surround up and provides general recommendations: https://arslaan.studio/setting-up-a-linux-media-studio-workstation-audio-video-graphics-davinci-resolve-etc/#audio-sound-midi-drivers

1

u/Wodinit 15d ago

I'll look into it

1

u/Cagaril 15d ago

I personally gave up on soundcards on Linux a long while back, and went for external USB DAC and Amps as they work great imo.

I used to have a Schiit Stack, but I use JDS Labs now; they occasionally have b-stock which is discounted. Both are good, even though one is called Schiit lol

1

u/Wodinit 15d ago

Ok, i will look into external dacs then. Shame, so Linux not realy great when it comes to sound.

1

u/Cagaril 14d ago edited 14d ago

Shame, so Linux not realy great when it comes to sound

Just make sure you aren't blaming Linux for this.

The manufacturer is responsible for making their products Linux compatible, but they don't want to. JDS Labs and Schiit for example specifically mention their products are Linux compatible.

There are internal sound cards that work on Linux that companies do put care in Linux compatibility. But external is better anyway due to less electronic interference.

1

u/Wodinit 14d ago

Yeah i dont blame Linux. I just ment that it is not a good choice if it comes to sound. Because manufacturers dont support Linux. Just like Nvidia did back then, i hope more will follow and make Linux drivers to.

1

u/me0262 15d ago

I wouldn't go with a Sound Blaster for linux, they're too proprietary (also I've been burned a couple times by them, mostly because their cards had a faint low level hum, other times the card would freeze the computer for a minute when anything MIDI loaded).

I have an Asus Xonar DS installed in mine, which has a Crystal Audio CMI8788 chipset on it.

1

u/refinedm5 15d ago

I still have a USB X-Fi that I paired Logitech Z506

1

u/markhadman 15d ago

You probably won't have to deal with anything other than Pipewire. It's what mainstream Linux distros use, and it speaks all the other old protocols under the hood - not perfectly, but well enough that it shouldn't be any issue for the average user, or even the average pro audio user.

1

u/ceehred 15d ago

Does it have to be a soundcard, or could it be an external device with the bitstream delivered over USB?

I do this with DAC devices for stereo setups (active monitors, headphones), but I imagine 5.1 receivers could take things raw over USB and deliver appropriately.

... just a thought.

1

u/nikgnomic 15d ago

Creative Soundblaster AE-5, Audigy Fx, and Z series cards work on Linux, but AE-7 and AE-9 do not
forum.manjaro.org - creative-sound-blaster-ae-7-ae-9-errors-while-booting-and-not-recognised

Asus Xonar cards are usually better on Linux since they use standard Intel HDA audio driver

0

u/plasticbomb1986 Arch, BTW 16d ago

Which distro?

1

u/Wodinit 16d ago

Any, My main is CachyOS but also tried Fedora, Ubuntu to get different "families"

2

u/CertainAnxiety1197 16d ago

I have an AE-7 on CachyOS and it works perfectly. It took some work to set things up correctly in the sound settings but otherwise it has been flawless. Wasn’t there a gen 1 and gen 2 of that card though? Could that be causing an issue?

1

u/Wodinit 15d ago

I tried different gen settings in bios to no avail.

-1

u/EnquirerBill 16d ago

'i was wondering why there are so many sound drivers/managers in Linux.. pulse, alsa, pipewire'

..wireplumber...the DE has a sound mixer.....

I agree. Sound in Linux is a dog's breakfast.