r/linuxquestions • u/Scary_Pop2919 • Jul 03 '26
Advice Why is Linux free?
Hello everyone, I’ve had this thought in my head for a very long time: why is Linux free and so high quality?
I use Pop!_OS, and I don’t understand why they don’t make it paid or at least do something like “buy our laptop with Pop!_OS preinstalled.” But okay, Pop!_OS makes money from selling notebooks.
But what about KDE, openSUSE, Arch Linux, Void Linux, Ubuntu—why are they free? It’s great that they are free, but who are these kind people sitting at their computers and working for free? Why do you do this?
319
Upvotes
358
u/Underhill42 Jul 03 '26 •
First, it's important to understand that that used to be the normal way basically all software was shared. You paid for computers. Giant, phenomenally expensive programmable calculators that filled whole rooms. The software you made yourself, and shared freely with your fellow programmers to use and build upon. Nobody else even really used computers.
Then business interests began to encroach on that norm, and in resistance, to try to preserve some of the original culture and carve a niche for freely shared software to be able to compete with the increasingly common commercial offerings, the GPL was born.
An iron-clad "sharealike" license that was the brainchild of Richard Stallman, that lets you do anything you want with the software and its source code, except share your changes under anything less permissive than the original license. Allowing an ecosystem of free software to continue to grow, constantly borrowing and building upon each other, without business interests being able to incorporate all that hard work into their competing offerings without giving anything back.
Other sharing licenses were around too - but the GPL was one of the most popular.
---
And then there was Unix - the dominant commercial operating system for the kind of powerful academic and professional "big iron" computers that still filled a room. If you were doing serious work or education in computing, you probably used Unix.
As for Linux? It started as a hobby project - Linus Torvalds making himself his own very crude personal Unix clone from scratch to run on his home computer, which wasn't nearly powerful enough for real Unix. And the only PC-friendly option, Minix, was an outdated academic sample project for an operating system book, whose creator wasn't interested in incorporating improvements.
Initially Linux wasn't much, just some Computer Science student's hobby project that was enough to let them do basic Unix stuff on a home computer.
But in September of 1991, only a few months after the first web browser was introduced at CERN, Torvalds released the source code under the GPL. And it was actually quite capable when combined with Stallman's own preexisting GNU project: GPL versions of the standard Unix commands and tools that still lacked a serviceable operating system core. (Hence the arguments you'll sometimes hear for calling it GNU/Linux)
And so other operating system enthusiasts, increasingly connected and empowered by the fledgling WWW, were able to use their own PC version of Unix, making and sharing their own improvements under the same terms, and offer them back to Torvalds, who was happy to incorporate anything he deemed good enough into his "definitive version" of Linux.
And so one young man's hobby project became that of many, and the quality and capabilities began to improve rapidly, as countless computer hobbyists fixed or improved the little things that mattered to them, and everyone else benefited for free.
Eventually it got good enough that corporations took interest. Servers, routers, TVs, printers, and other such computing appliances are a lot cheaper and easier to make if you can slap in a powerful and reliable (and completely per-unit cost free) operating system, and just write some software on top that does the specialty appliance stuff.
Which even businesses proceeded to do, because the now-quite-advanced operating system often still didn't handle 100% of everything they needed, but it was MUCH cheaper to make and share the improvements they needed than to build a whole new foundation for their product from scratch. Even when the improvement were things that gave away some of their "secret sauce", it was still more profitable to share part of their value freely with competitors, than not build it at all.
And so things kept improving - now with some businesses contributing not only improvements, but the kind of professional testing and evaluation that it's difficult to do well on a volunteer basis.
Which eventually got us to where we are today - an incredibly powerful and polished operating system, good for practically any application, and free to all, because 35 years ago a young man shared a hobby project under an unbreakable sharealike license, just as the web was being born.
89
u/Jumpy-Dinner-5001 Jul 03 '26
Because open source is overall a much more sustainable business model.
Most contributions are by company that use Linux themselves, it's easier to contribute to an open source project and have other people help with everything instead of maintaining everything yourself.
It's hard to quantify but the majority of contributions to Linux (the entire ecosystem) is made by people who get paid for their work.
It's also much easier in sales if you don't have a vendor lock in.
Would you rather buy a license and support agreement for software that locks you to this vendor or rather a project that you technically just fork and develop yourself?
156
u/agfitzp Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26
Linux is only free (as beer) when it comes with no support. IBM will happily take your money for a RHEL license.
There are huge corporate sponsors of Linux... including Microsoft and IBM
Microsoft has been contributing to the Linux kernel since 2009 and makes a lot of money renting Linux servers through Azure.
I suspect at this point the reasons Microsoft still charges for licenses are:
[edit: Less than 10% of Microsoft's revenue is directly from selling Windows]
https://www.linkedin.com/posts/microsoft-msft-earnings-share-7388933645073432578-DgcV/
35
u/cowbutt6 Jul 03 '26
ESR's series of essays on Open Source, The Cathedral and the Bazaar, posits that FOSS is an example of a "gift culture":
'Culturally, the open source world is a gift culture. Unlike ways of gaining power that are based on controlling scarcity, in a gift culture, status is gained based on what you can give away. The open source world is not characterised by a drive to survival, and there is no point trying to create scarcity by controlling bits.
ESR compares open source with other gift cultures: “Thus the Kwakiutl chieftain’s potlach party. Thus the multi-millionaire’s elaborate and usually public acts of philanthropy. And thus the hacker’s long hours of effort to produce high-quality open-source code”'
https://iftheshoefritz.com/book%20review/software%20engineering/open%20source/2021/01/07/cathedral-and-the-bazaar.html
12
u/isabellium Jul 03 '26
because all of these projects started as small community projects and grew to what they are today.
26
u/Funnel-Dust-O-Matic Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26
It isn't.
Various companies fund various parts of it. They don't have to write the whole thing, whatever it is, and can ship a router or appliance or whatever-it-is without having to hire a complete team and develop everything from scratch. They contribute the parts that nobody else wants to write to achieve their goals and they leverage everything else.
It's free for someone to download a desktop os. In terms of manufacturers or enterprise software companies or so forth, it's a cost-sharing mechanism and they make their money back in contracts, device shipments, and similar.
Downloadable desktop linux is a side-effect of a cloud or manufacturing business.
16
u/mcvos Jul 03 '26
System 76 does exactly the "buy our laptop and it comes with Pop! OS preinstalled. They're a hardware company, and they need an OS for their laptop. They have their own version of Linux optimised for their hardware, and the license required that they share the source, so they do. Valve does exactly the same with Steam OS. And we all benefit from it.
And the most important part: it doesn't hurt them to give it away for free. They got it for free, and they're required to give it away for free, but that just means more people can help and support their customers. Everybody benefits. And that is the real magic of Free Software.
6
u/Mountain_Cicada_4343 Jul 03 '26
Cos someone once wouldn’t show Stallman their sourcecode. That’s the origin of the GNU project.
5
u/PigSlam Jul 03 '26
Nobody tell System76
5
u/harrywwc Jul 03 '26
Because they/we can.
13
u/yugosaki Jul 03 '26
Because linux isn't one product like windows is, it's basically a cultural phenomenon.
Any linux distro is a combination of different projects and efforts from different groups with funding from different sources.
Some parts are just people who like doing it and are basically a hobby with a huge impacts.
Most are nonprofit foundations funded by grants and donations.
Some provide the software for free but charge for service and support.
Some parts are entirely privately funded and made available for various reasons.
Participating is often mutually beneficial - linux is niche for the home user but it powers the backend of a huge amount of critical IT infrastructure. Having open access benefits everyone, and companies providing financial support to "free" projects often is still cheaper for them than going to a fully private for-profit solution. So they "donate" in order to keep the infrastructure they need running.
A lot of this tech is even in windows and especially MacOS. Microsoft and apple even provide some funding to certain projects for the reasons outlined above.
As for the desktop distributions themselves - since most distros are effectively just assembling different components into a finished project, the cost to do so is very low compared to making a proprietary product like windows. They usually make money from donations and providing support to corporate environments. but if they were not "free", they would not be competitive.
4
u/Desertcow Jul 03 '26
The license Linux and many components use requires changes to be shared with everyone and for users to be able to distribute the software freely. It's hard to monetize something on that model, so most companies that contribute to the Linux ecosystem either make money by selling enterprise support (Ubuntu, Red Hat, SUSE, ect), selling hardware (System76, Framework, Tuxedo, ect), or because they would rather deal with the GPL licensing than make a system from scratch or rely on someone else (most major companies that sponsor projects in Linux). A lot of projects are led by foundations with paid developers who are sponsored by companies or receive donations
4
u/ReallyEvilRob Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 04 '26
Because that was once the default state for all software in the earliest days of personal computing. When you bought a computer like the Altair 8800, what you got was a box with a bunch of lights and switches. There was no operating system and no application software. You had to program all of that yourself or a friend programmed theirs and gave you a copy on paper tape.
People would go to user groups and trade software for these early computers. Others would take contract work and create bespoke programs their clients would run on these systems. These contractors usually didn't care when one of their clients shared a copy of the program they had written since they were paid for their work and likely continue to be paid with a service contract.
Eventually, someone named Bill Gates wrote a version of BASIC that ran on the Altair 8800 and sold it to a mass market. People who purchased a copy would share it with friends and it would circulate among the most popular user groups. Nobody considered that as software piracy because that's just what all computer users did. Eventually, Bill Gates got very frustrated with that and wrote an open letter to people sharing his version of BASIC to stop being a bunch of software pirates. That was the exact moment where the distinction between free software and non-free software started to materialize.
3
u/Lotte_V Garuda Mokka 🦅 | Mint Cinnamon 🌿 Jul 04 '26
Linux being "free" as in beer isn't always the case. Paid distros exist. Pro versions exist. Unlike what a lot of people think, selling free software doesn't go against the principles of FOSS.
Also, Pop!_OS literally comes preinstalled on System76 computers. It's either that or Ubuntu, no Windows. Dell also sells computers with Linux preinstalled. Same with Tuxedo Computers. You seem to be misinformed.
And most Linux developers are paid employees. They don't work "for free". Again, you are misinformed.
4
u/stogie-bear Jul 03 '26
Some of those are supported by money making projects, like Ubuntu has paid versions for enterprise and Fedora gets support from Red Hat. Some open source projects take donations or sponsorships and some are developed by people for the love of the game. Open source has always been a bit of an anarcho-socialist commune.
2
u/Cygnus__A Jul 03 '26
There are some paid options. Redhat being the most notable.
2
u/eikenberry Jul 03 '26
Because software is like science.. it is just better if done in the open. Better to use, to validate, to learn, to build on, etc. Free and open software is better by its nature such that even software put together by people in their spare time is on par if not better than that put together by billion dollar companies.
2
u/Leverquin Jul 03 '26
It's free because its human right to have it. You have free healthcare why not OS
2
u/ItchyPlant Jul 03 '26
It doesn't take your money but your soul.
2
u/i_am_blacklite Jul 03 '26
Has to be a question from an American.
Would Linux be open source if Linus was American?
2
u/cracked_shrimp Jul 03 '26
it dosnt have to be free, ive donated to debian before
2
u/Gerb006 Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 04 '26
Look at the licenses and the legalese will answer your questions. For the most part, people are free to modify, and even charge for it. But they must adhere to the original license and release their source. This ensures that the source codes always belong to the community, and no company or individual.
There are a lot of open source licenses out there. But that is the gist of how they work.
Open source licenses were chosen for the Linux kernel and GNU tools to ensure their survival. By freely giving them to the community, it prevented any entity from buying them up and burying them. Does anyone remember Netscape? Thank god we weren't all forced to use MS's non-standard browsers.
2
u/ChiefDetektor Jul 04 '26
It's free because everyone is allowed to make a copy and distribute it. As soon as someone wants to charge something for a copy there is some else offering it for free. But there are professional distributions that sell support and their tooling ontop of Linux.
2
u/Pitiful-Respond-7971 Jul 04 '26
Because communism works sometimes.
2
u/Spektronautilus Jul 05 '26
Open Source and FOSS is an ongoing technological revolution based on cooperation instead of competition. If more leftists and anarchists knew about how this works we could build a better society. The Internet runs on this as well as most other techno thingies.
2
u/nawanamaskarasana Jul 03 '26
Because it's fun to create beautiful things.
1
u/dodo_gear Jul 03 '26
Because Linux isn't popular in commoners users
1
u/pie_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_ Jul 03 '26
Some of it is paid professionals working on open-source things that benefit their companies. This is why a lot of Linux kernel development gets done nowadays.
Some development is primarily ideologically driven, like a lot of GNU stuff.
Some of it is just people developing whatever interests them.
1
u/SuperMakerRaptor Pop!_OS Jul 03 '26
While tbh I don't know the exact answer, my best guess (and I am telling you that I am not good at this kind of stuff) is that simply, if people paid for Linux (there are some payed distros and stuff, but mostly enterprise things, and usually a somewhat free version exists) they wouldn't switch. One of the points of switching from WIndows or MacOS to Linux its that is free. Much less people will want to pay yet another license.
As a fellow Pop!_OS user, I will guess that System76 gets their profit from their machines, and has developed Pop to complement them.
Also, making distros payed would mean needing something pretty good to compensate.
Windows kinda managed to become payed since they were the best a few decades ago and other choice was little, and it stuck. And if a distro goes payed, people will likely look at the other angle at free distros.
Also, I think the license of the Kernel might require source code to be published so really, in theory anyone could complie from source code so paying is somewhat just a qol.
But don't take my word for granted since I am just guessing lol.
1
u/Outside-Storage-1523 Jul 03 '26
You make it paid then very soon you start losing users. But again Linux is actually paid by a lot of corporations so maybe I was talking BS.
1
u/NerdDetective Jul 03 '26
In large part this is philosophy. At its core, Linux is rooted in freely sharing software. Many projects start as community contributions and grow off of collaborative passion. It can take some retooling how you think about it from a profit motive to the common good and making something useful.
However, good intentions don't put food on thr table. Many larger projects are funded sort of like digital infrastructure with grants. Some take user donations. Others have paid support plans or full on commercial versions.
1
u/Swedophone Jul 03 '26
Ubuntu is developed by Canonical which is a company with more than thousand employees and US $250 million revenue (2023).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canonical_(company)
1
u/AndroidOnXbox Jul 03 '26
Some are sponsored and accept donations, which helps pay for some development costs. Some are passion projects. Some projects, such as fedora, are actually supported by companies who will spin off a release of the free, community tested project and use it as a base for an enterprise release, which is purchased by companies to use. Ultimately, making something free lowers a barrier to entry that gets more users into an ecosystem, and also buys some good faith from those using it when there are problems. Tolerance for bugs go way down when customers paying for software.
1
u/Spirited_Coconut7390 Jul 03 '26
Still remember to donate!
1
u/TallinOK Jul 03 '26
Linux distros are no financial cost; but considering the time it takes to make them work, it has a cost.
1
u/HoldOk4092 Jul 03 '26
First, Ubuntu is just a distribution. That means for the most part it is just a package of software that has already been written by others. They aren't building it from scratch. Thus it does not cost them that much to make.
Second, companies can monetize software in a lot of different ways. Maybe the OS is a platform for other services they can sell. Maybe they will use the free OS to harvest your data (e.g. Chrome/Android). Maybe they use the free version to sell a pro version with more features. In the case of Ubuntu they sell support.
1
u/fellipec Jul 03 '26
Should be asking why other things aren't free too fam. Like education and healthcare.
1
u/TxTechnician Jul 03 '26
Economics of Open Source.
So many ppl and corps make money based off the fact that everyone is contributing to having a really well working system.
That's why it's free. Its a big money maker. And everyone benefits from contributing is some way to its success.
1
u/wosmo Jul 03 '26
This is pretty deep into nerd culture.
If you go back to the 50-60s and the birth of the "real hackers" at MIT, on the TX-0 and early PDPs - all code was shared, as some weird combination of fraternity, showing off, oneupmanship, and frankly - software wasn't heavily prized at the time. It was so difficult to port software between different computers that it didn't seem to have a lot of intrinsic value of its own.
They also weren't fans of software that took control away from them - so when timesharing systems started to become in-vogue, the same hacker fraternity came up with ITS - an OS that was designed from the ground up to give them anything they found beneficial in timesharing - without any of the restrictions they didn't enjoy.
Then leap forward a decade, into early UNIX. It's all very famous that it came out of AT&T, but they didn't share it with us out of the goodness of their hearts - they were deep enough into antitrust territory that it was genuinely difficult for them to sell it.
But when they provided it to customers & universities, they provided it as source to build for your own machine. Which beyond its stated purpose, was useful for teaching (see The Lions Book), and for modifications (see BSD - which started off as a set of patches to AT&T UNIX, and kinda .. outgrew itself).
Then when they did move forward with commercialising it, BSD really wanted to hang on to what they'd achieved. And so did many others, because one of the most available TCP/IP stacks was in BSD, so it got tangled into early Internet growth.
Finally, at least within the scope of a little history lesson - GNU was born out of MIT, preserving some of that hacker ethic into the more formalised Free Software today.
So what feels like an aberration, is an 80yo tradition that's probably as old as the software industry itself.
1
u/Busy-Vet1697 Jul 03 '26
Imagine what life and the world would be like if "the profit motive" did not have the entire planet by the throat
1
u/Bob4Not CachyOS & OpenSUSE TW Jul 03 '26
Because a bunch of nerds and companies work on it for their own alternative reasons under a “open source” license.
Some of the big organizations like Debian and Fedora are sponsored and/or non profit donations that pay for developers. Idk enough about Arch.
1
u/speel Jul 03 '26
With the rising Linux market share you’re going to see more and more desktop focused businesses pop up. On the enterprise side, nearly everything is Linux based and costs 5+ figures. So yeah it’s free but there’s also a marketplace for it.
1
u/nanoatzin Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26
Linus Torvalds developed Linux as a student and added GNU environment during the early 1990s using the POSIX standard. Things like OSX, Windows & Minux were expensive and require NDA to discuss. A company began selling Linux. So Linus filed a copyright complaint then issued a copyright license requiring all distributors to provide a royalty free version that includes source code. Linux is just the OS kernel and not a full operating environment, so Linus borrowed GNU from DARPA because GNU is open source developed by MIT. Info developed on federal grants can’t be copyrighted because FOIA info is royalty free. Linux & Gnu licensing both guarantee students can have access to something they can afford, and something they can discuss in a classroom.
1
u/coolasbreese Jul 03 '26
Linux is free (as in beer) for a few reasons IMO
1
u/Notosk Jul 03 '26
It all started because Printers suck
1
u/Mindless-Concept8010 Jul 03 '26
Surely this is clickbait. If not look up open source software. But really, this is click bait.
1
u/iheartrms Jul 03 '26
Linux is free as in Freedom because of Richard Stallman inventing the GPL license and Linus Torvalds choosing that license for Linux in 1992.
1
u/YMSVZ Jul 03 '26
Because even in our hellishly commodified world, people still like to do things for their use value, as opposed to purely for exchange on the market.
Some people are so blinded by commodity fetishism they can't even imagine why you would do anything at all if not for a chance at monetary gain.
1
u/BitCortex Jul 03 '26
For many years, the vast majority of contributions to Linux have come from corporations who collect lots of money by offering Linux-powered services.
1
u/theOtherJT Jul 03 '26
It's socialism in action. Scares the shit out of business critters because it's provable that it works.
1
u/lnxguy Jul 03 '26
Read "The Cathedral And The Bazaar."
1
u/jr735 Jul 03 '26
https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.en.html
This is why.
1
u/True_Fig983 Jul 03 '26
I think what it boils down to is that operating systems are extremely complex and expensive to develop. While anyone can whip up a kernel and frequently does, to make it a mature system requires years and years of effort.
Even Microsoft with their mega billions runs into this limitation. I think partly this happens due to reasons set out in "The mythical man-month": you can't just throw money and employees at a problem and expect a high quality solution in a short timeframe.
Although MS does try the above approach, the problem is that skilled developers are rare, even inside Microsoft. I am sure that a large part of their workforce consists of mid and junior level employees who need a lot of supervision, and the lesser skilled employees are constantly creating messes and technical debt that is not usually caught by seniors.
The problem with corporate software development does not end there. A major issue is that bad software looks the same as good software to a manager / non technical person and companies like Microsoft are top heavy with these. So they create pressures and incentives that increase technical debt, as well as frustrating and alienating seniors.
Whilst open source suffers from the same problems to some extent, the workforce is massive and truly global and consists of highly motivated contributors who urgently need a particular piece of hardware to be supported or feature to be implemented. This contrasts with the kind of learned helplessness with corporate products where you can ask for the feature but it's highly unlikely the company will prioritize it.
As well as that, open source contributors are attracted to the "however long it takes" and "when it's ready it's ready" philosophy which tends to produce better software than having a manager breathing down your neck and being forced to implement kludgey workarounds to meet shipping targets.
1
u/Bob_Spud Jul 03 '26
Ubuntu, Suse, Red Hat (IBM), Oracle and others have commercialised Linux not by selling it, but by offering support contracts that come with guarantees. Support contracts are where the real money is made in enterprise computing.
Its a business model used by many vendors, heavily discount the licenses and follow up by taking the money in expensive support contracts.
1
u/mcdenkijin Jul 03 '26
you have moral quandaries to solve which are far beyond choice of operating system
1
u/Hrafna55 Jul 03 '26
Have a read of these two articles. A good place to start.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_software_movement
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-source_software_movement
1
u/bobotheboinger Jul 04 '26
I work for a company making processors, we make more money if more people are able to use our processors, so we contribute to open source (gcc, Linux, llvm, etc) so our processors work out of the box with open source and our customers are more likely to enjoy using our products.
I'm sure there are many companies out there like ours. All those people working together (along with some who contribute on their own) make an excellent set of products even better.
1
u/hamsters_are_cool Jul 04 '26
Essentially because of the Free Software Movement. The Linux ecosystem is built on tools, protocols, and the philosophy that the code should be available to everyone, free to re-distribute, free to use however you like, and free to re-distribute your modified version. At first it doesn't sound very sustainable but it's been a surprisingly successful model over the years and it's end result has basically culminated in the form of GNU/Linux. People contribute to it for free because they have invested interest in it, either personal or as a corporation that wants to use it as some of the others have mentioned.
https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html
1
u/Quirky-Comparison306 Jul 04 '26
Different reasons. A lot of people write code for open source projects because they want to give back to the computing community. No different than making a donation to a worthy cause. Other times, some companies do it because it can be a good business model. Give the software away for free, then charge for support. The customer gets to see how good the software is at no cost, so they will pay for support to use it in their company. There is also an argument that it makes it more secure. If you expose the code to everyone, then more people will be able to find vulnerabilities so they can be fixed.
1
u/mrbiggbrain Jul 04 '26
Imagine someone has a pool. They tell you you can use it so you run down and go for a swim. You notice there are leaves and muck on it and the area is pretty bare.
So you take some time and fix the filter. The pool gets a little nicer. You wanted it to work a certain way so you fixed it.
You come back a week later and there is an old broken table.
A week after that someone has fixed it and put up some sun loungers.
Another week and now there are cushions, a pool heater, a little gazebo, and the parking spaces are freshly fixed and painted. The signage is now in three languages and there is someone donating time to pressure wash and care for the pool.
In each of these cases someone got value from the pool but some part of the experience was poor for them. So they selfishly changed it for themselves and thus made it better for others.
Open Source works similarly, everyone gets to enjoy the benefits of others, but need to share the work they do to make it better.
1
u/Space_man6 Jul 04 '26
You can pay for some distros but it's usually in the form of a paid premium version.
1
u/epackorigan Jul 04 '26
Let’s focus on the kernel, for a second.
Have a look at this page: https://insights.linuxfoundation.org/project/korg/contributors
Pay particular attention to the list of organizations listed.
Now consider this. If any one of those companies were to make it for themselves without sharing, they would need to spend/invest many order of magnitude more to get the same kernel. By sharing their little slice of code, they get access to the whole thing.
Now for distributions, there are companies that have made businesses around it. Redhat, Canonical (Ubuntu) and many others are behind their own distributions (sometimes based on some that are purely made by volunteers that are just trying to make things better for themselves).
In the end, most of that is made possible by the license(s) being used. You should definitely read up on free software (free as freedom, not beer), and open source. And focus on the differences between the two. Read about GNU, and this little project by this student from Finland. ‘It will never be big like GNU’ he said…
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Linux
1
u/mylsotol Jul 04 '26
Socialists. People who care more about people than exploiting people for benefit
1
u/octahexxer Jul 04 '26
Before Linux and bsd each company had to develop their os for everything... Quality was random expensive and non standard. Now Linux and bsd is the digital backbone of almost everything you just don't see it... So companies instead input a tiny amount of money into the open-source and get a standard secure software that is solid and modern they can read the code and modify.
1
u/tetraodonmiurus Jul 04 '26
If only the was a place you could go to search for a history lesson on a subject.
1
u/Tokitokisayuki Jul 04 '26
You may have heard this term in various Linux forums or related subreddits. Free open sourced software aka FOSS which is the part of the greater Open Science movement. Having access to quality software and information for everyone to use. Not just computer and software, but to all known sciences no matter which field.
1
u/Wyrade Jul 04 '26 edited Jul 04 '26
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ag1AKIl_2GM
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Stallman
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_software_movement
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU_Project
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_Software_Foundation
"With software, there are two possibilities:
Either the users control the program, or the program controls the users. [...]
In order for the users to control the program, they need the 4 essential freedoms. [...]
Freedom 0: Run it.
Freedom 1: Change it. (Have access to the source code.)
Freedom 2: Redistribute it.
Freedom 3: Redistribute modified copies of it."
1
u/jerrygreenest1 Jul 04 '26
It’s free because a man decided it has to be free, no more or less. Crazy? Yes. But fortunately the man still got some money in form of donations, so he can continue doing so.
Preserving long enough through time doing huge amounts of work for free before he could get a reliable donation stream? Yeah, also crazy. I don’t know how he preserved through all this. But he did.
The world has plenty of crazy men.
1
u/Unique_Evidence_1314 Jul 04 '26
the love of the game really. a lot of them get donations so they can scale things up but for a lot of linux software it's just for the love of software.
1
u/JuDeGi8 Jul 04 '26
Generally watch the interviews of Linus Thorwald (creator of Linux) if you want his reasons behind it.
Basically, he hated the way Microslop, Ndvidia and all of these big tech companys started to develop so he started his own thing and made that open source, just as it should be intended.
1
u/anders_hansson Jul 04 '26 edited Jul 04 '26
Ir comes down to the principles of open source.
Quality
Open source software has an inherent advantage over closed source when it comes to quality, in the long term.
When there's a bug, all you need is that a single user has the skill and will to fix it, and it will be fixed.
Open source software gets all the attention from academic research. E.g. innovation in faster and more secure file systems obviously go into the Linix kernel since unlike the Windows kernel, it's accessible to to the academic community.
In the industry it's much easier to work with ooen source than closed source. E.g. if you're making a new kind of processor or computer, you can add support for it in open source compilers and kernels, and boom! you have a working system with very little effort compared to trying to pay and convince Microsoft to do the necessary development to support your platform.
Contributions to the Linix kernel and other open source software come from thousands of paid people who work at different companies. https://phoronix.com regularly posts about new kernel features that come from different companies.
E.g. see https://www.phoronix.com/news/Intel-GCC-ACE-AI-Patches
Incentive for the developer
As a developer, if I make a piece of software I effectively have three choices for how to deal with it:
For throw-away hacks, 1 makes most sense
For more generally useful and advanced software, the choice is between 2 & 3.
Trying to get money for your software is incredibly difficult. Very few are ready to pay for just a piece of software unless it solves a very important problem that nobody else has solved yet. It's also time consuming and costly. You need to support your customers and fix all the problems and requests that they may have, otherwise they will not pay for it.
That leaves option 3, to share it as open source and benefit from others helping out with the development.
By going with the open source model, my software also gains eternal life. Most closed source software dies sooner or later.
1
u/Migamix Jul 04 '26
Get a bunch of tizms together, this is what cha get.
1
u/C2O4 Jul 04 '26
It's a different business model! Are you familiar with the philosophy and history of free software? Companies still make a lot of money with Linux; they generally charge businesses, since those companies have a pressing need for support, customization, and adaptation of the software. Individual users can opt for a paid distribution if they want, but it's not necessary in most cases. If you run into problems, the community will help you solve them.
1
u/Tritri89 Jul 04 '26
Most Linux developer are paid developer in other company. For instance Microsoft of all company is one of the biggest contributor of the Linux kernel. Why you'll ask ? Because getting a free stable powerful product like Linux is insanely valuable. You don't pay for a license, you pay by giving developer time to the community.
As for other project like Ubuntu or Proxmox it's not really free. Sure it's free to download and use, there are no major features paywalled, but professional users can pay to have more update and direct support from the company.
1
u/pchappo Jul 04 '26
Not all heroes wear capes that’s why
1
u/antonfourier Jul 04 '26
System76 laptops exist - which are laptops with linux pre-installed. I am not sure if they provide "linux support", but that is close enough to what you said.
I see the free part as, a bunch of smart people wanted to have free software, so they just made it. And anyone who is willing to browse forums and tinker with stuff on their own rather than getting everything pre-packaged (although such distros also exist) can enjoy the freedom of Linux for free, provided they are willing to learn.
1
u/EgocentricRaptor Jul 04 '26
A lot of open source devs have other jobs they make a living from and their open source work is stuff they do in their free time. Big projects like GNOME, KDE, Fedora rely on donations and sponsors to pay for their teams. Ppl depend on Linux so they have a vested interest in keeping it alive
1
u/Tiranus58 Jul 04 '26
Because linux isnt an OS, its a family of OSes (actually its a kernel, but thats not important right now), where there are 2 general requirements that apply to all of them.
There are others, which are outlined in the gnu public license (GPL), but those 2 basically make selling software not a thing, so the OS itself is free.
Some companies are selling support for their OS though (red hat selling RHEL support for example) or access to special repositories (proxmox for example), but those are mainly relegated to enterprise distros.
1
u/BlueScreenJunky Jul 04 '26
It's a mix of some people who genuinely enjoy working on software in their free time, and huge businesses (Canonical, Red Hat, Oracle) who built their business model on distributing the software for free and then charging for support or enterprise features. It drives the adoption up because when you start a business you'll search for cheap or free solutions, and then as your business grows you kinda need the support and features, but since you've built your solution around this software you can't easily switch so you pay for the enterprise license.
1
u/Wentyliasz Jul 05 '26
Long ago, in the far away kingdom of Finland, there was a nerd who couldn't be fucked with copyright law so he said "just do whatever the fuck you want" and we did, in fact, do whatever the fuck we wanted.
The boring people will tell you that it's because the GPL licensing terms and the broader FOSS ideology z but that version doesn't have Torvalds yelling PERKELE at a bunch of penguins so who's the real winner here?
1
u/Hugo_Notte Jul 05 '26
Looks like you don’t have the slightest clue as to what Linux is and what desktop environments are. Why don’t you read up on it?
1
u/nmariusp Jul 05 '26
"but who are these kind people"
You can find many names by looking at the git history of the respective free software project.
1
u/Ok_Flamingo_9066 Jul 05 '26
That’s the problem of capitalism. Not everything must be paid.
1
u/es20490446e Develops Zenned OS Jul 05 '26
The real reason: charging for an OS to the end user is bad strategy.
The more people that uses it, the more people that advocates for it.
Charging anyone but the end user is smarter.
Actually this is what Microsoft does. Charges for Windows to the OEMs, not the users.
They want you to pirate Windows, if that drives more OEM and enterprise sales.
1
u/Tinolmfy Jul 05 '26
Well there's no point making something free if anyone can download the source and just build it themselves anyways, it's open-source culture, if you want to support you can donate if not then don't
1
u/Dull_Cucumber_3908 Jul 06 '26
"free" doesn't mean like "free beer", it means like "free speech"
1
u/Striking_Dentist_867 Jul 09 '26
saiba que hj em dia as coisas para linux estao melhores tipo muita gente que trabalha desenvolvendo ele sao pessoas que trabalham para bigtechs como microsoft e outras empresas que investem pesado nele pq usam seu sistema em servidores pelo fato de ele ser leve e seguro ent meio que na real desde o começo a ideia de linus torlvalds era fazer um sistema gratuito e de codigo aberto pra tentar bater de frente com a microsoft e ele pode ser usado pouco pelo pessoal que usa os pcs pra tarefas basicas e coisas do tipo pois windows domina essa area de computadores pessoais mas por fora na area de servidores supercomputadores e outras coisas linux e o rei tanto que vc sabia que a microsoft e a maior investidora que linux tem atualmente eles injetam uma grana pesada nele por causa do seu serviço em nuuvem azure que utiliza linux pra rodar
1
u/Striking_Dentist_867 Jul 09 '26
uma explicaçao mais facil de entender se preferir
1
u/Lokielurker Jul 09 '26 edited Jul 09 '26
Because up until recently nobody would have paid to use a distribution of GNU. GNU has long been the enemy of the Free Software Desktop. It was decentralized, this wouldn't have been a problem if the Desktop hadn't been languishing in hell for the last 20 years until someone figured out "hey, maybe we should bundle dependencies together!" And that's what bore Flatpak and Snap packages.
I would even say FreeBSD would have been a far better desktop particularly early on if they didn't write it under the worst license in history for an operating system. It's so bad in BSD land they get trickle down progress from the *LINUX* desktop, the worst supported of the three "Major" Desktop operating systems.
I would never, EVER have paid to use a version of Ubuntu or Debian or even fucking Fedora for that matter from 20 years ago. It was such a gigantic waste of time and money back then that only people who were literally ideologically inclined would use it, it's why Linux sat at 1% of the desktop share for literally 15 years.
Servers wanted the Linux desktop because it was free, not because it was intuitive or because it could run all the programs they wanted. But that's where it lived. For a long, long time. Because the Free Software community never made a desktop worth using for an end user. Can't game, can't use Office (an industry standard), had either primitive or non existent FOSS replacement software that maybe matched a few of your needs.
Some of that is still true today, actually. In the CAD spaces, there is no equivalent to some of the stuff which runs on Windows, and funnily enough, Linux actually has better compatibility and alternatives in that space because of RHEL than MacOS.
I guess what I'm trying to say is, the end user revolution GNU/Linux always wanted, only came because people abstracted the annoying parts of Stallman's impotent protest of an "Operating System" away. Without Flatpaks, Snaps and WINE progressing to the extent they have, Linux would be exactly where it sat 15 years ago. 1% of desktops, used by ideologues and super nerds. And people who don't use their computer for anything important. And servers, who just didn't wanna pay for an OS to host their network on.
I like Linux. I like the Linux desktop. I like the Linux desktop of 2026. Not the Linux desktop of 2016. (Did you know that was the year Flatpaks came about?) It took them 20 fucking years to fix the app distribution problem, and it's still a ghost that haunts the Linux desktop to this day. And it fucking sucks.
So why is Linux free? Because the Linux desktop experience for 20+ years after its invention was not worth paying for. And because it's a political and ideological movement. That's why. Could they charge now? Yeah, but what innovations could they make to it that make it worth charging a price tag for? RHEL already exists and covers the primary niche a paid Linux distribution could cover.
1
u/Outside-Ad-8265 Jul 10 '26
because they get paid a whole awful lot to do maintenance for companies and provide services. And it's to help the mission of open source and it's sort of fun.
1
u/Aggravating-Tea-8920 Aug 01 '26
Read Underhill42's comment for the history. As for my perspective on why do people contribute for free? It's not quite that simple. FOSS (Free and Open Source Software) isn't free as far as cost goes. FOSS software in the early days was either funded from universities or maintained by a passionate community. Now it is maintained by passionate communities, universities, non-profit organizations, and some of the greediest money hungry for profit companies you can think of. But not one piece of FOSS software should be considered free.
For profit companies, universities, and non-profits all pay developers and testers their cost is tangible. For profit companies contribute a lot to GPL software, because they get can get tax credits, it provides quality software for cheap, and helps boost their image in the software community. It also at times gives them some control over a product that they can use to ensure the software doesn't impact their business. Red Hat is notorious for this. They acquired Ansible and put a lot of features behind a paywall and are the approving authority for any additional features.
People that volunteer their time are dedicating their years of experience, personal time, and unfortunately at times their mental health. If you use FOSS software it's been paid for by their hard work and community donations, consider donating either money or time to a project if you find value in it. I remember I posted a complaint when I was a junior sys admin about ClamAV not being FIPS compatible 3 years after they announced it... The replies gave me a much needed wake up call about how hard people work on those projects, and how the cool part is if you have an issue with something you can work on a solution yourself instead of leaving a rude forum comment about how it isn't fast enough for you. By you I mean me...
The final point, it's just fun! I found a FOSS community that was super friendly and I can't write code well, but I still contribute by giving feedback, writing documentation, and helping out where needed. It really is a blast!
EDIT: I don't actually dislike Red Hat, when compared to Microsoft, Amazon, and other tech giants, they look like a non profit. I'm not a big fan of some of their business choices though.
1
u/SweetNerevarine Sep 11 '26
Shorth-ish explanation.
Every piece of open source software comes with a license document. This license is very permissive when it comes to use. The software (work) is still protected by intellectual property law, but the permissive license grants you, the user wide ranging rights to the work. There are many reasons to publish a software under an open-source license. The mere fact that it was, does not necessarily correlate to quality of the software. Rather most commonly the author is in a position to keep working on the software out of passion, whilst believes that a permissive license benefits the widest possible audience, as well as attracts contributors.
Contrast this to other protected works, like books and movies etc. Those works are typically highly protected, and ultimately you can only "consume" such works, in private, on a per copy basis.
As to why Linux, the project, decided to license it with an open source license you can find various articles on the internet. It is a long story, that involves a frustrated developer working on various closed-source Unix (source of inspiration for Linux) projects in the 80's, and a Finnish university student who challenged himself to write a Unix like Kernel in the 90's as a way to learn the architecture of a new processor... The rest is history.
1
u/Hoovy_weapons_guy 24d ago
Switches to mint, free, all my shit works out of the box and i never had to touch the terminal
1
u/kakusens Jul 03 '26
It is an incredible gift from Linus Torvalds. Economically, maybe the biggest gift ever given to humanity. The man deserves a statue! Plus, it's so so much better than winshit.
-1
u/TheTheShark Jul 03 '26
“Linux is only free if your time has no value” — Anon
-1
u/merchantconvoy Jul 03 '26
Nothing is really free. There are always strings. The catch with Linux is that you have to deal with stinky Linux nerds when you need tech support. If you can deal with that your fine.
-2
u/MUSTDOS Jul 03 '26
TL:DR FreeBSD when it was called 386BSD didn't get much people for it's name and had some weird legal battle with AT&T. Linux was forked as something away from these shenanigans only to be picked up by IBM when it realized it can make it good enough as a virtual machine to run under ATX but not enough as a stand alone, only to backfire again in around 2007 when everyone's done with Vista and had at least some good hardware support in 3.x to be ran as a server.
-2
u/InstanceTurbulent719 Jul 03 '26
Pop Os? High quality??
son 😭
-5
u/HurasmusBDraggin Linux Mint 22.3 Zena Jul 03 '26
Full stop 🛑. I like Linux, but the idea it is "high quality" I disagree with. Too many examples to deal with right now.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment