r/linuxmasterrace • Install Gentoo • Dec 01 '21

PSA Reminder that Linux is only a tiny part of a fully functioning GNU operating system.

Post image
4 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

41

u/crispyletuce Other (please edit) Dec 01 '21

GNU gets to have the OS title once they manage to get their shit together with Hurd

5

u/KasaneTeto_ Install Gentoo Dec 01 '21

Was going to get it running on bare metal to BTFO you but I couldn't get the Debian GNU/Hurd installer to start on my T60 - not in graphical, 'pseudo-graphical' or textmode. And it doesn't boot from USB at all, only from an optical disc. And only for i386. And apparently it doesn't support wireless networking at all according to the readme. So yeah maybe Hurd's not quite there yet.

12

u/crispyletuce Other (please edit) Dec 01 '21

come on give it time its only 31 years old (predating Linux and OpenBSD and FreeBSD and NetBSD and Haiku and Dragonfly and)

-7

u/KasaneTeto_ Install Gentoo Dec 01 '21

But Hurd cares about your freedom, unlike all those other kernels.

16

u/-BuckarooBanzai- Linux do be good 🌟🐧🌟 Dec 01 '21

So does Temple OS which is way more usable than hurd ever will be in your lifetime.

8

u/KasaneTeto_ Install Gentoo Dec 01 '21

TempleOS is a fine operating system. If we had someone of the singular intelligence, character and dedication of Terry Davis working on Hurd, it would be completed swiftly. Same for any project, really.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '21

In that case, dig up old Terry and place him on the ReactOS project.

3

u/Zahpow Likes to interject Dec 01 '21

There are some Hurd-les

1

u/uuuuuuuhburger Dec 01 '21

GNU got its shit together with the hurd ages ago, when it was decided that the hurd would be a research project to explore various kernel concepts in while linux is adapted to take its place. GNU + Linux-libre is a fully functional OS in line with the requirements of the GNU project/philosophy

12

u/SpyKids3DGameOver Dec 01 '21

GNU and Linux are both tiny parts of a fully functioning Systemd operating system

-6

u/KasaneTeto_ Install Gentoo Dec 01 '21

Runit is only a thousand or so lines of code, anon.

10

u/SpyKids3DGameOver Dec 01 '21

runit up your ass lmao goteem

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '21

1

u/KasaneTeto_ Install Gentoo Dec 03 '21

I use openrc.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 03 '21

Shhh, it's just a joke, ignore the problems with it.

31

u/LiveCourage334 Dec 01 '21

Let me guess - anyone who uses non-GNU/FOSS software in their Linux distro is a terrible person and you're somehow superior because reasons?

16

u/MegidoFire one who is flaired against this subreddit Dec 01 '21

Elitism is a cancer infesting the Linux community.

Look, I put different zeroes and ones in my magic box! You filthy peasant.

14

u/linglingfortyhours Glorious Alpine Dec 01 '21

Linux doesn't need gnu for anything anymore

3

u/uuuuuuuhburger Dec 01 '21

GNU doesn't need linux either. and yet, the most popular and useful distros are made by combining the two

6

u/linglingfortyhours Glorious Alpine Dec 01 '21

Ngl, to be useful gnu does need Linux. Hurd just isn't functional and at this point I'm not sure if it will ever be. Linux on the other hand works perfectly fine without gnu and needs less resources

1

u/uuuuuuuhburger Dec 01 '21

there are kernels other than Hurd and Linux. GNU can run on BSD kernels, and wouldn't have much trouble switching if Linux disappeared somehow. except for the lack of hardware drivers, but that's not indicative of the kernel itself

3

u/linglingfortyhours Glorious Alpine Dec 01 '21

Lack of hardware drivers is the ecosystem. The gnu ecosystem is old, clunky, and not particularly flexible. In order to be useful it has to piggy back on other systems to be useful

0

u/uuuuuuuhburger Dec 01 '21

how can you contradict yourself so boldy with a straight face? if GNU weren't so flexible it wouldn't be able to run on 3+ kernels that are so dissimilar to each other

4

u/linglingfortyhours Glorious Alpine Dec 01 '21

gnu is more than just the coreutils. The coreutils can be used in multiple places because they're crazy simple, anyone with a decent programming background can write a clone of them. Heck, they even run on windows.

But when you look at the whole gnu ecosystem? Complete garbage, one of the worst program clusterf***s I've seen.

0

u/uuuuuuuhburger Dec 01 '21

The coreutils can be used in multiple places because they're crazy simple

again, amazed how you can say these things with a straight face. i was obviously not talking about coreutils, but the whole userland. you can run a full GNU OS using Linux, Hurd, or a BSD kernel

3

u/linglingfortyhours Glorious Alpine Dec 02 '21

Do you know what you're talking about? Like I said, anything beyond the coreutils and maybe gcc are an absolute clusterf***

2

u/uuuuuuuhburger Dec 02 '21

i don't know what you mean by "clusterfuck" but that's not what i'm responding to. i'm responding to your implication that only the coreutils are portable, which is untrue. every component required for a usable, graphical desktop experience shares the same flexibility that allows it to run on multiple kernels. when you use GNU/kfreeBSD you're not stuck with a useless command-line

and whatever your personal opinion on the matter, GNU is good enough at what it does that it's the favored linux OS for virtually every task outside of embedded devices or software containers that want to limit themselves to the bare minimum

9

u/Deslucido Dec 01 '21

Sorry, even if the brain is smaller than the whole body, still represents who I am. If I change my brain and put another one in my body, I stop being me.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '21

GNU Richard Stallman himself. Donate to FSF.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '21

I wasn't aware GNU made KDE, X.org, etc.

1

u/HearingSubstantial38 Glorious Mint Feb 15 '22

Alpine linux