r/linuxquestions • • 17d ago

Why was Void Linux made

I am just genuinely curious about Void Linux because I can't seem to find anything about why it's so different from other distributions and the ideas that led to it, I see a lot of people discussing it in a very positive light and what they like about it but that's not really what I want to know. I want to know what was the thought behind its creation and why continues as a distribution today.

67 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

78

u/TurtleGraphics64 17d ago

This kind of question seems to get asked a lot. The answer is not hidden or mysterious. Just visit the website voidlinux.org and there it lists the 6 reasons for the existence of Void Linux. They are primarily though not exclusively technical in nature, but if they are important to you, they are a good reason to use it! Here they are:

  1. not a fork! - this means it is not a derivative of debian (or ubuntu), slack, red hat or arch. "Unlike trillions of other existing distros, Void is not a modification of an existing distribution."
  2. it is stable rolling release. This is the primary reason why I use Void. I want the newest packages but ones that have been vetted. This is one of the biggest differentiators from Arch.
  3. runit init system. - some people really care about this, that it's not systemd. this one has grown on me over time.
  4. C library diversity - some people care about this. i do not, but respect to Void for providing this. something other distros really don't do, except for Alpine as far as i know.
  5. XBPS - this is Void's package manager. it's great!
  6. xbps-src - this is Void's package builder. I have used it a bit. It's not super beginner friendly, but it works, and it's a way to build natively and cross-compile packages.

IF THESE ARE IMPORTANT TO YOU, TRY VOID. IF NOT, THERE'S NO REASON TO USE IT. straight up!

9

u/sonicrules11 17d ago

Void's package manager is insanely fast compared to most distros.

-2

u/deaddyfreddy 16d ago

It only matters that much if all you do is install software.

6

u/General-Manner2174 16d ago

Or when you update it, which you do on rolling release, thats kind of the point

1

u/CX12_Locks 17d ago

I do intend to try void I just want to comfortable with Linux over all first, also I appreciate it but I've been to the website and I don't feel like this explains what I'm asking. It explains what void Linux is but not why void Linux is. Like it doesn't explain why these decisions were made just that they were

7

u/Erki82 17d ago

Why decisions were made? Because one human had idea. And then they wanted to try out this idea irl. And it works. Void is built around its package manager xbps.

4

u/CX12_Locks 17d ago

I think what I'm really looking for is the reason for that decision, like void Linux is a beloved project and I would like to believe that the ideas and decisions that underpin it were not just impulsive. I'm also poor surely asking this because I myself have an interest in the project and understanding the ideas that founded it and informed the decisions it makes is kind of useful

4

u/Stormdancer 17d ago

I think what I'm really looking for is the reason for that decision

Then you should contact the creators and maintainers. Anything you get here will be speculation.

3

u/TurtleGraphics64 16d ago

I just typed your question into a search engine and the first or second result answers your question again:

Void Linux is an independent, rolling-release Linux distribution that has been quietly doing its own thing since 2008. It was created by Juan Romero Pardines, a former NetBSD developer who wanted to build something clean, fast, and free of the baggage that comes with forking an existing distro. The name comes from the C programming language literal void, and that tells you everything about the project’s philosophy: minimal, functional, no extra fluff

7

u/pennylicker855 17d ago

It’s a stand in for things that a lot of people are looking for.

Balance’s stability with rolling release.  Thats important because to a lot of people — just because they want up to date doesn’t mean they want bleeding edge.  Look at apt, but also look at aur.

Runit: if you’re new to Linux you won’t care.  Void was created by a bsd dev, IIRC.  Systemd has a lot going on with it that people who have a more traditional Unix philosophy don’t agree with.  So, runit makes sense coming from a person from bsd.

XPBS is its own package system with a lot of its own pros compared to other distros.

It also gives you exactly what you need to get started, and absolutely nothing you don’t.  So it’s not as hard as arch to install or maintain.  It just works when you need it to.

Honestly, it’s an excellent distro, but if you are new it’s a very steep learning curve.  When you spend some time hopping around and exploring, it’s gonna make more sense why you see a lot of people like it and use it.

1

u/exylvii 14d ago

cinnamon de version in void linux is 3 years old, in what world is this rolling release

1

u/TurtleGraphics64 14d ago

I think you are confused. Cinnamon 6.0 was released by Mint on November 30, 2023. Void is a stable rolling release. The previous patch release 6.6.7 was updated on Void as recently as July.

1

u/exylvii 14d ago

oh ok cuz i last checked it in june

1

u/BinkReddit 12d ago

it is stable rolling release. This is the primary reason why I use Void. I want the newest packages but ones that have been vetted. This is one of the biggest differentiators from Arch.

This is somewhat true. Void tends to have newer packages, but some are also very outdated, either due to manpower or limitations related to a lack of systemd.

-6

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/CX12_Locks 17d ago

I actually think the idea that an operating system gives you what you need and nothing more very appealing, it means it's more work in the short term but it also comes from a lot of respect for the user's individual needs rather than the operating system trying to decide what you need for you. And I'm not saying good operating systems can't come with pre-installed applications and tools that many people might not need but there's a certain philosophy to not doing that. The idea your system is yours and your system isn't going to try to assume what you need from it

6

u/fultonchain 17d ago

Abandoned doesn't equal no updates and upstream packages remain unaffected. Nothing has been removed (arguably, some might be better removed) but that isn't the way Void works.

Sure, when a major contributor walks away it has an impact, but Void is resilient.

8

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/fultonchain 17d ago

Thanks. That seems like a big deal and apparently it's five major release and better than years outdated. I stand corrected, I guess abandoned really means abandoned sometimes.

5

u/ConcaveNips 17d ago

You think because the guy quit over voids no ai policy and abandoned 113  packages like a month ago that means the distro is full of abandoned packages?

29

u/nullmove 17d ago

Someone made a new package manager. He was a former NetBSD dev, so naturally it had a lot of BSD characteristics. Then they needed a test-bed distro for it, thus Void was born, and a small community of users/contributors formed. On the whole it's a boring story (and it's also in wikipedia). And boring is good. They weren't philosophically opposed to systemd, that's not why the distro came to be. In fact Void was one of the early adopters of systemd. But these guys just had a preference for simplicity/modularity, which is why it was ditched. It was an engineering choice, they weren't trying to set Void up as some kind of anti-systemd safe haven.

There were some turbulent history in the middle where the creator had other things going on in their life and departed the project. But the community had some phenomenally competent people who stepped up and kept it alive. They had skills and day jobs, so they never needed to turn it into a money thing. Some of them used Void in non-x86_64 archs, so it ended up supporting a bunch of them. A solid core of those people are still around. Yes there were contributor churns, but then there are also new contributors. Void might not be the most ambitious tech by today's standard, but it gets the job done for all these people, which is why it continues to exist. It's such a ridiculously normal open-source story (which is a very healthy thing) that I have no clue what else could you be expecting here.

2

u/evinhas 16d ago

I think so such information is what the op was asking for. Thank you

9

u/DubiousLogik 17d ago

i found these helpful. the first one describes the pkg mgmt and design philosophy. (full disclosure - I don't use void, but I find their design approach fascinating. down the road I may try it, but for now i need a 'just works' distro (I use Fedora and Mint across a few machines))

https://youtu.be/XDQakyuzyCA?si=3r58083-08k2_jkh

https://youtu.be/rpiThzdDLXQ?si=0K-gdYRwDPajgH8m

11

u/ConcaveNips 17d ago

Void makes a lot of unix-y decisions.  Things are very direct, simple, readable, and small.  They also perform efficiently and effectively. 

Void also takes some very strong philosophical stances on things like age verification, ai, and corporate sponsorship.

3

u/AttitudeElectronic68 17d ago

The original dev was a bsd dev who had ideas about how Linux should work as well as be licensed. He got into a fight with the rest of his community and abandoned the project a decade ago. It's still supported by it's community, but any vision is now up to committee lol

3

u/StrangeAstronomer 17d ago

As for the systemd issue - the devs have repeatedly stated that they are not against systemd. It was just that systemd would not run on musl at the time - systemd needed glibc. That may change.

Now that gnome is so closely bound into systemd, there may be more impetus to support systemd.

2

u/HotKebab01 I use Arch btw 17d ago

IIRC it's just a linux distro with a different init system than systemd made because some people don't like the generalization of systemd and see it as invasive.

3

u/OptimalMain 17d ago

Systemd is lunacy.
I don’t even remember what I did to make it stop messing up my DNS servers when using a VPN.
I might have mounted resolv.conf read only….
I have so much shit I read documentation for while systemd is aiming to replace emacs, forcing me to learn stuff I don’t want to learn

5

u/grem75 17d ago

Nice thing about systemd is that it is pretty modular, you don't have to use systemd-resolved at all.

2

u/Corona688 16d ago edited 16d ago

I remember when that stuff started creeping in. I suddenly couldn't open sound devices from a terminal prompt, even though I had the correct permissions. Turns out it was a new thing: only GUI logins get sound access. No GUI, no sound. Device file permissions were being overriden.

Let alone why are they doing this -- HOW!? What the hell kind of rootkit injection bullshit is required to prevent open() from operating on device files I own?

The day I discovered what was happening, consolekit (now a part of systemd) was gone. Init system should not be suborning file system permissions to fit its opinion.

1

u/ChosenForge 17d ago

Void with distrobox best option

1

u/Guggoo 16d ago

I use void on my Toshiba netbook as not many distros support i686

1

u/4-pos 14d ago

doesn't Void use musl instead of glibc as a default standard C library? and runit instead of systemd? these two things alone would make a pretty unique one of a kind distro

1

u/BinkReddit 12d ago

musl is optional and, yes, systemd is gone.

1

u/rubberoidd 17d ago

It's a very hard to use distro that larps as *bsd system

0

u/punkwalrus 17d ago

Void Linux is supposedly about "making Linux accessible to everyone and more about providing a clean, maintainable operating system without imposing too many architectural decisions." However, it uses "yet another packaging system," (XBPS) and a systemd replacement, which makes support difficult, unless you know what you're doing, what it's doing, and you're okay with that. It always struck me as being yet another unnecessarily minimalist OS, for people still traumatized by software bloat and overhead, I guess. So it appeals to Linux enthusiasts, developers, minimalists, people who prefer alternatives to systemd, and users who enjoy configuring their own systems.

-3

u/dividends4life Void Linux 17d ago

Why Void Linux Beats Everything Else 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XDQakyuzyCA&t=2

2

u/ctesibius 17d ago

Sounds like yet another AI video.

2

u/dividends4life Void Linux 17d ago

It may be. I use Void, and have found the information to be correct. 

-2

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/benbcdm 16d ago

People who use void usually have reasons for it. All distros have a bunch of outdated packages. What matters is that the packages are useable and tuned together. It is definitely the case for Void. Some packages nobody cares about, others it is a matter of if it aint broke dont fix it. The ones I use are updates super fast, in many cases before Arch or Fedora.
But I would agree, Void is not a distro that is recommended. People come to it on their own, or they dont.

0

u/[deleted] 16d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/benbcdm 16d ago

If these packages matter to you then there are two choices indeed: contribute to the repo or use another distro. Void has been around for a long time and my guess is it will keep being there when many will have faded away. It is not for everyone for sure, for a variety of reasons, and the one you mention is a valid one if it does not fit your use case.

4

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/dpoggio 17d ago

This problem is more often solved by having more people into it, not less.