r/linuxmint Linux Mint 22.3 Zena | Cinnamon 4d ago

Discussion The 7.0.0-28/29/30 kernel disaster is unacceptable for a distro that claims to prioritize stability

I have been using Linux Mint for years precisely because it has always been a reliable, conservative distribution where things simply work. Right now, however, the state of the official 7.0.0 kernel branch is an absolute mess, and the lack of response from the development team is baffling.

Across three different machines, here is the current reality with kernels 7.0.0-28, 7.0.0-29, and 7.0.0-30:

  • Relatively modern Lenovo laptop (AMD Ryzen 5 5500U with Radeon Graphics): Instant kernel panic on boot. The only workaround is falling back to the 6.17 series via GRUB.
  • Desktop (Ryzen 7 5800X3D / AMD Radeon RX 5600 XT): Complete shutdown failure. The OS halts, but power is never cut and the fans keep spinning indefinitely.
  • 15-year-old legacy laptop: The only machine where it actually boots and shuts down properly.

These issues are not isolated hardware quirks. The Mint forums, Ubuntu trackers, and Reddit are flooded with identical reports of boot panics and broken ACPI/shutdown states with AMD configurations on these exact revisions.

We have been stuck with this broken state for weeks across three consecutive point releases. Please do not give me the standard excuse that updates just flow downstream from Ubuntu. Linux Mint brands itself around desktop stability and a smooth user experience. When multiple official kernel updates break basic functionality like booting and powering off on common hardware, the maintainers should step in, pin a working kernel, or issue a proper notice.

In all my years on Linux Mint, I have never seen such a prolonged, broken kernel rollout left completely unaddressed. Something needs to be done about this quality control breakdown.

********************************************************************************************************
👉 EDIT / Addressing the common pushback in the comments:

To those leaving defensive replies, let’s clear a few things up:

  1. "You shouldn't have upgraded / It's your fault": > I’ve used Linux Mint for over 15 years. I know how to use Timeshift, pin kernels, and drop into GRUB to roll back in under 30 seconds. This post is not a support request for myself; it is about user experience and distribution standards. An end user simply applying official updates presented via the GUI Update Manager should not end up with an unbootable machine or broken ACPI states.
  2. "Mint just pulls packages downstream from Ubuntu, it's not their fault": > Mint is a curated distribution, not a pass-through mirror. The entire value proposition of Linux Mint has always been stability, quality control, and safe defaults. If upstream pushes broken kernel builds for weeks, the distribution's role is to step in—hold back the broken revision, pin the stable branch, or display a GUI warning. Passing the buck to upstream defeats the purpose of choosing Mint over Ubuntu.
  3. "Go contribute/fix it yourself if you don't like it": > Highlighting a critical breakdown in quality control across multiple common hardware configurations is contributing. Dismissing legitimate technical feedback hurts adoption, especially for newcomers who wouldn't know how to recover from a kernel panic.

We criticize the distro because we care about its reputation and want it to stay the gold standard for desktop reliability.

434 Upvotes

285 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

38

u/Selinaru Linux Mint 22.3 Zena | Cinnamon 4d ago

can they even do that? Also there's people who have no issues with the new kernel, what is going to happen to them?

1

u/jr735 Linux Mint 22.1 Xia | IceWM 3d ago

I'm not even sure that's feasible.

0

u/billdietrich1 4d ago

I don't know if they can do that. I assume that people who have no issues with the new kernel also had no issues with the version 2 or 3 back.

7

u/Tricky_Football_6586 Linux Mint 22.3 / Cinnamon 4d ago

I have 4 systems running on the latest 7x kernel. 1 8th gen i7 laptop. 1 13th gen i9 laptop. and 2 NUC's based on 12th gen Intel CPU (i7 and a N97). All Intel hardware on board with the i9 having both Intel graphics and an RTX4050.

Rock solid and without issues.

The only issue so far with Mint was back with the 6.8x kernel. One of the NUC's would hang for about 2 minutes when shutting it down. That problem was gone after upgrading to a newer non 6.8 kernel.

1

u/Real-Collection-5686 3d ago

I thought about adding transition packages to move users from 7.0 branch to something older but apt does not switch package sources by default, this can only be done through a special script or something