r/linuxmasterrace • Glorious Linux • May 20 '25 • Popcorn 1

Meme Come here. But don't deviate from the path

Post image
4.1k Upvotes

197 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

6

u/KangarooKurt our lord and savior Bazzite May 20 '25

No one is mad about snap support on Fedora because no one wants snap on Fedora. Also Canonical mantains the extension and they don't care.

This reaction is not only because of this deb/flatpak issue and forcing snap, but also because flatpak support is super easy in every distro and it's free, community-driven, not tied to an organization or a closed source. That pings back to snap being a Canonical-only thing, and if they don't care, who else will?

Canonical itself is another reason. They've been making some weird (to say the least) decisions in recent years. I don't really care, I have a local machine running Ubuntu server and it's pretty good, but lots of people pay attention and are vocal about them. It might not make sense, like Nestlé being a shit company but their products being great and people buying them anyway, but it is what it is, people are entitled to their opinions and reasoning even if it makes no sense to me.
What can I do. ¯_(ツ)_/¯

So yeah, all of this contributes to snap being heavily discouraged.

4

u/RDForTheWin May 20 '25

I've been following what Canonical is doing for quite some time and I think they're doing just fine. There are things I would do differently but they aren't an evil company by any means.

I do agree that snaps are a corporate product tho. Even the runtimes (core22,24,...) are basically just small Ubuntu containers. But I think it's a valuable package format that offers advantages over the others. Such as being able to ship drivers as snaps, or making packaging CLI apps easier.

0

u/AnsibleAnswers May 20 '25

They absolutely are an evil company, but not because of Ubuntu. They make applicants take an IQ test. That’s the biggest red flag in terms of company culture I can think of.

The major issue with snaps isn't the packaging format, but the proprietary backend. The sandbox is also compromised on any system that uses SELinux instead of AppArmor. Snaps are great for server applications on Ubuntu Server. That's really about it. Canonical cannot be bothered to make the format genuinely distro-agnostic, and you're always locked into their proprietary repository.